12 ms·
Resident Evil Village in the browser through Stadia
- sph 4y agoOf course it doesn't seem to work on Firefox :(
- reflexco 4y agoIt doesn't seem to load on both Firefox and Chrome so I'm not sure the browser is the problem. Their servers are probably overloaded.
- pja 4y agoIt worked in Chrome for me, but not Firefox.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoHey! It's not antitrust because Google is not a monopoly. Just go demo Resident Evil Village in your Firefox browser through a different provider. /s
- izzydata 4y agoFirefox should shut themselves down so Google can be sued.
- rvz 4y agoFirefox itself is a failure and it is not early days. We've given it enough time to be better than Chrome and it is still declining.
- solar-ice 4y agoYou mean web standards are a failure, because Google keeps creating products that only work in Google Chrome.
- account42 4y agoIf only it was just google that equated the web with Chrome :|
- rvz 4y agoI see. It's something else's fault. Mozilla Firefox had more market share than the declining IE and the opportunity to get further ahead at one point and it still lost. Even the CEO was confident in competing against Google if they were to release their own browser at the time and believed that they would not be >80% dependent on the companies revenue. [0] The inability to recognise responsibility of past failures is perhaps the reason why Firefox has failed and the parent Mozilla is still totally reliant on Google's money. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20120105090543/https://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9044160/Mozilla_can_live_without_Google_s_money_Baker_says_ https://web.archive.org/web/20120105090543/https://www.compu...
- solar-ice 4y agoWhen Google develops a product (Stadia) and does not adhere to web standards in developing that product, I do not know who else to blame for Stadia not working on browsers that support web standards, which was the criticism here.
- CodeArtisan 4y agoI don't know about Stadia but changing your user-agent to Chrome with something like User-Agent Switcher makes Nvidia Geforce Now work on firefox.
- rand49an 4y agoIt doesn't seem to work in the latest version of Edge either, works for a few minutes and closes.
- neogodless 4y agoMy experience was it not working in Firefox, but working in Edge.
- brunno 4y agoIt's region locked to some countries: SORRY. CAN'T DELIVER. Which area can I play in? You can access this streaming demo from the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, France, Italy, Germany, Austria, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Denmark, Norway, Finland, Belgium, Ireland, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Romania, and Hungary.
- Titan2189 4y agoAnnoying for me (NZ) as well, but understandable. If they don't have servers close enough it'll be a bad experience. So better not get bad press and directly deny access.
- the_duke 4y agoThose are the countries that Stadia is available in. [1] You really need servers to be close by for game streaming to work. [1] https://support.google.com/stadia/answer/9566513?hl=en https://support.google.com/stadia/answer/9566513?hl=en
- onychomys 4y agoThey really oughta alphabetize that list.
- nominusllc 4y agoit's in order of importance
- delecti 4y agoWhat ranking of importance? Germany is twice as big as Canada, and is also bigger than France or Italy.
- diffeomorphism 4y agoUS, next to US; UK; list of countries in Europe.
- fallat 4y agoHonestly, playable. 1. Input lag for this doesn't matter 2. Lower resolution hides the lower texture fidelity as well Clearly though very game dependent.
- kubb 4y agoTo you it doesn't matter, sure.
- fallat 4y agoI meant "for this game" - RE is not reaction based.
- the_doctah 4y agoIt may not "matter" per se because it's not a MP shooter, but input lag of any kind feels sluggish and bad to play.
- fallat 4y ago"of any kind" is not really true. My old large LCD TV had terrible input lag, but your brain eventually adjusts. I eventually replaced it with a quality large LCD TV because the lag really mattered when combining controller + online play + fast FPS. Otherwise, I was able to beat all the Dark Souls with what I'd say is input lag equivalent to that demo.
- mrtranscendence 4y agoI think the situation is not so black and white. I've not used Stadia before, but I played a lot of God of War streamed from my gaming PC to my phone using a controller accessory. In GoW I essentially didn't notice any lag after a few moments. But in other games that are more reaction-based I absolutely did notice, and that never got better. So it does seem to depend on what kind of game you're playing and how much lag there actually is ... I'm sure I would've noticed 200ms of lag, but 15-30ms? Not really. That said, I don't know how much lag there is using Stadia (I launched the demo here but didn't play beyond seeing that it worked). Maybe the lag from streaming over the internet is too large for good experiences in general.
