4 ms·
> They basically were friendly with all neighbors seeking to influence > internal policy. For example, all public works depend on a > sponsor (saudi, qatar
by dotancohen 4y ago
> They basically were friendly with all neighbors seeking to influence
> internal policy. For example, all public works depend on a
> sponsor (saudi, qatar etc), to fund the project.
I had no idea! Was this because they were unable to collect taxes from the populace? Where could I read more.
> When? I think Black september sealed the fate of lebanon. They had no internal
> unity to reject the palestinian refugees like Jordan did (via authoritarian methods).
Was there no way to handle the palestinian refugees without authoritarian methods? Honest naive question, most people who voice an opinion on the subject seem to have extremely one-sided and narrow viewpoints, your comment demonstrates otherwise. I would appreciate a candid opinion from someone who sees the larger picture.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago>>>>I had no idea! Was this because they were unable to collect taxes from the populace? Where could I read more I don't know where this practice comes from or how long has it been around. I do know however the public works bidding is a cartel, and there is so much corruption at all levels, from deputies to private enterprise, that it would make Brazil's petrobras corruption scandal (lava jato) look minor in comparison. >>>>Was there no way to handle the palestinian refugees without authoritarian methods? Im not sure. Displaced populations had to go live somewhere. The palestinian issue is rare because they were forced to leave, which is atypical for "total war" conflict. In total war conflicts, the result is winner takes land with resources, and loser state is (a) integrated into larger empire, with either assimilation, or massive civilian casualties, or (b) else loser state is left with minor pop and land. With Palestine, there was no leftover "loser" state, there were no resources changing hands, and no civilian wipeout. I dont know of any democratic country succesfully managing refugees at that scale. Total war is not rare historically, what is rare is democratic states existing at the time total war was still prevalent. The question is interesting. Id like to give it more thought. That being said, history tends to put everyone in their place. Jordan may still implode due to royal malfeasance, but lebanon already did.
- dotancohen 4y ago> Im not sure. Displaced populations had to go live somewhere. This is the crux of the issue. Jordan was a strong nation that was able to protect its national identity and existing citizens by subjugating the refugees. Even today, two out of every three people in Jordan are descendants of those displaced in 1948-1949. We might not like what Jordan did to those people, but protecting its citizens is quite the major function of government, is it not? Of course I am referring to the period up until 1967. The PLO actions after 1967 changed the dynamics of the situation and any rubric for judging policy in the period before that year is not valid for judging policy in the period after that year.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"Was there no way to handle the palestinian refugees without authoritarian methods? " That is one if the ongoing big questions worldwide, isn't it? The EU solves it by paying Erdogan and co. to do most of the dirty work of keeping them away. There is no nice way, to turn someone desperate away. You can either integrate them well, or you push them out. Or you can work towards solutions, that bring prosperity to the poor, exploited areas of the world. Ending wars would be a good start.
- dotancohen 4y ago> You can either integrate them well, or you push them out. But what is "integration" when for every one of _your_ citizens, _two_ refugees are coming. At that scale one is not integrating the refugees, rather, one is simply giving the country to the refugees. Of course, those refugees had to go live _somewhere_. The Egyptians rounded them up into Gaza, stuffing 250,000 people into land that could support 60,000 and already had over 100,000. That is why there are no real refugee camps in Egypt today, and why Egypt refused to take Gaza back after 1956.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago>>>>There is no nice way, to turn someone desperate away. You can either integrate them well, or you push them out. Historically, there was a 3rd and even 4th option. Both are extremely antihuman (genocide, slavery) but they were options nonetheless.
- hutzlibu 4y agoAnd of course there is the 5th, often applied solution of putting them in enclosed temporary camps, that turn permanent, if the conflict never gets solved. And personally I like the swiss approach, too.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago>>>>>Was there no way to handle the palestinian refugees without authoritarian methods? " Actually I will take a stab at the question. I think Switzerland is a decent example of how to handle refugees while still remaining a free country. In fact, Switzerland offers a glimpse of a solution: the suisse model of citizenship the municipal level. In Switzerland, each canton makes its own rules for naturalization. Some cantons have adhoc policies, and refuse granting citizenship for almost any reason. [1]. Now, expand that thesis: - if cantons also had sovereign control of their borders (which they did, during the old confederacy) they could manage refugee crisis while retaining democratic ideals. https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2017/01/switzerland-citizenship-nancy-holten/513212/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2017/01/sw...