2 ms·
I agree that he has an impressive resume, but I believe the parent's point is still valid: live-coding compiler work doesn't make someone magically faultless.
by kelnos 4y ago
I agree that he has an impressive resume, but I believe the parent's point is still valid: live-coding compiler work doesn't make someone magically faultless. Everyone has their blind spots.
If Jonathan Blow truly does believe that there are "perfect" programmers who never, ever need runtimes that do bounds checking (and other useful things)[0], then that is a huge blind spot. Maybe these unicorns exist, but they are just that: incredibly, vanishingly rare. And Blow certainly isn't one of those people; I've played both Braid and The Witness, and I've seen them both crash (in game code, not in a linked platform library). They're amazing, beautiful games, but that doesn't make their author above criticism.
> ... but you’ve kind of signed up for a little of this: what the fuck is your CV?
Valid criticism/skepticism need not turn into a dick-measuring contest. Trying to invalidate someone's opinion by asking for their credentials is logically fallacious. Please don't do this sort of thing here.
Also not sure where all the anger is coming from. Why do you feel such a personal stake in Jonathan Blow's reputation as some sort of infallible coding god?
[0] Not saying that I know for a fact that he does believe this; I'm just going by OP's article, which could easily be wrong or at least exaggerated.