11 ms·
Taiwan to Deploy ‘Bee Eye’ Radars Near Chinese Mainland
- mensetmanusman 4y agoUnfortunately, China will likely attack Taiwan unless Russia is humiliated.
- AussieWog93 4y agoI wouldn't be so sure of that. Chinese leadership is very conservative, and they have a lot to lose from a military campaign gone wrong.
- FooBarWidget 4y agoThat is a fundamental misreading of China's relationship with Taiwan and China's intentions. China is likely to never attack Taiwan as long as the status quo is maintained, and as long as they believe that eventual peaceful reunification is possible. China's policy on Taiwan has not changed for decades. The height of military tensions were in the late 50s, when China and Taiwan were shelling each other. In later decades, they still sometimes deliberately shelled each other as a statement to others that the China-Taiwan issue is a domestic Chinese issue. Nowadays neither side has unleashed a shot for well over 30 years. The US has maintained the One China Policy for decades as well. Officially they haven't changed the policy, but unofficially they are trying to change it into a "Taiwan Independence Policy" without admitting that they are. This is where a lot of recent US-China tensions come from, especially on the military side. Anything Russia does to other states has got absolutely nothing to do with it.
- buildbot 4y agoThis is only the second time I have heard someone reference actual shelling of Taiwan, the other was my Mother in Law who lived there for awhile - I tried to find info about it online and came up blank, is there a good source you know of?
- hnthrowaway0328 4y agoGoogle 金门炮战 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis
- buildbot 4y agoThat seems somewhat earlier than the 70-80s? Edit - either I misread or they changed it to 50s, my bad. That would he the second straight crisis.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fartcannon 4y agoWhat about what they did in Hong Kong? They changed the rules once, what stops them from doing it again? History clearly means nothing.
- FooBarWidget 4y agoDeviations in agreements is not a thing exclusive to China. Agreements in international politics are made for a purpose. Perhaps to keep peace, or to protect some interest, etc. If the situation changes such that that purpose can no longer be served — especially if that purpose is an extremely important core interest — then any country will seek to deviate from agreed upon behavior. For example, the US clearly agreed on the One China Policy but they are now changing it. Because the US no longer values the original purpose that the One China Policy served. So the question "will China renegade on its agreement or not?" is best answered with another question: "What is China's core interest? What purpose does an agreement serve to China?" It is unfortunately here where big misreadings happen. Popular western understand of China says that China does things because they are "authoritarian", "expansionist", "power hungry", etc. But a true analysis of China's interest would show that one of China's core interests is territorial integrity, defined largely by the territory it had inherited from the Qing empire in 1911, and the Republic of China in 1949. China's policy on territorial integrity has not changed since 1949. We may not always agree with China's interests. Maybe they conflict with ours. But properly understanding those interests will at the end of the day surely yield better outcomes than misreading China with stereotypes.
- throw10920 4y ago> Deviations in agreements is not a thing exclusive to China. Yes, but merely looking at the agreement that China broke recently with the invasion of Hong Kong, a reasonable person would assume that there's a much higher risk of them breaking more agreements than another arbitrary country that hasn't been invading other countries recently. Said another way, most people currently will trust France to honor a pact more than they trust Russia. ...not that that somehow makes violating the agreement with and invading Hong Kong somehow morally excusable. China seems pretty similar to Russia right now - with an authoritarian dictator planning to use military force to invade nearby countries. You can even draw parallels between their mindsets - Putin wants to recreate the glory of the Soviet Union and views the old USSR countries as "his", just as Xi Jinping wants to recreate the glory of old China and views Hong Kong and Taiwan as his. > So the question "will China renegade on its agreement or not?" is best answered with another question: "What is China's core interest? What purpose does an agreement serve to China?" I don't see what purpose this statement has. It's clearly in China's core interest to be aggressive and expansionist and invade nearby countries and steal IP from other countries, but none of that is right, and none of that changes the fact that they're an aggressive enemy who pose a threat to the whole Asia region at least, if not the whole world.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y ago> Anything Russia does to other states has got absolutely nothing to do with it. Your comment was excellent, and helpful to me. Thanks. I do disagree that China isn't watching US reaction through a million lenses to see how they can best increase their odds rolling over Taiwan with minimal damage. My strongest evidence? Political changes in Hong Kong.
