4 ms·
HN's readership isn't homogeneous. There's room for both points of view. I've done a lot of useful work in feedback systems without ever really grokking Lapla
by CamperBob2 4y ago
HN's readership isn't homogeneous. There's room for both points of view.
I've done a lot of useful work in feedback systems without ever really grokking Laplacian notation and the notion of complex frequency in general. A lot of the actual numerical methods used in real life boil down to a few canned formulas. But I know enough about the underlying theory to appreciate where the canned formulas come from, and fully intend to sit down some day and go through the whole process. Articles like this are interesting if only for the occasional gems in the comments, such as John N.'s pointer to Maxwell's 'On Governors' paper that I'd never run across before.
At the same time, I don't see much upside in making hiring decisions on the basis of whether someone can regurgitate a bunch of textbook math. I'd rather spend the interview talking about control problems the candidate has dealt with personally, how they were handled, and what the candidate learned from them.