7 ms·
In reality the states that are most outwardly in favor of small/no federal government and "states' rights" are also the ones that benefit most from federal spen
by paxys 4y ago
In reality the states that are most outwardly in favor of small/no federal government and "states' rights" are also the ones that benefit most from federal spending. Don't buy into the campaign speeches too much. The federal government is only going to keep getting stronger. There's too much money in it for everyone involved.
- gowld 4y agoThere's no contradiction in wanting both (a) other people's money, but not (b) other people's rules. This is a natural mentality.
- rayiner 4y agoThat's rational. What's irrational is w hen blue states get mad at red states for not taking their money.
- dwater 4y agoNot if it ends up costing more in the long run, like when instead of spending money on prevention it must be spent on disaster recovery. If the agreement was "We won't give you this money now, and we won't rescue you later when it turns out you would have needed it" the attitude might be different.
- rayiner 4y agoIf any state is going to be demanding a federal bail out anytime soon it’s going to be blue states like Illinois and New York facing catastrophic pension burdens coming due.
- tptacek 4y agoThe federal government probably should not bail out IL and NY's pension systems, which are mismanaged. But have you done the math on this red/blue net dependency thing? I pulled up the numbers on proposed and theoretical pension bailouts, and then the net federal dependency numbers for red states, and it does not appear to be a close call. But I didn't look very carefully. Did you? Illinois has the highest tax burden in the country. We're not Greece. We are paying through the nose for, well, everything. We get 95 cents on the dollar for our federal taxes, and we pay a lot of those. Texas is a lower-tax state. It is, in some ways, better managed than Illinois. But it gets 20 cents back on every dollar it pays in federal taxes. It seems to me that the reason not to bail out pension systems is that they're long-term unsustainable, and that they're mismanaged, and something has to be done to stop the bleeding. But it's hard to argue that bailing them out would be a redistributive injustice. We subsidize the low-tax red states. (A comically similar microcosm of this debate occurs within Illinois, with rural Illinoisans regularly making noise about wanting to divest itself of Chicagoland. Go right ahead, Peoria!)
- TrispusAttucks 4y agoAnd also (c) paying other people's taxes. Reduction of the fed may be the only way to ever meaningfully address national debt.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- themitigating 4y agoInstincts and "natural mentality" can be contradictory.
- TimPC 4y agoYeah most of the states opposed to the federal government would never lead because they get a large amount of equalization type payments due to various measures on which they perform worse than successful states. It's nearly impossible to leave a government you don't really approve of if they are transferring a large amount of money into your local economy.
- splitrocket 4y agoI wouldn't bet against dumb in the short run: see brexit.
- TimPC 4y agoIt's a different sort of dumb. Britain didn't get more from the EU than it paid in, it was one of the wealthier countries in the EU.
- azmodeus 4y agoBritain was wealthy when it left. When it joined the EU it was the poorest member joining.
- Tagbert 4y agoAre you sure of that characterization that the UK was the poorest member when it joined? That seems incorrect. The UK has always been one of the stronger economies in the European zone.
- HWR_14 4y agoIn 1972 the UK still hadn't recovered economically from WWII, and the other members of the EU at the time were France, West Germany, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Belgium and Italy. With the possible exception of Italy, all those are (per capita) economic powerhouses.
- 4y ago
- astockwell 4y agoUnfortunately the public within the states that benefit most from federal spending are constantly told the opposite by their leaders. Similar situation with water rights, and several other tragedies of the commons.
- rayiner 4y agoMaybe consider that the desire of groups of people to be in charge of decisions that affect them, instead of submitting to the decisions of far away rulers, overrides for many people the desire for free money. Many people, for example, want Puerto Rico to be independent, even though they undoubtedly would get more free money if they became a state.
- skinnymuch 4y agoOr consider most people are being tricked as the other person was saying.
- tengbretson 4y agoThat federal spending is done perpetually at a budget deficit though. Is it so difficult to believe that a state couldn't also figure out how to build a money printer?
- 1270018080 4y agoThe federal money printer is backed by the strength of the national economy. How would the money printer backed by the states ranked at the bottom in GDP per capita, lifespan, education etc. fare? I can't imagine that going well.
- rayiner 4y agoI assume it would be fine. Iowa’s GDP is bigger than Greece and it’s GDP per capita is comparable to Norway’s. Mississippi’s GDP per capita is higher than France’s.
- cudgy 4y agoYet France provides far more social services to its citizens with less money per capita than Mississippi. I guess the difference is mainly due to immense spending on defense and medical care.
- rayiner 4y agoDefense is a drop in the bucket, 3.5% of GDP in the US versus 2% in France. The difference is taxes and what people have let after taxes. France’s taxes are 45% of GDP, versus 25% in the US. The French have universal healthcare, but Americans have bigger trucks and more TVs. And based on their voting patterns, they prefer it this way, whatever you think about their priorities.
