3 ms·
For people without consoles or powerful graphics cards (Intel iGPU, Apple chips, etc., mobile phones) cloud gaming is the only way they'll be able to play games
by jeroenhd 4y ago
For people without consoles or powerful graphics cards (Intel iGPU, Apple chips, etc., mobile phones) cloud gaming is the only way they'll be able to play games on their devices.
If this trend catches on eventually this might throw a wrench into Apple's plans to get companies to develop against their proprietary graphics standard. Why buy two new Metal-optimised games that'll only work on your Mac when you can play every game on Steam/Epic/whatever through Shadow.tech?
There's a hefty monthly fee but the separation of the game stores+cloud saves and the servers you run your games on allows you to cancel your server subscription and keep all your games ready to play within minutes, or to switch to real hardware down the line. It's an excellent value proposition that often gets ridiculed because of how new the model is.
The ban risk is always there but that's no different from Steam or any other games store. Very few people have all their games on a disk drive and ever fewer also regularly download updates. The hundreds or even thousands of terabytes you need to backup a moderately sized game library these days don't come cheap.
In reality, all you really need to backup for single player games are your save games because if you get banned, you can just download a cracked copy of the games you like.
- account42 4y ago> For people without consoles or powerful graphics cards (Intel iGPU, Apple chips, etc., mobile phones) cloud gaming is the only way they'll be able to play games on their devices. Only way to play state of the art graphics-focused games at the limit of what personal computers can do, sure. But not the only way to play games period. Laptops and even phones these days are quite powerful and can achieve a lot. Due to diminisshing returns with even more powerful hardware, the gap in graphical fidelity between what a top end PC can run and what a cheap laptop can run will only get smaller.
- jeroenhd 4y agoSimilar to the web has evolved to eat RAM and CPU because of ever faster browsers and machines, games have become harder to run even for similar graphic fidelity. The close to the metal, often hacky, super complicated performance trickery that was necessary years ago isn't relevant anymore. Like the rest of modern software, improved base specs are allowing for more developer comfort at the cost of some performance, bringing out more features quicker rather than running simple games at incredible frame rates. There are titles that will run on pretty much anything with a moderately powerful GPU (league of legends, rocket league) but you'll have a hard time running Cyberpunk on integrated GPUs, no matter how much you crank the settings down. On my laptop I've tried running Skyrim (the latest rerelease) on my 10th gen Intel integrated GPU and the results were choppy and nearly unplayable. It all depends on the games you want to play and how well they've been designed to operate in restricted performance environments. For sure a laptop made five years from now will run current high-end titles at decent frame rates if you set them up right, but that doesn't solve the problems of wanting to play a game now, or wanting more than the minimum graphical spectacle at playable frame rates. A $500 Chromebook won't play most games even if it could run Windows, and that's the performance level many people are at. Developers like their shiny, fast, expensive machines and PC gaming enthusiasts love their 3080s and 6900XTs but your average person doesn't have any of that. Both AMD and Nvidia are still finding ways to squeeze more performance out of their chips and even Intel is joining in with competent dedicated GPUs from what the leaked specs seem to indicate.
- spywaregorilla 4y ago> A $500 Chromebook won't play most games even if it could run Windows, and that's the performance level many people are at. Developers like their shiny, fast, expensive machines and PC gaming enthusiasts love their 3080s and 6900XTs but your average person doesn't have any of that. Yeah, a $500 chromebook won't, but a $500 gaming laptop will. Gaming laptops are far cheaper and more capable than people expect. They just aren't super thin, are heavier, and they tend to need a beefy power supply. My laptop is like 4 years old or so, has a 2080RTX, and cost I think $800 at the time. It's been able to run everything I've thrown at it at max settings, save VR. Including RE Village
- jeroenhd 4y agoA 2080 in a laptop for $800 must've been quite the deal, even with GPU prices dropping I can't find anything similar to that in price/performance ranges right now. Even right now the price for a new laptop with that chip in it seem at least 1.5x to 2x higher. $1200-$1500 seems to be the bare minimum for a laptop with that chip, and the cheaper ones tend to come with worse cooling and power caps that will significantly hinder its performance. Are you sure you're not forgetting a 1 in front of that 800 dollar price tag? I can't find any new laptops with dedicated graphics for $500. You can find laptops with an AMD 5500U for that price, but I doubt you'll be playing RE Village on that.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoNot advocating for this laptop in any form, and I would encourage waiting for good sales, but first result on amazon looking for an RTX laptop gives https://www.amazon.com/Acer-AN515-55-53E5-i5-10300H-GeForce-Keyboard/dp/B092YHJGMN/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2MDSH8XYQAPGC&keywords=gaming+laptop&qid=1654875091&refinements=p_n_feature_seven_browse-bin%3A18107822011&rnid=3012494011&s=pc&sprefix=gaming+laptop%2Caps%2C109&sr=1-1 https://www.amazon.com/Acer-AN515-55-53E5-i5-10300H-GeForce-... $749 for an RTX3050. probably fine for pretty much everything but vr
- jeroenhd 4y ago
- pjmlp 4y agoRegardless of much 3D API hate Apple gets around here, small reminder that game consoles never cared for Khronos APIs either, any junior engine dev is quite capable to write a pluggable 3D engine, and it isn't even what is more relevant on a full blown game engine.
- jeroenhd 4y agoThere's a difference between consoles and macOS, though. Anyone buying a console is in the market for games, but the same cannot be said about anyone buying a Mac. It's worth dealing with the proprietary API for PlayStation because the PS5 can sell games at huge quantities, and with DirectX you not only get the Xbox market, you get the PC market practically for free. You'll need to do some fine tuning to get PC levels of compatibility, but that's less work than writing against an entirely different graphics API. Mac users generally don't tend to game on Mac. This also means there are fewer experts on writing game engines for metal than there are for alternative platforms. I don't see why that would change any time soon, and that's why I don't think programming for Metal will be worth the extra effort and cost. I definitely believe that this can be done. It all boils down to drawing triangles real quick and Metal is just a new way of specifying how to make those triangles appear. I just think it's economically unfeasible to invest much time into Mac gaming. I think it's much easier and probably cheaper to just throw the game on Stadia/GeForce Now to reach Mac/ChromeOS/Android gamers. All they need is a browser and a decent internet connection.
- pjmlp 4y agoGames for iDevices aren't created out of thin air. All relevant AAA tooling already do Metal for a while now. As of Metal 3, Khronos APIs are now the only ones left without any kind of support for mesh shaders or optimized API for texture IO. No worries, they will probably get a few more extensions to load per GPU vendor, making it no different than having a proper plugin infrastructure in place.
- mrtranscendence 4y agoI don't disagree with you generally about developers making native macOS games, but "all they need is [...] a decent internet connection" gets dicy. My purportedly 400mbps connection doesn't do a stunning job at cloud gaming, and most people (around here anyway) don't even have that. Add in the fact that almost all devices to be used for cloud gaming connect via wifi and the experience has the potential to be less than superb. I don't really see that changing in the very near future, which makes me think that the jump to cloud gaming won't be as quick as some companies want it to be. Whether this changes the calculus WRT making native macOS games I guess I can't say, but even without cloud gaming picking up the porting slack I don't expect to see much happening here unless Apple decides to throw a bunch of money around to make it so.