- FooBarWidget 4y agoChina is definitely watching the US, but I don't think it's for the reason you imagine. China prefers peaceful reunification. They don't want to fight a war if they don't have to. At the same time, peaceful reunification is a core interest of China. Which means that they will go to war, but only if they believe peaceful reunification is no longer possible. So yes they do watch the US to make calculations. But even if the US is weak, they still don't want a war as long as they believe peaceful reunification is possible. Furthermore, Taiwanese reunification is not only a core interest, it's also possibly the most emotional one for the Chinese. Large portions of the population support reunification, and they will overthrow whichever leader lets Taiwan go. This is why "raising the stakes" by announcing military support for Taiwan does not deter China. Quite the opposite: they encourage China to go to war, costs be damned, because such foreign support signal that peaceful reunification will become impossible. As for Hong Kong, see my comment here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31705632 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31705632
- hueyluey 4y agoFor many chinese people this is such an emotional issue because the chinese government has been very keen in promoting these emotions. They let go Mongolia and no one is still crying about that. The communist party could at least let off some steam on the issue if they wanted to...but they don't
- indymike 4y ago> China prefers peaceful reunification. The people of Taiwan, just like those of Ukraine do not want to be re-absorbed. > Quite the opposite: they encourage China to go to war, costs be damned, because such foreign support signal that peaceful reunification will become impossible. It already is impossible. I think the world, save Beijing is moving on.
- indymike 4y ago> That is a fundamental misreading of China's relationship with Taiwan and China's intentions. China is likely to never attack Taiwan as long as the status quo is maintained, and as long as they believe that eventual peaceful reunification is possible. China's policy on Taiwan has not changed for decades. The problem is that the status quo may not be acceptable to the people of Taiwan and reunification is not acceptable not even slightly wanted by the people of Taiwan. The's not really any chance of a reunification of the current China and the current Taiwan. > Anything Russia does to other states has got absolutely nothing to do with it. Not really, if Putin had quickly succeeded I have not doubt that WWIII would have started with a failed attempt to take Taiwan followed by WWIII. There's no scenario where A) China can take Taiwan, and B) Taiwan will accept Chinese rule. That died 70 years ago.
- Adraghast 4y ago> Not really, if Putin had quickly succeeded I have not doubt that WWIII would have started with a failed attempt to take Taiwan followed by WWIII. What qualifications allow you to make claims with such confidence?
- indymike 4y ago?
- FooBarWidget 4y agoYou know, the early 2000s looked pretty promising, with China and Taiwan having normalized relations for a while and with cross-strait business blooming. Back then a large portion of Taiwanese identified as Chinese. Today's tensions haven't always been there. As little as 10 years ago, Taiwanese supported reunification (though on their terms, e.g. the ROC government takes over the mainland) Ironically, Taiwan is very pro-Japan nowadays even though Japan was a colonizer in the early 20th century. Given this, it's not at all set in stone that relations will stay bad if peace endures.
- thesausageking 4y agoTSMC also guarantees China won't attack Taiwan in the near term. They're about 30% of the semiconductor industry and their most advanced foundries are only in Taiwan and no one else has been able to replicate them elsewhere. An invasion would cripple tech in China and the West, so the US would get involved and it would lead to a full scale war which no one wants.
- throw10920 4y ago> China is likely to never attack Taiwan as long as the status quo is maintained, and as long as they believe that eventual peaceful reunification is possible. Put another way: if the people of Taiwan decide that they don't want reunification, then China is going to invade and take them by force.
- imwillofficial 4y agoThat’s not what was said whatsoever. Make your own comments, don’t try and fail to interpret others’ comments and restate them.
- mdp2021 4y agoThat looks like "drawing conclusions", not like "attributing thoughts". "B wants stasis¹" // "Hence if A breaks it by removing doubts, B will act" - this is what was actually diplomatically declared, reminded, renewed in the past hours. ¹"stasis" - not the most proper expression of what is sought, but just to remain close to the original post in question.
- imwillofficial 4y agoIt doesn’t look like “drawing conclusions at all” They said “Put another way:” That is literally restating what the OG commenter said but with spin.
- mdp2021 4y agoSeems fully legit. «Put another way» completes what the original poster wrote, in a different telling perspective. The OP said, "A will refrain from B under condition C: the general intention of A is to refrain from B". The replying poster noted, "Admitting that A intends to refrain from B under condition C, the intention is also not to refrain from B, failing condition C". The replying poster is correctly noting that the relation is not just "C→¬B", but "C→¬B ∧ ¬C→B". FooBarWidget notes one half of the story; throw10920 remarks that the other half is also present. Correctly one states - reassuringly - "do not see a false extreme: B is not an absolute set intention", but the other notes that at the same time it should not be forgotten that "B is a set conditional intention". Which is what A has stated for a long time: "the reunification will happen: peacefully if possible, coercively otherwise". The 'put another way' formula is logically imperfect but rhetorically admissible, it is in a clear context. Of course throw10920 did not "repeat" what FooBarWidget wrote, «what was said»: he proceeded in the debate from the immediately preceding move posing a new "line". It is a "put another way" not in terms of restricting to the original poster's idea (thus re-reading it), but starting from the poster's idea in the context of given information.
