3 ms·
Smart meters are not just ‘dumb’ but a scandalous waste of money
- solardev 4y agoIt's not clear from the article... in the UK, do the smart meters come with an in-home dashboard that customers are expected to read? And then report back what they see on an honor system? The ones I've seen in the US are outside the house, like the old meters, but communicate to each other and report back to the utility directly via a mesh network.
- timthorn 4y ago>in the UK, do the smart meters come with an in-home dashboard that customers are expected to read? That's the idea. >And then report back what they see on an honor system? No, the meters should report usage to the utility companies autonomously. The goal of the in-home display is make householders aware of their energy use with a view to reducing consumption. What the article/letters are about is a comms problem that had arisen between some meters and the infrastructure, which then results in the householders having to submit manual readings.
- solardev 4y agoSo what did this quote from the article mean? > We have to read almost all of them and are frequently required to provide dated photographs for all phases plus the total, on each meter – sometimes four photos for each reading – since the power companies don’t trust customers to provide accurate readings. Who is the "we" there? That sounds like they're still sending as many people out to read the meters as before, except now they have to take pictures of each screen too. Why would they have to do that if the meters report back automatically?
- mytailorisrich 4y agoIn this guy's case the smart meters do not work so he is asked to manually report readings...
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd in Finland I could see hourly or even 5 minute consumption nearly live... UK is sometimes weird place... Like having coin operate meters...
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThey do come with an in-home dashboard but no-one's "expected" to read it. The main idea is that those meters indeed report readings to utility company automatically.
- zeristor 4y agoThree anecdotes? Is that it?
- jaclaz 4y agoIf you want a fourth one, from another country here it is (Italy): In a small village nearby, reknown to the locals for having (for some reasons) terrible 2G/3G coverage, a few years ago the gas company replaced meters with "smart" ones. The technology was 2G/3G, the units had a SIM (or e-SIM) and - in theory - it would "ping" very rarely the gas company to send the info about consumption, no fancy dashboard, but of course a small lcd display to allow the customer to read the data (in m3). All of this powered by a built in (and not-removable) battery that was intended to last many years (I believe 10-15, but cannot say for sure). Anyway, again for some reasons, the devices either scanned the (as said very problematic) cellular network too often because it couldn't "hook" to it or for whatever other reason batteries died within 2 years or less. The battery wasn't replaceable, and the whole electronic module was not available so they changed again all the meters with a new model. The ones for electicity (as well without any fancy feature) on the other hand usually work flawlessly (they are powered by the mains and send data though the line itself). Since a few years they are starting to get installed (in condo's or similar centrally heated buildings, according to some EU directive) new "smart valves" and "caloric counters" on radiators (the idea is that a guy with a sort of radio modem passes and reads in one go all the data of a whole building) and the issues are coming out, dead batteries (replaceable but only with a special tool, so a technician needs to come to your house to replace them), non-working units that need to be entirely replaced, malfunctioning units, a whole mess.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]