- 762236 4y agoJust played on my phone. Impressive.
- cloogshicer 4y agoAm I the only one who thinks this is super scary stuff? If in the future, all software will only run on servers, more and more control will be taken away from users. If Google shuts down the service, or bans your account with no recourse, as they like to do, everything you've purchased is gone.
- Titan2189 4y agoSooo, I take it you have 0 games purchased in your Steam account then?
- cloogshicer 4y agoAt least there you could crack it and keep it running if the service shuts down. But I agree, the dependence on Steam is concerning too.
- memorable 4y agoI like how the OP and your account both created in 2018.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoFar easier to crack in the worst case of service shutdown. At least if you have downloaded the game. Of course also not an ideal solution.
- Thaxll 4y ago
- libertine 4y agoThis is where I thought Stadia would shine - they could bring back game demos that are accessible through a link. It's like the magazines with demo CDs times all over again, where I actually tried games instead of experiencing them through the eyes of a influencer.
- ascagnel_ 4y agoIt's better than that, for developers at least. Instead of having to provide a custom build for the demo, they can ship the full game to a service like Stadia, and then Stadia can enforce a time limit on that demo.
- bogwog 4y agoThat seems like a very small value proposition. I doubt the reason we see many demos nowadays has to due with the burden of creating a custom build for the demo.
- danielvaughn 4y agoEven better, imagine the opportunities this opens up. I could see a group of friends all playing the same first person game, taking turns directly from their own browsers. Or a streamer getting frustrated with a game, and letting one of their viewers take over to help them out. Pretty cool possibilities.
- mariusmg 4y agoAmusingly bad experience when compared with "local" copy. In Stadia it loads for ~3 minutes and then it fails with a "The game couldn't start, but try opening it again now." With my PC copy, i'm playing in around 15 seconds.
- onion2k 4y agoI was playing in Chrome within about 30 seconds, with graphics looking better than my integrated-graphics-only Macbook can manage. It's quite impressive when it works.
- sumy23 4y agoI was impressed at first too, but after playing for 20 minutes, I hit multiple instances of lag and the slight delay in controls was annoying.
- berdario 4y agoI've seen this kind of issue with people who have a custom firewall setup. You probably need to configure your firewall to allow playing.
- tmpz22 4y agoThen what the heck is that error message? I’d expect that error message from a junior developer.
- Sakos 4y agoIt's not the kind of thing Google's internal metrics for job performance cares about. It's a generic/useless error message because there's no incentive for their developers to improve UX. It's probably been there since the first MVP they made.
- malka 4y agoOf course it's shit > The game had to close Sorry about that. Reopen the game to keep playing (in reality it never opened)
- tartuffe78 4y agoImpressive, but still not really playable on Safari on M1
- hombre_fatal 4y agoRight-click in Safari brings up the context menu (so you must play in Chrome) but I'm not sure it's an M1 Safari thing.
- j7ake 4y agoIt seemed to work well, but then my MacBook crashed for some reason.
- JadoJodo 4y agoI'm still unsure exactly who the market is for Stadia/streaming games. People with a console/PC are going to just buy it outright. I could see it used by someone who travels a lot, but hotels aren't going to like the massive bandwidth hit, nor will mobile carriers. The most obvious candidate is people who cannot afford a console or PC, but having just played through this demo, the graphics look like last-gen consoles anyway. I'm sure there is a use-case for this somewhere, but I can't think of it.
- mysterydip 4y agoThis person: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31693294 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31693294
- loudmax 4y agoThere are many significant benefits to streaming games. There's enormous flexibility to streaming, and it strongly lends itself to massively multiplayer online games. Stadia's problem was that Google's management worked out a platform and pricing model that undermined all of the benefits and conferred none of the advantages.