- kmonsen 4y agoThe U.S. never had a one China policy. It officially acknowledges that China has a one China policy. It might sound the same, but it is not. Which it why it also has the policy to sell Taiwan weapons to defend itself, and sometimes the policy to actually defend Taiwan. Note that it’s policy on China is changing. Obama started to build a pacific alliance, Trump was a bull in a China shop but escalated the policy of disengagement from China. Biden has maintained Trump’s policy even though it would help with his biggest domestic problem (inflation) to reverse it, while also making clear he will defend Taiwan even if it means war with China.
- liuliu 4y agoAgreed up until: > Anything Russia does to other states has got absolutely nothing to do with it. This is a major change in the global status quo (given that China is closely aligned with Russia now). I disagree with your parent comment on "unless Russia is humiliated". It is yet unclear either way would increase China's appetite for Taiwan. If Russia is defeated, China may find it is necessary to reunite with Taiwan to maintain its geographical security given Russia would no longer be able to support / project support for China's military move in the future. If Russia wins, China may find it is a strategical weak point for U.S. allied forces and it is a good time to reunite with Taiwan given higher nationalism. Again, it is yet unclear. One thing certain though: the uncertainty increased substantially following Russia's war on Ukraine.
- rnk 4y agoThat's not true from my perspective as an American. China didn't historically make the same kind of continuing and increasing bellicose actions and claims as they do today. They have grown slowly over time, perhaps as China's military power has increased. Yes 50 years ago there was attacks, but China seems to be more threatened by the emergence of true democracy in Taiwan, and the development of later generations in a more independent societal direction (the people who left mainland China were being replaced/aged out of leadership by people who had never lived in China). My Taiwanese friends have also told me that China has significantly increased their concern for the future.
- dirtyid 4y agoThat's certainly a very American perspective. Ongoing PRC claims has been consistent since they were inherited from ROC days. They even fought war in SCS with NVietnam when their military was poverty tier. The reality is PRC rise in region has been EXTREMELY peaceful relative to level military expansion which itself is modest relative to GDP. All while settling 12/14 again, ROC inherited land border disputes with more concessions. PRC has done nothing particularly bellicose except defending claims she inherited, again not of her own making. The only possible except of Senkaku which again also ROC/TW claims. Japan BTW, has border (maritime) disputes with 100% of her neighbours despite being WW2 loser who should have territory constrained by treaty. Meanwhile SCS is a multiparty shit show, even then PRC managed to drop a dash line with North Vietnam when other parties made zero progress. The "peaceful" region rise of PRC is historically unprecedented. There's a reason why western analysts has to bemoan about "grayzone" warfare... because PRC military has been extremely constraint. Even relative to ROC days when TW regularly blockaded military shipping and spent spy missions over PRC territory. TW just coping with reality that military balance has completely shifted in PRC favor. Tranch of US weapon sales to TW in 90s made TW one of the most advanced military powers in the region, but that's been chipped away to the point that TW itself is essentially hopeless regardless of level of US weapon sales. As for being threatened by democracy, like TW broken politics and industrial stagnation outside of semiconductors is regularly memed on mainland. People don't generally look to TW as a model... or SK or JP or even US (anymore). PRC is threatened by renewed TW seccessionism weaponized by US because at the end of the day, the civil war never ended and they consider TW Chinese clay.
- melling 4y agoRussia has too much artillery to be humiliated. They are shelling everything and rolling over the dust. “Russia isn't fighting a campaign of attrition, it's waging a war of oblivion.” https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-61634050.amp https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-61634050.amp
- rocqua 4y agoIf you plan a quick win and instead manage to claim 2 provinces after you flattened them, that is humiliating.
- melling 4y agoClaiming only 20% of the country is humiliating? I suppose they can fortify that and come back in 10 years and take the rest. Remember when Hannibal destroyed the Roman armies? That sure was humiliating. What happened next?
- stale2002 4y agoIt is yes. Because their initial goal here was instead to go in and overthrow the government in a couple days, while not expecting any significant international response. There is a huge difference between their initial expectations, and what actually happened. And now they are in too deep to undo their mistakes.
- bigcat12345678 4y agoNah, anyone who think China's ambition is Taiwan, is simply ignorant of the civilization's history. China has always been the central of the world order, pride herself on its superiority in all aspects of human society. Taiwan needs to be a showcase of superiority over the US represented system. This superiority could be demonstrated in many manner, not necessarily taking over the island. After all, one who eyes the ocean does not care the pond remain private.
