3 ms·
This is a genuine question. Is there a defense of cryptocurrencies that doesn't follow the pattern of, "yes, that is indeed true, however here is an edge case o
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
This is a genuine question. Is there a defense of cryptocurrencies that doesn't follow the pattern of, "yes, that is indeed true, however here is an edge case or counterexample which either doesn't exist yet, or is not in wide use so it's not actually a problem"?
Every article or comment defending cryptocurrencies has followed this pattern and it isn't convincing to me. I'd love to have my mind changed, but when every rebuttal follows the same script, I remain am unmoved.
- toolz 4y agowhich argument do you find to be an "edge case"? My main argument in favor of crypto is the democratization of finance and leveling the playing field, which as we can already see crypto generally only has real benefits to the poor - for rich it's just a speculative play, but for the poor it can mean the difference between getting paid across borders without corruption stealing your money or being able to save wealth when banks won't help you out of lock you out.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThe general form is that crypto can't do X. The response is that an obscure implementation Y does do X. The problem is that Y, while existing, largely doesn't address X in practice because Y's trading volume and/or market cap is insignificant. I guess to your point. How much corruption is avoided, and how much wealth is being saved that would otherwise be locked out? Without the means to quantify it, it feels like another, "this is theoretically possible"-type argument in the same way. The answer I expect to get is, "No one knows, but it is possible." I guess I'll keep waiting to be convinced. There are a lot of great things that are theoretically possible. Still waiting on them.
- yellowapple 4y ago> The general form is that crypto can't do X. The response is that an obscure implementation Y does do X. The problem is that Y, while existing, largely doesn't address X in practice because Y's trading volume and/or market cap is insignificant. Sure, but this presupposes that Y's trading volume and/or market cap are indeed actually insignificant. A lot of people make that presupposition, but it's often about as accurate as a drunk chimpanzee playing darts. Proof-of-stake is the case-in-point: "but but Ethereum hasn't switched yet so therefore PoS is obscure", quoth the "skeptic", entirely ignoring that multiple of the top 10 cryptocurrencies by market cap and/or transaction volume are already proof-of-stake and have been for some time now. Even taking that presupposition at face value, what's experimental today is less so tomorrow. That experimental solutions do exist bodes well for the state of things even months (let alone years, let alone decades) from now. If you want to wait until then, then you do you; meanwhile, those of us willing to experiment will do so.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoCool. What percent of market cap and trading volume do they sum to?
- everfree 4y agoI think it's a fair script to use against arguments of the form "cryptocurrencies will never amount to anything". I would hazard to say that it's not the criticism of the current state of cryptocurrency that irks most of its proponents - most of them agree that it's not very useful currently. However, it becomes problematic when you take that valid criticism of the technology's current state and use it to support the conclusion that the entire tech is a permanent dead end. That problematic reasoning is what this article's really speaking out against. If you want your mind changed that cryptocurrency is currently useful, I can't help you there. But if you want your mind changed that many of the drawbacks of blockchain technology are not as insurmountable as detractors would have you believe, the article does a good job of laying out points in favor of that.
- kelseyfrog 4y ago> If you want your mind changed that cryptocurrency is currently useful, I can't help you there. But if you want your mind changed that many of the drawbacks of blockchain technology are not as insurmountable as detractors would have you believe. Let me summarize the sentiment to see if I'm understanding: "I'm excited about crypto now because of what crypto could be in the future." To me it feels like being really excited about technology X because technology X+n might fix the problems with technology X. I just can't get behind that as a general principle. I've been hypeburned too much and I just don't have it in me anymore.
- everfree 4y agoIt's a less prescriptive sentiment than that. It's your right to not be excited about cryptocurrency, and your reasoning is fair enough. Also, the article does a good job of clearing up misinformation about what cryptocurrency is intrinsically incapable of. I don't think those two things are in conflict.
- yellowapple 4y agoI'm excited about space exploration now because of what it could be in the future. I'm excited about various up-and-coming programming languages and operating systems and such because of what they could be in the future. Why shouldn't I be excited about crypto because of what it could be in the future?
- fsflover 4y agoThis is also how almost any technology can be dismissed.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoGreat. But let's agree that the opposite is also false. Rather, a technology should be judged against its present merits. As an extreme example: A: I have cancer - just a few months yet to live with the currently developed treatments. B: That's actually not a problem because cancer treatments might get better in the future. Should A feel great instead? No. The converse is that any technology can be accepted. Future merits or lack of future merits are simply not a justifiable measure by which a current technology should be judged. It's as absurd. Just as absurd as saying, "You should like natto today because some day natto might taste better."
- fsflover 4y agoAs a non-extreme example: My government can seize all my funds in my bank and/or put any local currency exchange rate to dollar that they please. Should I fight them, move, or just buy some crypto which cannot be controlled by any single entity? You will ask how I'm going to spend it and this will miss the point: safe storage of assets is also important. (And I can trade crypto with friends for cash, too)
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI won't ask that because I'm already checked out debating the details. I'm more interested in the metadebate. The amount of kettle logic that occurs in these types of discussions inevitably leads to that. I wish there was a way to talk about crypto holistically, but discussions about externalities get detoured into discussions about counter-examples, which get detoured into discussions about value, which get detoured into discussions about monetary policy. Every complaint is met with a just-so rebuttal that brings in a new dimension of justification. Cryptoskeptics end up being defeated by attrition. It's a fine way to cinch a debate rhetorically, but lousy at changing people's minds. I guess that's the rub, people just drop out which looks like a win. I wish cryptoenthusiasts saw how that happens. They could make better arguments.