- mmargerum 4y agolaptop users
- scoopertrooper 4y agoCurrently sitting in a hotel with 282/170 mbps internet connection. I've never streamed a game before, but the demo runs beautifully, better than you'd expect possible.
- danrl 4y agoAT&T, a mobile carrier, explicitly asked their customers to stream a game. They brought online a game from the Warner Brothers catalog just for that, using the same technology. So I am not sure of the bandwidth argument holds for all mobile carriers. https://more.att.com/playnow/ https://more.att.com/playnow/ Disclaimer: I work on Stadia.
- nazgulsenpai 4y agoThere's also a free demo on Steam. https://store.steampowered.com/app/1541780/Resident_Evil_Village_Gameplay_Demo/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/1541780/Resident_Evil_Vil...
- haunter 4y agoYou can also play Fortnite permanently free in Xbox Cloud (no Gamepass sub needed). Honestly it's pretty good as far streaming goes. https://www.xbox.com/play/games/fortnite/BT5P2X999VH2 https://www.xbox.com/play/games/fortnite/BT5P2X999VH2
- edibleEnergy 4y agodang, that is slick! (Apple M1 Macbook Air)
- flatiron 4y agois it me or the official stadia controller is not listed as an option in the controller section?
- dont__panic 4y ago"Connecting" for minutes, with no visible progression feedback, then "Loading" for minutes, with no visible progression feedback. Exactly what I expected.
- sam537 4y agoI wonder how many of us got sidetracked into playing at work today.
- Sakos 4y agoThe whole cloud streaming games thing is weird to me. It seems to be something that only appeals to people who don't have any gaming devices at home. If I'm at home, where I have the best connection and it's okay to use, I have consoles and my desktop PC. If I'm not at home and I'm on my phone with a very good 5G connection (300Mbps) and fairly low latency, it feels awful. If I'm visiting a friend or at an office (in Germany), where I don't have any of my gaming devices, it's likely the internet there will be awfully slow too.
- sascha_sl 4y agoAny amount of jitter will ruin it, and mobile networks without jitter are hard to impossible. You can probably find an in between of these two extremes playing on WiFi. Most services also recommend to be connected to Ethernet outright.
- chmod775 4y agoSome mobile networks are pretty low latency compared to old copper ones. LTE here has 14ms to one of my servers, while the wired connection has 22ms. Most of this is probably owed to more modern hardware. Small amounts of jitter could be compensated for by adding some artificial latency, ad-hoc, when a connection with jitter is detected.
- Sakos 4y agoI don't think I was having issues with jitter. It was just noticeable latency for inputs. If it had been a turn-based game, it would've been fine.
- some-guy 4y agoI have an ISP in the SF Bay Area (Monkeybrains) with very good throughput for the price (I get 700 up and down, static IP, no data cap for $35/mo), but Stadia / XCloud is basically unusable due to jitter since it uses a mesh microwave network.
- jayd16 4y agoI suppose kids with parents that don't want to buy a whole console or devote the space could maybe fit into this category. Maybe Google expects gamers to be wowed away from console hardware? I don't really see it, though.
- maxfurman 4y agoVery impressive! The one-click demo works like a dream compared to the old PC Gamer demo disk. I did have some stuttering and one moment where my character kept walking for a second after I let go of the button, but not a deal breaker for a demo. The biggest technical problem I saw is that right clicks aren't fully captured (I'm using Safari 15 on Catalina) and they open a context menu over the game. If I were to keep playing this game, it wouldn't be through Stadia, for the reasons listed above. But I am much more likely to buy a copy for my PS5 than I was before. Good Job, Capcom Marketing Team!
- roansh 4y agoSlightly off topic but: It is in money’s interest to turn everything into service based model? Read some news recently that, big corps are buying up houses shooting up their prices enough that common man can’t afford them. I guess once the acquisition is large enough, they can force you to pay more money for shelter.
- honkler 4y agoeverybody loves to earn rent.