- appletrotter 4y agoI love this take. WHy should Greeks care about barbarians?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bigcat12345678 4y agoI don't follow your statement about "Greeks care about barbarians". Greeks, if I guess correctly, had a similar barbarian problems, like the ancient Chinese rules. Superficially, the 2 share the same high-level setting, i.e., an advanced kingdom is surrounded by nomad barbarians, where the advanced kingdom has a settled society built on top of rural + makers + traders economy, with a strong top governmental body; the barbarians are living a much more primitive life, and often trade with the advanced kingdom for things they cannot produce, and often resolve to invasion and looting when the climate cycle degrades their normal life condition beyond the normal capacity of their eudrance. I don't know about Greeks. Ancient Chinese devote significant intellectual and military thinking and resources on barbarians. Dealing with Barbarians often determine the live and death of a Chinese dynasty. For example Tang, Song, Ming were all ended by barbarians (in the general sense). And the great dynasties of Chinese history is always characterized by a military success and political subdue of barbarians. Han in the Wu Di era, Tang in the Tai Zong era. Ming in the Cheng Zu era.
- avgcorrection 4y agoThis is a funny comment considering that Taiwan considers mainland China and Mongolia to be part of Taiwan/the Republic of China.
- treme 4y agoTaiwan is a core interest of US for it's a choke point to deep sea access path to Pacific. Ukraine was never a core strategic interest for US.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- futhey 4y agoRussia has been humiliated abroad. Now, they must be humiliated at home. This means Crimea returning to Ukrainian control. That... will require a significantly greater commitment from Nato allies, or the US. Until Nato makes a greater commitment, the Chinese will (correctly) read this as a sign that in the event of a Taiwan invasion, the US will provide military support, but stop before committing troops to enforcing the status quo in the Taiwan strait.
- cpursley 4y ago> Humiliated abroad The vast majority of human kind are neutral or pro Russia regarding the situation. Sorry, but the English speaking countries (sans India) and EU are not "the word" despite the sense of superiority and entitlement. As for Crimea, that ain't never happening. The people there are majority Russian and Tartar and with a very small Ukrainian minority. Not only does Wikipedia tell me that, but I've talked with people there (in person).
- Rapzid 4y agoThere was a UN resolution a while back condemning the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Did 141 countries vote in favor of it with just 35 abstaining?
- cpursley 4y agoSum up those opposing and abstaining countries population sizes. Some very important countries with large and growing economies and populations are neutral.
- trasz 4y agoThey are neutral, but that doesn't mean they are on Russia's side. See China, for example - of course they can't officially join American sanctions, but Huawei is closing down its Russian stores anyway.
- 4y ago
- jimmont 4y agoChina is more likely to have its government choose a very different leader with resulting policy changes than attack Taiwan. Its economy and along with this politics have increasing problems which are unlikely to reach a plateau or improve in the next decade, possibly longer, and the current leader's policies are accelerating and exacerbating these problems. The only major wild card I see is if the government is able to make a unilateral move against Taiwan in an effort to distract from its internal problems. I don't know how the PRC works well enough to have some notion of how realistic this might be. Given Biden's restatement of the US positions it seems even less likely this would happen. And if it did I'd expect the US and Japan will immediately become involved, promptly followed by other allies if it escalates. What I also cannot gauge is what might happen if action were limited to only a place like Kinmen. If so the arms shipments to Taiwan and would likely immediately change and who knows maybe both Japan and the US would setup military bases there.
- yellow_lead 4y agoIn Taiwan right now, I was surprised how close some Taiwan-controlled islands are to the mainland. Kinmen is just 10km away[1]. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinmen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinmen
- gspr 4y agoWow, thanks for this! I had absolutely no idea either.
- ethbr0 4y agoWikipedia has a great map [0] and 1960s context [1] on Quemoy and Matsu. Broadly speaking, the ROC controlled them, the CCP attempted to seize them [2] in the 1950s, and the US threatened involvement (including nuclear). Then everyone settled down to just lobbing artillery at each other. In modern times, they're more of a symbol than an asset, in that if the CCP made moves to seize them, the US would assume an invasion of Taiwan was imminent, and bad things would ensure for everyone. Consequently, the CCP has no real reason to care about them until they're also willing to invade the main island of Taiwan. [0] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/6f/Nationalist_China_-_administrative_divisons._LOC_2007633622.jpg/790px-Nationalist_China_-_administrative_divisons._LOC_2007633622.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/6f/Na... [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matsu_Islands#Republic_of_China https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matsu_Islands#Republic_of_Ch... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoI heard that conscripts used to draw straws to see who would get deployed to those islands because of the chance of artillery landing.
