4 ms·
Plot twist: it's always the driver's fault. Autopilot is glorified cruise control (the technical term is 'Level 2' on the SAE scale). It literally doesn't mat
by zozbot234 4y ago
Plot twist: it's always the driver's fault. Autopilot is glorified cruise control (the technical term is 'Level 2' on the SAE scale). It literally doesn't matter when Autopilot bails out altogether (even if it manages to automatically avert a crash on other occasions), the driver must be fully in control at all times. Would you trust your cruise control to prevent a collision? Of course not, that would be crazy. It's not what it's built for. What a worthless discussion.
- legalcorrection 4y agoThe problem is that people can’t actually take over fast enough necessarily. If you’re not actively driving, then you can’t just immediately react.
- epgui 4y agoThe NHTSA report says that on average, an attentive driver would have been able to react 8 seconds before the crash. 8 seconds is a lot of time on the highway (where autopilot can be used).
- freeflight 4y agoYet the autopilot system chose to only warn the drivers 1 second before impact, which is basically no time at all to react to anything. So if those 8 seconds of "autopilot ain't too sure" actually exist, then the car needs to signal that to the driver so the driver can be ready to take over. The fact it still doesn't do that, speaks volumes about the kind of "progress" Tesla seems to be making, none of it good.
- zozbot234 4y agoThe crashes were not of a kind that Autopilot could have detected earlier. Several involved stationary objects, that Autopilot seems to intentionally ignore because it can't tell apart what's actually in the way of the car from harmless features of the surroundings that will never cause a collision. Which just goes to prove: Autopilot = glorified cruise control. You must never expect it to keep you safe.
- chrisseaton 4y ago> Autopilot = glorified cruise control Isn't that what the name implies? An autopilot keeps heading and speed.
- zozbot234 4y agoSure, but what does that have to do with Autopilot? "Driver gets into a crash because they were spaced out and not actually paying attention to the road" is something that happens all the time, no need for modern ADAS.
- epgui 4y agoExactly, the most important metric/question is whether it improves overall safety compared to the baseline.
- wolverine876 4y agoThat's the metric Tesla and the self-driving car industry would like to use, but I don't see why it's the most important. Also, it misconstrues 'most important' to mean 'all that's important'. We could just ban personal vehicles to improve overall safety.
- Spivak 4y agoBecause “drivers space out when using a system that removes the stimulus of driving that keeps them alert” is not solely the fault of the individual when it’s not possible in real world scenarios to use it safely.
- googlryas 4y agoBut you're supposed to be actively driving with autopilot. I use autopilot every now and then, and when I do, I literally keep my hands on the wheel in a driving position, and my foot resting lightly on the pedal.
- legalcorrection 4y agoYou by definition can’t be actively driving. You’re just watching. It’s active driving that keeps you alert in the first place.
- ulfw 4y agoThen what are you going from Autopilot? How's foot hovering any more comfortable than lightly putting it down? How is hands on wheel in a driving position more comfortable than occasionally turning the wheel? Seems a tiny gain compared to the dangers of the system.
- googlryas 4y agoVery late reply but...what I gain is basically nitpicky adjustments to lane and speed control. I'm extremely active in the sense that I am constantly observing near, medium, and far distances while driving, but I'm just not providing minor steering inputs directly. I think that I can better observe the conditions if I'm not providing those controls, even though I need to keep a model of autopilot and its abilities running in my head. Having said that, that model is simple - dump out of autopilot as soon as there is any kind of complexity added to the environment.
- Sakos 4y agoIt seems so weird to me how people so vehemently defend Tesla instead of holding them to higher standards. What do you owe them and why?
- abawany 4y agoSome might also be defending their stock portfolios, 401ks, and future tesla purchases built on tsla price appreciations.
- smokey_circles 4y agoWell when you wrap your identity around someone else's idea, you get weird outputs at the edge cases
- robonerd 4y ago> the driver must be fully in control at all times Yes, that's precisely what the manual said last time I checked. But it's not how Elon Musk has presented it, nor how innumerable Tesla drivers treat it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cma 4y agoTesla say in the video here the driver is only there because of regulators, not ethical reasons: https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot This video was from 2018 or so I think and they pretended the driver wasn't needed.
- lawn 4y agoThe whole concept is flawed. We cannot expect humans to be able to pay attention and be able to take over at a moment's notice at all times, simply because that's not how our brains work. Autopilot is in the danger zone, where it's good enough to make your brain relax, but it's bad enough to require your brain to not do that. So it's fundamentally unsafe. Cruise control in contrast isn't good enough so your brain will have to pay attention, otherwise you'll crash very quickly. And this is all made much, much worse by Elon's and Tesla's irresponsible marketing, and the believers who dismiss this as a "worthless discussion".
- zozbot234 4y ago> We cannot expect humans to be able to pay attention and be able to take over at a moment's notice at all times And yet, this is what ordinary driving requires already. It's not a new requirement. The whole point of this investigation is to figure out the matter of whether a SAE Level 2 ADAS really makes distracted driving more likely. The jury is still out on that, and even if it does it would be reasonably easy to cope with the problem by tuning the system to alert the driver more frequently, especially ahead of impending danger (such as in low visibility conditions, which are expressly mentioned as a key factor in these crashes).
- rad_gruchalski 4y ago> We cannot expect humans to be able to pay attention and be able to take over at a moment's notice at all times, simply because that's not how our brains work. Plus, it will always give you the control back in the most difficult situation you can ever encounter as a driver. It's already an emergency, the computer threw a fit and doesn't want to deal with it. You're on your own, you have 10 seconds, all the best! Better get it right the first time.