- wodenokoto 4y agoIt’s geoblocked. At least they tell you where to go. But the dream of a border less internet seemed a lot closer in the 90s than today > SORRY. CAN'T DELIVER. > Which area can I play in? You can access this streaming demo from the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, France, Italy, Germany, Austria, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Denmark, Norway, Finland, Belgium, Ireland, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Romania, and Hungary.
- fartcannon 4y agoMoney ruins everything.
- mattlondon 4y agoIt is due to the location of the servers. Outside of these regions there are no local servers so the lag would be unfavourable.
- sergiotapia 4y agoRespectfully to all the devs that poured their soul into this tech. Maybe physics and reality just make this an impossibility. I've played this game on a great PC and my PS5 and it looks incredibly good. Almost fake how good it is. On this, it's blurry and makes my eyes hurt because it's like they are trying to compensate for being out of focus. I'm in a metro area, Miami, with a gigabit fiber connection. I'm the poster child for this service but it's not good. Game streaming may just not be possible to do.
- tehlike 4y agoYou are missing a large segment. A lot of people don't care about things you care about. Most spend lots of time looking at a tiny screen and playing games there that have graphics quality of a 90s game. That's the segment you could target with more interesting games. I sometimes get bored at work, and want to do something different during lunch. This could be it. I sometimes open quakejs to play for fun. I can't install a 30G game onto my corp laptop...
- finiteseries 4y agoIt is entirely possible to do, and even surpass the quality of a local Xbox Series X: https://youtu.be/oSMt43BOyeU https://youtu.be/oSMt43BOyeU Stadia ports/limits games on top of underpowered hardware and limits the bitrate to ~44Mbit/s with a “4K” stream, ~30 with 1080p. It was amazing 2 years ago or so, it’s quite far behind competing services like GeForce Now nowadays with double the bitrate, true 4K streaming, ray tracing, Steam/Epic support etc.
- sergiotapia 4y agoYou were correct. Geforce Now feels like a generation ahead of Stadia oh my god.
- finiteseries 4y agoIt’s incredible, happy to spread the good word. Highly recommend the 3080 tier and playing with the GFN app streaming settings & any in-game visual settings as well, the default configs can be a little conservative!
- TheDesolate0 4y ago
- EamonnMR 4y agoCompared to the steamed games we saw back in the day (~2012) this is hugely impressive. Felt smooth and responsive enough on a mobile connection. In fact, it played better than in home steam streaming over wifi did. Granted, I still hate the idea of not owning anything anymore, but technically this is very impressive. Kinda like a really well executed prank by a school bully.
- FpUser 4y agoCrashed but the intro was responsive
- sylware 4y agoSaaS is an efficient way to force ppl and companies to pay a monthly rent. They will change file formats to work with only SaaS then slowly kill standalone apps. But some of the SaaS mafia will not want to depend on the client software from google and will have to code their own. Chrome is google lock-in by complexity and size, SDK included. Yep, this makes me feel very uncomfortable, this is a significant loss of control.
- unsignednoop 4y ago>SORRY. CAN'T DELIVER. Can I just say that I adore Jenglish? These silly translations have become less common though with better translation apps available.
- orloffm 4y agoI've used Nvidia GeForce Now recently, and turned out that the lag issue can be pretty much mitigated by buying the 19.99$ subscription and switching to 120FPS. Games render at that framerate internally, and somehow it's much, much more responsive than the default 60FPS, even with V-Sync off. Highly recommend to anyone.
- numlock86 4y agoHow come Google hasn't shut down Stadia yet? Serious question, no rant. Early adopter here. Service has a terrible pricing model and business numbers since the start.
- colinplamondon 4y agoThis might be what that looks like. (1) Kill the subscription (2) Immediate Priority: Biz-dev deals, make sure every major release's early demo is available on Stadia. Expose people to platform without requiring them to switch from a console. (3) Secondary Priority: Focus SDK development on indie developers. Offer generous streamed minutes for all developer accounts. Charge per streamed minute after that. Let developers pass on the cost however they want. With open pricing, open enrollment, open SDK, developers could do really amazing things with Stadia: and would figure out the business model. Google could focus on driving down the cost per streamed minute as low as humanly possible, with the broadest possible access. Amazon certainly will.