- xeromal 4y agoOh wow, I only thought they had one island.
- acgt 4y agoBiden said he would militarily defend Taiwan (throw Ukraine under the bus). The leash on Taiwan is officially off now. Embrace for more aggression from both sides to challenge the status quo.
- samcheng 4y agoI'm not convinced the equivalence you mention - "aggression from both sides" - is really there. The current Taiwanese government's only stated goal is to defend itself; there is no serious surviving political will in Taiwan to attack China. China could attack Taiwan (particularly Matsu and Kinmen), but an attack on the mainland also appears less likely these days, given the very real chance of humiliation a la Russia in Ukraine.
- melling 4y agoRussia has regrouped and moved past the “humiliation“ event. Russia has 10 times the artillery as Ukraine and they are putting it to work. The West is simply not providing enough to Ukraine Hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians will eventually die, and they could lose. https://www.newsweek.com/ukraine-risks-losing-artillery-war-russia-vadym-skibitsky-military-intelligence-1714782?amp=1 https://www.newsweek.com/ukraine-risks-losing-artillery-war-...
- samcheng 4y agoEven if Russia manages to level a few more cities, it's hard to see the past three months as anything but a humiliation of Russia's military might. The damage to Russian military international respect (fear, even) has already been done.
- melling 4y agoNope, a few missteps in the first 90 days of the war will hardly matter a decade from now. The West really needs to update their news cycle. While everyone was laughing at the problems Russia had early in the war, they went into full artillery mode. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/10/world/europe/ukraine-ammo-shortage-artillery.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/10/world/europe/ukraine-ammo...
- antux 4y agoChina is always overstepping their bounds and needs to be checked by the superpowers of the world. Without checks and balances, they will continue to bully the neighboring countries by force and deception.
- swayvil 4y agoA gaggle of billionaires with a nation in their pocket. They want to grow. Mugging your neighbors might be the only option.
- melling 4y agoChina, Russia, and the United States are the only 3 superpowers. China already has a larger economy in terms of PPP. It passed the United States in 2017. Russia appears to have bigger plans beyond Ukraine: https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-38099842 https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-38099842 Also, people seem to be a month behind on what Russia is doing in Ukraine. https://www.stripes.com/theaters/europe/2022-06-10/ukraine-ammunition-battlefield-prospects-6303189.html https://www.stripes.com/theaters/europe/2022-06-10/ukraine-a...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago> people seem to be a month behind on what Russia is doing in Ukraine. What are you talking about? https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-june-10 https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/russian-offens...
- melling 4y agoSo, you and I both posted the same information about the current assessment. Thanks. It’s great to discuss the current situation “Ukrainian officials are increasing the urgency of their requests for more-sophisticated Western-provided weapons systems amid reports of growing Russian artillery superiority”
- born-jre 4y agoThis video by polymatter is one of best at explaining the china Taiwan relation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p2LiMTtGrAY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p2LiMTtGrAY
- bsedlm 4y agoI see this, and I just wonder about the millions of dollars in radar technology sold by american companies owned by american congressmen... I wonder if the chips they're using are made in taiwan... heheh
- bigcat12345678 4y agoPersonally, Taiwan's most important mission now is to continue maintain TSMC's superiority over either China and US in advanced Chip manufacturing. Once TSMC lost that advantage, either side of China and US are going to put Taiwan in a much lower significance in the consideration of their own duel of power. The one being treated the worst is always the one who is inconsequential. The bad guys are never target of so-called justice...
- dirtyid 4y agoDeployed within 2 minutes of host of PRC ordnance. This is the kind of expensive platforms US doesn't want TW to pursue because it's a money sink relative to insurgent porcupine capabilties - to the point of vetoing TW military purchase decisions that doesn't contribute to US vision/strategy for TW - one where TW fight like insurgents and get droned to dust. At the end of the day, it's about domestic politics, expensive high tech platforms provides politicians photo ops of a modern military that might have a chance to ignorant voters vs adopting strategy to convincing constituents to get slaughtered like Taliban. Ergo TW continusouly developing mid/high tier indigenous platforms while seeking to import other flashy weapons that won't survive the first hours of a cross-strait air campaign.
- jakzurr 4y agoShort, interesting article (from a tech standpoint). A bit more here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CS/MPQ-90_Bee_Eye https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CS/MPQ-90_Bee_Eye https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_Sword_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sky_Sword_II I've gotta admit though, the political comments here, esp. regarding Ukraine/Russia, were even more interesting.