3 ms·
I'm sorry that the lady couldn't vote, perhaps she should apply for citizenship to the country she lives in if she wants to vote. In Sweden "Settled" people ca
by dijit 4y ago
I'm sorry that the lady couldn't vote, perhaps she should apply for citizenship to the country she lives in if she wants to vote.
In Sweden "Settled" people can only vote for local governments, not for the Riksdag (Parliament).. that privilege is for citizens only, for example.
But, it's hardly "weird" that British people do not have EU citizenship automatically anymore, EU citizenship is granted on top of your normal citizenship if your country is a member of the EU, which the UK no longer is.
The same mechanism that turned Brits to EU citizens in the 70s is the same process by which those rights are no longer applicable to British citizens today, what did people think they were voting for?
Surely this is Hardly "news", or maybe I'm too optimistic about how much people understand about the politics of the world around them.
I would expect expats to know more than the usual uninformed (or misinformed) British citizen living domestically.
- solar-ice 4y ago> what did people think they were voting for? Brexiters did, indeed, in general, think they were voting to strip the rest of us of our rights, and they succeeded in doing so - they thought that this was worth "protecting us from Brussels" or preventing immigration or that it would mean £350 million a week to the NHS or whatever else. This court case (and a handful of similar ones) was a last-ditch attempt of people stripped of their rights to keep them.
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoYeah, but my understanding is the case was about municipal elections (like the local mayor/council etc.) In the UK the rules are the same as Sweden where any resident can vote. But it seems many countries have citizenship requirements even for the municipal elections.
- przemub 4y agoThe UK has citizenship requirements as well. British, Irish and Commonwealth citizen residents can vote. In local elections only, EU citizens can vote as well. This is because the EU forces that right, and the UK has not repealed it (yet?).
- avianlyric 4y ago> The same mechanism that turned Brits to EU citizens in the 70s is the same process by which those rights are no longer applicable to British citizens today, what did people think they were voting for? I’m not sure that’s trivially obvious. The process of joining the EU is complex and extremely well documented and understood. The process of leaving is a couple paragraphs with zero specifics. Ultimately the question boiled down to, having been granted EU citizenship, on what basis was that citizenship revoked? If EU citizenship is just an extension of your national citizenship to an EU member, then reason for loss is clear. But if your EU citizenship is distinct and additional to your national citizenship, then what basis was it revoked, and what gave the revoking entity the right to strip a person of their EU citizenship? Clearly the courts strong believe that EU citizenship is directly tied to your citizenship of an EU member. But until the ruling was made, that answer wasn’t absolutely clear, and why shouldn't UK citizens make a Hail Mary attempt at preserving their EU citizenship? The down side of bringing the case and loosing is a lose of time and money, but winning would fundamentally change many peoples relationship with the EU.
- GordonS 4y ago> what did people think they were voting for? Therein lies the crux of the problem - nobody knew exactly what a vote for Brexit would mean, beyond somehow leaving the EU and "sending Johnny Foreigner back". Many politicians and the tabloid media spread many dubious claims, and plenty outright lies, about the purported benefits of Brexit. For example, fisherman were made to believe French and Spanish boats would no longer fish in their waters - which never came true. This particular one example is a good one, because it demonstrates well that this group, who rely on cheap foreign labour, didn't know what they were voting for.
- x86_64Ubuntu 4y agoPeople who believed that Brexit wouldn't overall have a negative effect were the ones lured by it's less than noble claims. One lesson of the past decade is that these "duped" people aren't victims too, but enticed by some other less palatable sentiment they possess.
- GordonS 4y agoI don't disagree, but I also believe the tabloid media hold great power over that segment of the population; indeed, many of the "less palatable" sentiments have been encouraged by the tabloid media, or perhaps even originated with them.