- morelisp 4y ago> Focus SDK development on indie developers. Offer generous streamed minutes for all developer accounts. Charge per streamed minute after that. This would be horrible for everyone involved. First you're focusing on games that wouldn't need the high-end hardware in the datacenter to begin with, and second your revenue model incentivizes the worst possible mobile game style grind. Google would burn through players as fast as possible most of whom would eventually turn to just playing on their iPad directly, developers would have to deal with yet another middleman, and players would get addicted to the shittiest games imaginable.
- mupuff1234 4y agoMaybe they believe the tech itself can play an important role in the future, perhaps in AR/VR so it's worth keeping stadia alive as a testing ground. But most likely they're fully aware of the reputation Google has and they'd rather put stadia on life support for a few years.
- bogwog 4y agoThis is a good demo for the game, but I personally wouldn't play it like this. I tried it on a 27 inch 1080p monitor, and it looked really bad. The compression artifacts were clearly visible in dark areas, and there was a lot of aliasing. I think it may have been running at sub-1080p with upscaling. The camera felt sluggish, but tbf that's probably from the game itself. I own this game on Steam, but haven't played it in a while so I don't remember exactly how it feels. For a high fidelity cinematic AAA game like this, the latency isn't a big deal, but the low quality visuals are hard to accept. The "load" time was also worse than launching my local copy. Sure, I didn't have to download it, but considering you need a pretty fast internet connection to use Stadia at all, you probably shouldn't have a hard time downloading the game anyways.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> compression artifacts It's bad enough having to accept this from streaming services... Now video games as well? It's like we're going backwards.
- dopeboy 4y agoI just ran a AAA title game at, let's call it 90% quality, on a laptop with an onboard intel GPU. This is unequivocally moving forwards.
- hbn 4y agoI don't have the greatest internet ever (50 down, 5 up I think?) but it's well within what they claim to be acceptable. I hate everything about the idea of purchasing games that you can only stream, but when they were offloading free Stadia Premiere Editions (controller + Chromecast Ultra) to Google Play Music subscribers I grabbed one and committed myself to playing through a game entirely just to say I gave it a fair shot. I chose Superhot: Mind Control Delete which is a game where you go around a kill a bunch of mannequins that are trying to kill you, but time only moves forward when you do (meaning you can stand still and the game is nearly paused). I managed to make it through the whole game, but there wasn't a single play session where I didn't have multiple spikes of lag, or a several seconds of frozen frames that take a bit to catch up. Thankfully because of the nature of the game I was able to just stop moving and I'd usually be safe by the time the game was working again, but it wasn't a good experience. If it was any other game that required constant twitch-reaction throughout the gameplay, those lag spikes wouldn't be acceptable. Even if it works well 99.9999% of the time, that 0.0001% where it's not working is frustrating, and not something you have to deal with playing locally. The idea that someone else in your house could kick off a giant download that suddenly makes your game unplayable feels like we've regressed to the days of dial-up where your mom kicks you off the internet because she needs to make a phone call.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoI'm gaming using the excellent shadow tech service. I have fiber, and playing nervous games like hades work great. But I would not play lol, dota, falling guy or call of duty with it. The latency, no matter small, is a handicap when timing win or break a game.
- random_moonwalk 4y agoVery cool. Script a bit awkward though judging by the intro - 'Daughter?... Oh yes my daughter who I have travelled to this remote village to find, now I remember.'
- dmix 4y agoI've been using Xbox Cloud for months on my Macbook, Android TV, and iPhone with an Xbox controller and it's been amazing. I never experience lag on my fiber connection. I'm happy I didn't bother buying an Xbox. For everything else I have a remote Windows box on https://paperspace.com https://paperspace.com which even lets you stream VR games to my Oculus Quest via Parsec. Stadia works fine but the Xbox is way more affordable, Stadia's 'pro' game selection is weak, while Xbox has had far more games with one single price and new ones come on multiple times a month.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gundmc 4y agoAgreed - Microsoft's ability to stream anything that runs on XBox vs Stadia's Linux requirement means XBox Cloud's selection is miles ahead. I have a powerful gaming PC, but use streaming as a console replacement for games not on PC. I've used Stadia and XBox for streaming and while I prefer Stadia's tech, I spend 99% of my time on XBox due to game library (particularly MLB the Show).
