2 ms·
Skype is claiming copyright on the source files that this guy created while reverse engineering the protocol? It's times like this when I really wish that every
by pyre 15y ago
Skype is claiming copyright on the source files that this guy created while reverse engineering the protocol? It's times like this when I really wish that everyone involved in that decision could be held personally responsible for the blatant lie that that is.
Even if it was against the law for him to reverse engineer the protocol, they don't own copyright to the source files he created.
- Roboprog 15y agoUnfortunately, the article seemed to indicate that the engineer disassembled a binary, rather than sniffing network protocol traffic.
- ianburrell 15y agoI thought the researched decompiled the Skype client, posted the resulting source, reversed engineered the protocol, and wrote open source implementation. The decompiled source is definitely a derivative work and possibly copyrighted by Skype. It is hard to tell if the DMCA takedown is for that decompiled source. The other problem is that by looking at the decompiled source, his source is tainted. He will have a hard time showing that it isn't a derivative work. Especially if he wasn't really careful writing the source from scratch and not cleaning up the decompiled source.
- kijiki 15y agoIf you want to do this right, you do it the way Compaq did with the IBM PC BIOS. One group of engineers analyzes the code, and writes a english text specification. A 2nd group (100% disjoint) took that spec and then wrote a compatible BIOS. This survived a legal challenge, but that was in the IP environment of the early '80s, so who knows what would fly now.