2 ms·
I just can't really feel any animosity toward Gary Bowser (or his business partners) here. The amount that Nintendo "lost" is probably a couple orders of magni
by kelnos 4y ago
I just can't really feel any animosity toward Gary Bowser (or his business partners) here. The amount that Nintendo "lost" is probably a couple orders of magnitude less than the damages that Nintendo claims. An illegally-obtained copy of something does not equal a lost sale! It's of course not surprising, but is ultimately gross, that rightsholders keep trying to claim that every unauthorized copy is one that the recipient would have paid for if it hadn't been available illegally, when we know at this point that's far far far from the truth. The vast majority of people who obtain illegal copies would never pay in the first place.
I think it would suck if a small creator got screwed over to this degree by a group of infringers like this. But the true loss to Nintendo here is far less than it costs them to litigate, and is a rounding error when compared to their total revenue numbers over the years involved here. It's only profitable for them to litigate because they're able to obtain awards in such ridiculous excess of their actual damages.
I don't think I'm really strictly in favor of this sort of organized copying, especially for profit. But I just can't get even a tiny bit riled up about it, either. I think, up to a certain point, companies should be forced to just accept this sort of thing as a cost of doing business. Sure, figuring out what that certain point is might be really difficult to agree on. But I think this particular case falls well below that point. Remember that copyright is a social and legal construct. It's up to the public to decide what rights it confers, and what remedies are available to rightsholders who feel harmed by infringers. There's nothing inherently "correct" about the rent-seeking behavior our current laws enable.
- WoahNoun 4y ago>An illegally-obtained copy of something does not equal a lost sale Not one to one, but easy availability of pirated content certainly results in a non-zero number of lost sales. So then the argument is about the size of the damages and not whether damages exist.
- mojzu 4y agoThere's also an argument to be made that piracy increases sales in some cases, most of my music/game/tv/film tastes as an adult can largely be traced back to content I pirated as a teenager who didn't have money to spend. Now most of my spending on entertainment either goes to artists/franchises that I was introduced to via piracy, or on services that are more convenient then piracy (Steam, Apple Music, Netflix, etc.)
- shkkmo 4y ago> The amount that Nintendo "lost" is probably a couple orders of magnitude less than the damages that Nintendo claims. That seems unlikely. The group made millions of dollars over the years which would probably make it at most a single order of magnitude overestimate. That said, I am not a big fan of copyright or the DMCA provisons that this conviction was obtained for.
- Asooka 4y agoNintendo: has record profits. Also Nintendo: We arE loSiNg gaJiLLionS to pIraCy
- stewx 4y agoThose are not contradictory statements, even if their claimed losses are exaggerated.