- starstripe 4y agoI tried Stadia and really wanted to like it but I cannot get over the input lag. I play a lot of FPS so it really matters. Even in this demo I feel my aim is way off because of the input lag. I also get motion sickness with this input lag.
- smarkov 4y agoI also experienced a good amount of motion sickness, likely attributed to the input lag but also due to the narrow field of view which I couldn't find an option to change.
- redox99 4y agoWhen I played RE Village I used a trainer ("cheat software") to increase the FOV, because it was giving me motion sickness. And I have never in my entire life felt motion sickness when playing a game (and I play all the time).
- mentos 4y agoYea but there are virtually no cheaters on streamed games so might be a worthy tradeoff?
- bb010g 4y agoIf I'm playing Risk of Rain 2 on Stadia, why do I want to restrict myself from modding? Not every FPS is competitively multiplayer.
- georgia_peach 4y agoPro: I couldn't tell that it wasn't native. Con: On Linux, it pegged my CPU worse than native. I guess this is more of a revenue-guarding technology than a practical one. For people who care about truth and posterity, having a disconnected "final" copy is an indispensable testament--even for toys like video games. Without that, "creators" will make "adjustments"--for not-so-altruistic purposes--and act as though they had never expressed such things in the first place. The number of internet articles I have seen "disappeared" in the past 10 years is chilling. It is no comfort that technology has made real-time editing of history economical for interactive media as well.
- hartator 4y agoI mean it's super impressive but there is still a noticeable lag. I don't fully get the vision behind it. GPUs - even mobile ones - can power these kind of graphics for comparable or less power consumption. And the future is even brighter with M1/M2 chips and progress in the like. But the lag issue to have server side rendered graphics will never be solved. As it's a physics constraint. Maybe for a new kind of massive multiplayer games made possible by having everyone on server side graphics? But it doesn't seem to be the way these services try to work on.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- daenz 4y agoIt seems like Google really underestimates the experience of lag. It's a deal breaker for many gamers. Yes, this is a super impressive demo, but having your screen glitch and lag frequently is infuriating enough to quit.
- Shank 4y ago> I don't fully get the vision behind it. GPUs - even mobile ones - can power these kind of graphics for comparable or less power consumption. And the future is even brighter with M1/M2 chips and progress in the like. From a cynical point-of-view, I actually kinda see the thinking. Aside from latency, this is actually a pretty good demo. If you look at games like gacha games and more recently Diablo Immortal as not video-games, but value extraction systems, getting it in the hands of as many people as possible is the thing you want. If you can deliver a compelling experience without needing the user to invest upfront in hardware, you can immediately start charging them and getting them in the funnel. Honestly, the chip shortage is a pretty compelling argument for Stadia, on its own. The catch is that Stadia didn't invest heavily in GPU power, so it doesn't deliver quite the compelling vision that's needed to compete with latest generation GPUs. If Stadia was the equivalent of a datacenter of 3090 Ti cards though, I think it would've actually done quite well when GPUs were extraordinarily expensive for people who just wanted to play a couple hours of games every week.
- shadowgovt 4y ago
- dvh 4y agoWell, I never really played any AA or AAA game, but even though it is janky and slow, barely playable really, I think it would help me to decide if I want to buy this game or not. Slightly better than watching playthrough on youtube.
- rowanG077 4y agoOof. What a bad experience. The video quality is pretty bad for smaller details. And the latency while looking around is nauseating for me. All this while on a wired gigabit connection that is reported as excellent. Only games I see having a good experience is slow paced games were immediate feedback is not required. Think turn-based combat games, or card games. One on hand I'm sad this technology still is unuseable after years of research. But on the other hand a future where everything is running remote on BigCo servers is very bleak.
- hokkos 4y agounplayable, the lag makes me dizzy, and the poor quality of the image is ugly and I have a 300mbit connexion.