5 ms·
I don't understand this argument at all. Why are New York and California so hell bent on keeping Texas in the union and telling it what to do? It seems to me th
by rayiner 4y ago
I don't understand this argument at all. Why are New York and California so hell bent on keeping Texas in the union and telling it what to do? It seems to me that it would be preferable to them for red states to leave the union, so that blue states can have universal healthcare and government-funded abortions.
I think this is actually at the root of why America's administrative capacity has become so weak. Administrators are, for want of a better phrase, not content to stay in their lane, and try to smuggle other ideological baggage through their administration, which breeds resentment and resistance. Transportation planners are not content to build the roads people want, but want to make people take trains instead. Educators and public health experts think it's their job to weigh on race relations. The administrative class has always been haughty, since its inception in the Wilson era, but now they've found religion and become evangelical about it.
- tomjakubowski 4y agoInterstate commerce is more important to society than either issue.
- vkou 4y ago> I don't understand this argument at all. Why are New York and California so hell bent on keeping Texas in the union and telling it what to do? No particular state is more hell-bent on keeping Texas in the union than Texas. All of the Texan talk of secession is just virtue signaling and pea-cocking, intended to drive the voter base to show up to the polls.
- rootusrootus 4y agoFor one, the construct of "red states" and "blue states" is wrong. It would be more like city states. Texas is barely hanging on to the idea that it is a "red state" as you would call it. A bit more domestic migration to the cities and it could easily become another "blue state." Most states that appear to lean in either direction at the governmental level have very substantial opposition voter populations. This is the biggest reason nobody is seriously going to consider secession, aside of rhetoric for the base.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThis still doesn't explain why states are so hell bent on regulating policy within other states instead of letting them make and learn from their own policy decisions
- rootusrootus 4y agoI cannot answer that. It is obviously bipartisan, however, because conservative state legislatures are attempting to regulate abortion access in other states.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI know there are periodic federal bills, but how are state legislatures regulating access across state lines? Is this issue of local residents that travel for it?
- everforward 4y agoThey're regulating local citizens that travel, which still has jurisdictional issues afaik. E.g. a state can't generally file charges against a citizen for possession of marijuana if the possession occurred in another state. I'm not sure what happens in the case of an abortion provider from a legal state visiting an illegal state. My suspicion is that they might try and be rebuked on jurisdictional grounds. It's an even weaker case than local citizen travel, since no part of the acts occurred inside the jurisdiction.
- rayiner 4y agoI assume the theory is that the fetus is a Texan and the state has an interest in protecting them.
- rayiner 4y agoNo they’re not. A few are trying to regulate their citizens traveling to other states to get abortions. Meanwhile the mainstream position on the left is imposing a standard that under 30% of Americans support (elective abortions to 24 weeks) in every single state.
- pg_bot 4y agoAnyone with a brain understands that we are stronger together than apart. People who advocate for leaving the union should be seen for what they are, children throwing a tantrum. Do you think most Americans on either side would want to deal with border checkpoints, different currencies, nuclear proliferation, tariffs, property disputes, and a myriad of other issues that would come with leaving the union? While we have disagreements, the American people are not particularly divided on the major issues.
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoTexas went for Trump over Biden by a margin of about 630,000 votes in a state with a population of close to 30 million. That's a really tight margin for New York and California to decide to cut the whole state loose. Another factoid: Biden got 5,244,886 votes in New York and 5,259,126 votes in Texas. In other words, more people voted for Biden in Texas than in New York.
- rayiner 4y agoThat analysis incorrectly treats Biden and Trump voters as homogenous, which isn’t true. I’ll use Georgia as an example because I lived there. Georgia Democrats are quite different than San Francisco Democrats. Throughout the 2000s state level politics was pretty amiable, with conservative democrats in Atlanta more or less getting along with republicans at the state level: https://www.ajc.com/blog/politics/the-bipartisan-duo-strikes-again-deal-taps-reed-wife-coveted-post/eTQP7ZAY3RZfN8JLL5QDwK/ https://www.ajc.com/blog/politics/the-bipartisan-duo-strikes... That changed recently when the state became the target of national politics. Suddenly, the folks on the other side of the aisle were not Georgia Democrats, but California and New York Democrats. That created a ton of polarization that didn’t exist before. Right now, our national politics pits California and New York Democrats against Mississippi Republicans, and the rest of us just have to pick a side. Things would be far less polarized if we split up, and it was California Democrats versus California Republicans and Texas Democrats versus Texas Republicans. Here in Maryland, we have an extremely popular Republican governor that does Republican stuff like oppose public transit and try to keep taxes low. State politics is quite civil, because Baltimore isn’t San Francisco (despite voting similarly for Biden) but neither is Carroll County Mississippi (despite voting similarly for Trump).
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoI'm not entirely sure what you're saying but it sounds like your theory is that Texan and Georgian voters were hornswoggled by New York and California carpetbaggers so their votes somehow don't matter for this discussion. The plain fact is that as of 2020 approximately as many Texan voters wanted Biden as Trump, to where a 3% shift would have changed the result. Those voters could have stayed home but they went in and cast a ballot. Talking about secession on that margin is ridiculous. Also, if you're using New York and California Democrats as a proxy for left-wing voters, Biden is pretty disappointing on that front. A huge part of why Biden was the nominee was specifically so he could appeal to centrist voters. The fact that Texan and Georgian voters voted for someone who was picked partly to appeal to those same people should not be surprising.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Why are New York and California so hell bent on keeping Texas in the union They aren't. It's not 1860, no one is campaigning on preserving the Union over other policy considerations. While there would be intense disputes about how to treat people who didn't want to be separated from the US, and about disposition of federal property in the event of a divorce, few in NY or CA outside of the Republican minority in each state would expend even the slightest effort on keeping Texas in the Union as such, though they might oppose bad divorce terms on those other issues. On the other hand, all the other Republican-led states would oppose the idea fiercely, because it would be a giant shift away from the Republican Party in the national balance of political power. (And, yes, Texas is far from solid red by population, but that's not what matters.)
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoPeople in these states would care if secession were seriously on the table, since a lot of them have personal connections to the state and will not be like "Oh, I guess my parents are going to be in a different country now, no big deal," especially if said parents very much don't want their state to secede.
- rayiner 4y ago> They aren't. Then why do they care so much about abortion laws in Texas, or whether Texas expands Medicaid, etc? Really, why do they care about the federal government at all? Historically, Democrats cared about the federal government because Republicans states like California had the money and they needed the federal government to redistribute it. But today, Democrat states have the money. So what’s the point? Why not just adopt universal healthcare in California without regard to what Texas does?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Then why do they care so much about abortion laws in Texas Because Texas is in the Union, and what is Constitutionally allowed in Texas is what is Constitutionally allowed in their state, and they don't assume that they will have a permanent legislative majority there, because, well, history shows that they likely won't. Other than that Californians care about rights in Texas the same.way they care about rights in Saudi Arabia.