3 ms·
German Payment Outage Underscores Danger of Cashless Economy: System Fragility
- JPLeRouzic 4y ago"But some IT experts have pointed to a different possible cause: an expiring security certificate. The problem, it seems, is that the Verifone H5000 is a rather old albeit robust model whose so-called “End of Life” was officially announced by Verifone in 2019. " ... "That is the hypothesis of Jan Wildeboer, a self-described “EMEA Evengelist” at IBM-owned Red Hat who began informing the English-speaking public about the issue in a rapidly expanding Twitter thread." https://jan.wildeboer.net/2022/06/H5000 https://jan.wildeboer.net/2022/06/H5000
- DemocracyFTW2 4y agoFragility is also what happens to you when you rip out a decentralized, grown and proven-to-work, decades-old system like railroad signalling and replace it with a centralized digital system. Or when you think it's a good idea to make public water supply plants accessible over the internet. This we're yet to learn the hard way, I'm afraid.
- 0dayz 4y agoFor your first example it's more a matter of architecture than technology.
- DemocracyFTW2 4y agoSure, in so far as you can architecture your signalling network in a more or less centralized fashion. However, the systems that we e.g. in Germany used to have used a lot of different technologies like taught wires that would physically move signals, locally working operators in distributed signal boxes connected with a dedicated pre-digital telephone network and so on. This system simply did not have a single point of failure that you could attack over the internet from thousands of miles away. Even a Carrington-event level CME would not have taken out the entirety of the system, even after much of it went electric, then electromechanical and electronic. What they now do is they rip out all of the old technology and replace everything with digital equipment; Siemens for one will build a single central signal box for the entire Norwegian railway system[1]; they do not say in the linked article whether that system will have a gateway to the public internet, but locally at least it will use ethernet (via fiber in the case of a German pilot) to get rid of heavy 380V copper cables. So yeah, "more a matter of architecture" but still totally what they're aiming for, a single control station for the railway network of an entire (not-so-small) country, a.k.a. single point of failure. [1] https://new.siemens.com/de/de/unternehmen/stories/forschung-technologien/folder-future-living/freie-fahrt-zum-internet-der-eisenbahn.html https://new.siemens.com/de/de/unternehmen/stories/forschung-...
- sschueller 4y agoOr drive passenger cars through a tunnel without any emergency exists instead of building a proper proven subway...
- noneeeed 4y agoOn a personal level, this is why I always have a bit of cash on me. I have a couple of notes in my wallet, and one off those cash capsules on my key ring. I can and do pay using my phone but I always have real cards with me. I probably sound a bit paranoid to some people, but I’ve had enough situations where somewhere couldn’t or didn’t take card, or my phone was low on power that it just seems sensible to have backups.
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> I probably sound a bit paranoid to some people, but I’ve had enough situations where somewhere couldn’t or didn’t take card, or my phone was low on power that it just seems sensible to have backups. It's not paranoid at all, it's just an understanding of the situation better than most; I do fintech and I'm still a proponent of cash for the reasons alluded to in this article and your response are just sound preventive measures. People like to think everything works under ideal conditions so longs as things will remain as such there is no reason to not prune back-up systems. This is a very common mistake. To take it further I think that cash itself will always have (some) value in Society, their is a reason the USD/EUR fills the gap between collapsing economies. It's a trust based system, and I have many critiques about it, but one cannot dispute it on sheer utilitarian terms. My thoughts on this could be a series of essays, but the short answer is that countries that eliminate currency are setting themselves up for failures, just look at how common downtime/outages is for most used platforms and how prevalent hacks are from some of the biggest retailers. We suck at security, and are even worse at it at scale: forgery is a thing, but it's minuscule when taken into account of the totality of economic activity it produces.
- Semaphor 4y ago> It was as if parts of Germany’s payment system had just travelled through a wormhole back to the 1990’s I guess the author has not had much experience with Germany? It’s more like the 2000s or even the early 2010s. Only the combination of covid, some pro-cashless regulations and SumUp (cheap card readers, standalone or phone-attachments) made it possibly to forego always carrying cash for me.
- mrkramer 4y agoDecentralized payment processors are the solution e.g. Bitcoin.
- atoav 4y agoThis was a problem caused by not updating the firmware on the scanning devices at the stores. If you have a centralized store with decentralized trust (blockchain) or a conglomerate of banks in the back does not fix the problem of missing firmware updates. Yeah, in theory with bitcoin anybody could implement their own device. In practise you would have the precisely same outcome.