4 ms·
Can a biologist fix a radio? Or, what I learned while studying apoptosis (2002)
- nereye 4y agoSome previous posts: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30120457 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30120457 76 points|breck|4 months ago|18 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=624695 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=624695 22 points|Maro|13 years ago|4 comments
- flobosg 4y ago(2002)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cleansingfire 4y agoThis is an interesting point, and I hope it is actionable. Of course we need to understand the biological components and systems in detail. Unfortunately biology varies wildly between individuals, while the radio is constructed to a specific design, from parts standardized to three significant figures or so. A wiring diagram for a radio is sufficient, but cells are influenced by a very dynamic environment. We won't diagram my gut biome to that level of detail, yet it influences My biology.
- rwj 4y agoActually, lots of circuits can be built with components specified to within 20%, perhaps with some key components specified more tightly. Good designs are robust against component variation.
- dgacmu 4y agoAnd one of the mechanisms for making robust designs is feedback (think 98% of op-amp circuits), which happens to be a favorite in biological systems.
- procarch2019 4y agoAgreed, got my degree in BME and it was probably evenly split between Bio, EE and Mech E. Went on to work in industrial automation, which a lot of people look at me with a questionable stare, but actually makes perfect sense. I remember going to a career fair senior year right after doing a physio lab where we directly studied feedback systems. The company I ended up working for was demoing their software, which was control graphics. Looked a lot like the diagrams we were using in labs.
- kurthr 4y agoYes, one was designed while the other evolved. That makes understanding their operation qualitatively different (e.g. one is almost linear sequence of nearly ideal stages with minimal degrees of freedom, while the other are completely non-linear chemical systems with hundreds or thousands of degrees of freedom). Even reverse engineering a GPT3 instance is mind boggling and the number of independent variables is tiny in comparison.
- Barrera 4y ago> Yet, we know with near certainty that an engineer, or even a trained repairman could fix the radio. What makes the differ- ence? I think it is the languages that these two groups use (Figure 3). Biologists summarize their results with the help of all- too-well recognizable diagrams, in which a favorite protein is placed in the middle and connected to everything else with two- way arrows. Even if a diagram makes overall sense (Figure 3A), it is usually useless for a quantitative analysis, which limits its predictive or investigative value to a very narrow range. The lan- guage used by biologists for verbal communications is not bet- ter and is not unlike that used by stock market analysts. Both are vague (e.g., “a balance between pro- and antiapoptotic Bcl-2 proteins appears to control the cell viability, and seems to correlate in the long term with the ability to form tumors”) and avoid clear predictions. This thought-provoking essay nevertheless makes an apples-and-oranges comparison. Let's try another experiment. Present a radio repair technician with car (ICE) that cranks but won't start. Give the technician, who has zero previous experience, no documentation or training and just watch what happens. I'm going to guess that the technician will follow something that looks a lot like the approach used by the biologists in the essay. Disassembly. Manipulation of components in isolation. Hypothesis of function. Hypothesis validation. Rinse and repeat. The reason the comparison doesn't work is not some variation of vitalism (the author brings up as one objection). The reason the radio technician can solve one problem (broken radio) and not the other (cranking no start) is not language or vitalism or anything else. It's the simple fact that when faced with a broken radio, the technician uses a model that works. It reflects reality and stands up to the harshest scrutiny. The technician doesn't get that model through induction, it's handed down by those who created the system. And to be fair, the manufacturer helps by building its product to code, rather than some hazy spectrum of possible codes. The author tries to make a case for "formal" approaches by which it seems like he's talking about mathematical approaches. But I think this misses the point. Trying to understand a defect in an alien system poses a conundrum: science teaches us to break the system down into parts or "systems", but there are many ways to do that. Even if we hit on the right fracture points we easily lose the connections that made the whole work.
- hprotagonist 4y agoA classic. its spiritual sequel: “Can a neuroscientist understand a microprocessor?” https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?id=10.1371/journal.pcbi.1005268 https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?id=10.1371/jo...
- mjfl 4y agoI'm a trained physicist (undergrad) in biology (phd). I've always wanted to give a retort "could a physicist understand a microprocessor?". the answer is no, no they couldn't, unless they were trained in computer science. The abstraction of 'state evolving in time according to analytical equation' really breaks down when looking at computational systems, such as a microprocessor, as well as a biological cell.
- SilasX 4y agoInteresting. My intuition is the opposite [1]: computers are highly optimized to decouple the different functions and subsystems. That is, even when the state space is huge, only a very narrow set of state transitions is possible. This constraint is what makes experimentation tractable, in contrast to biological systems, where state will bleed across the whole system because, at some point, that was a fit adaptation. I think that view is historically validated in that, in wartime, one side would steal the other's encryption hardware (e.g. the Enigma machine) and be able to piece together a meaningful description of what it's doing, without access to the original designers, and even get to the point where they could pose what encryption function they're trying to reverse. Of course, there's a key distinction there -- those were largely mechanical systems, while the question here is about tiny microprocessors. So I'd agree there's a sort of pre-requisite that physicists be aware of the existence of some key primitives that the system operates on (here, current, voltage, electricity, etc. along with the ability to see small enough parts). If that's what you meant by being "trained in computer science" then I'd agree, though that's a non-standard use of the term.[2] In any case, there's more to the physicist's toolbox than closed-form analytical equations. [1] My earlier comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16818220 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16818220 [2] Per the Dijstrka quote ("Computer science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes"), compsci is about the limits of computational processes, not electronic hardware per se.
- geocrasher 4y agoAs somebody who understands radios (Amateur radio is a hobby, and I've scratch built receivers) I had to stop reading. It's a fascinating, but somewhat frustrating read. I do think the overall approach is really interesting though and aptly describes the overlap in knowledge that often happens in otherwise disparate disciplines.
- donthellbanme 4y ago
- Animats 4y agoA classic radio receiver is reasonably easy to fix, because it's a pipeline. The usual tools are a signal injector and a signal tracer. The signal injector allows you to put in a test signal at various points in the circuit, and the signal tracer lets you listen to what's coming out. You start at the front and back ends, and work towards the part that isn't working.