3 ms·
Great book -- read it when I was a teenager -- but one thing that I think makes the book a bit harder to explain to smaller kids these days is the use of relays
by xt00 4y ago
Great book -- read it when I was a teenager -- but one thing that I think makes the book a bit harder to explain to smaller kids these days is the use of relays for explaining lots of things. Its a great concept to explain things but it does tend to cause a bit of confusing for younger kids who may not have played with electromagnets as much as kids from 20-30 years ago. Not sure what to replace relays with but maybe having kids watch a super easy to understand video about how relays work would help make the book easier to understand for say like an 8 year old reading the book.
- ultrasounder 4y agovery easily substitute using FETs. Essentially the same as relays and BJTs but much easier to control logic FETs than BJTs.
- squarefoot 4y agoBut that would introduce more complexity (polarity, biasing, etc) that would distract from the initial purpose. With a relay they should only learn how connecting a battery to pins 1 and 2 closes the contacts on 3 and 4. Using relays with more throws they can also learn the basics of logic gates, flip flops, etc. I believe that relays still have a place for educational purposes.
- ultrasounder 4y agoYup! Agree 100%
- rrauenza 4y agoMy kids played a lot with "relays" in Minecraft using Redstone. Not quite the same, though!
- xt00 4y agoHa that's a great idea.. sounds like a good idea for a coding book.. hey so you know minecraft.. use that knowledge to learn how computers work..
- userbinator 4y agoHydraulic relays? I vaguely remember coming across a similar "bottom-up" book about how computers work many decades ago (near the end of the mainframe/minicomputer era) which used water flowing through pipes and valves as its analogy. Unfortunately the title wasn't so memorable, but I do recall the cover was a photo of a little girl filling a bucket from a spigot on the outside of a house. Does anyone know what book that was? I've searched a bit before, but had no luck.