3 ms·
I’ve worked in government, small and large corporate in many capacities over a period of years. Most of this is bunk. The government is really good at operatio
by Spooky23 4y ago
I’ve worked in government, small and large corporate in many capacities over a period of years.
Most of this is bunk. The government is really good at operations and incredible at capital spending and management. In general, operations in larger government entities are documented, audited and executed to a standard only found in regulated industries. Even then, companies suck too - look at Bank of America losing millions in cash due to incompetence and poor controls as an example.
The government’s key weaknesses are around change, which is difficult, and governance, which limits the ability of professional managers to run their business. At the Federal level, Congress tightly controls appropriations and sets priorities. Sometimes that means that the full resources of the US are deployed at a target, other times that means that a critical problem goes unsolved because the program is starved of resources.
Witnessing how COVID response was managed in different states was both horrifying and inspiring. You get the government you want.
All of that was enabled by the massive mobilization of Federal resources. The Trump administration, which suffered from many self-inflicted crises and issue with ability to execute, was able to leverage the bureaucracy to get the response going. In short, the US government accomplished something incredible through the pandemic. The capability is there, but the politics drive inaction.
- ryathal 4y agoIn my experience with government for every great example there is another where huge amounts of time an money are wasted on paperwork and audits to prove money isn't being wasted or misspent. Government is also great at creating the appearance of work or progress, but rarely delivery of true value.
- carapace 4y agoI wish I could upvote this comment twice. People are assuming the hypothesis but I don't think it stands up in the first place. Here in SF we just replaced a bridge and are in the middle of diggin a big ol' tunnel but you still find people complaining that "we don't build". We build. We have also already built most of the stuff we need (e.g. SF Bay Area has all the bridges we need already.) And also things are more complex now, and we know more about the consequences of our actions, so we're more cautious (e.g. environmental reviews, etc.) There are some progressives who seem to put ideology above effective action but they don't last (e.g the DA who just got recalled. He did some good work but he couldn't get the daily job done so he's out.)