- native_samples 4y agoHaving been to a French hospital and having been shocked by what I saw there, I wouldn't assume that more spending automatically equals more services.
- systemvoltage 4y agoCan you substantiate this or provide citations? Which states and how do you quantify "benefiting" from federal spending?
- 1270018080 4y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/o1v3xl/oc_which_states_give_more_than_they_receive_per/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/o1v3xl/oc_... maybe this thought process?
- systemvoltage 4y agoI am even less convinced now. Seems like a mixed bag.
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoWhich part is a mixed bag?
- skinnymuch 4y agoIt can’t be a mixed bag when it’s so heavily tilted with the blue states being better.
- downrightmike 4y agoThose states benefit from Fed money because they have multiple century debt from lack of investment. "States Rights" is just about slavery and wanting it back, but that won't solve their problems with the investment they already are not doing and are unwilling to do.
- pclmulqdq 4y ago"States Rights" was about slavery in the 1860s, but I doubt that most people who are into small government today want slavery back.
- UnpossibleJim 4y agoThat was a large part of it, but it also had to do with taxation over building highways for trade in the north while the south had ample waterways to move trade goods... I'm not saying it wasn't about slavery as well, before anyone gets mad. EDIT: https://medium.com/@jonathanusa/everything-you-know-about-the-civil-war-is-wrong-9e94f0118269 https://medium.com/@jonathanusa/everything-you-know-about-th...
- downrightmike 4y agoThose people who want small government always expand governmental powers when they are in charge. Example 1: Look at what the SCOTUS just did about the 4th amendment having no power for 100 miles inland from the border.
- rayiner 4y agoThis is a remarkably bad argument. Many countries around the world have some sort of federal system. People who agree with each other enough to participate in some level of government together, but not enough to participate in a unitary government together, is a common problem that exists around the world. Federalism is a solution to that problem around the world. Germany, for example, has "state's rights." Religious people in Bavaria decided that government buildings should display crosses (https://www.cnn.com/2018/05/31/europe/bavaria-germany-crosses-public-buildings-intl/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/05/31/europe/bavaria-germany-crosse...) and folks in Berlin don't get to veto that. When German press asked Angela Merkel why she wouldn't order a nationwide COVID lockdown, she explained German federalism, and the German press (which is much smarter than the American press) nodded and moved on. India features states that differ quite significantly in their healthcare systems or social laws. In Switzerland, a country the size of Maryland, laws on same-sex marriage differ between cantons until national consensus was reached less than two years ago. America is a country of 330 million people, and far more diverse than Germany or Switzerland. Why should we ignore the real need for flexibility and localism just because some people who are long dead abused federalism?
- CJefferson 4y agoBrexit showed how politicians can lose control of their campaign speeches -- I personally do not believe it was what any senior politicians actually wanted.
- tablespoon 4y ago> In reality the states that are most outwardly in favor of small/no federal government and "states' rights" are also the ones that benefit most from federal spending. It's worth noting that the issue gets confused because of the makeup of the political coalitions in the US. Namely the party of "small government" is a coalition of social conservatives (who often are fine with government spending, so long as it's not forcing liberal social policy on them), and economic libertarians (who care deeply about low taxes and less business regulation, but aren't as sensitive to liberal social policy). The social conservatives bring the votes, but party has historically prioritized the policy of the libertarians. Until relatively recently, it was actually pretty common for the states you speak of to send socially conservative Democrats to Congress. Over the last 15 or so years, the Republicans successfully exploited the compromises those Democrats were often forced to make with an officially socially-liberal party to defeat them electorally. Also, as an anecdote, one of these states (North Dakota) could probably legitimately claim to be one of the most socialist states in the country. It literally has a couple major state-owned businesses. If you took social issues off the table, I think you'll see those states behave much differently.
- Tagbert 4y agothose social issues have often been used as drivers for support by politicians who use that support to push "libertarian" legislation.
- codefreeordie 4y agoIt's a hell of a bargain, though -- we'll destroy your economy, attack you population, but give you money so you're not as dirt poor as we would have otherwise made you.
- cudgy 4y agoCalifornia? What other states have wanted to secede recently?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> California? What other states have wanted to secede recently? California did not want to secede. A Russian-linked group tried repeatedly over the 2016 to 2020 period to get an initiative for an independence referendum on to the ballot in the state, but never managed to qualify the initiative, much less pass the initiative calling for an independence referendum.
- leereeves 4y ago> also the ones that benefit most from federal spending The analyses that draw this conclusion leave a lot out. By narrowing the discussion to spending, they ignore the many benefits of federal policy for corporations based in the big cities in a few states. A few industries come to mind that would make a lot less money if federal policy were different: banks, pharma, entertainment, and even technology.