10 ms·
Mass-scale Cold Fusion either becomes reality or proved a scam today
- Pent 15y agoA better source of info than what I linked previously: Live updates from the test @ http://freeenergytruth.blogspot.com/2011/10/ecat-1mw-test-update-thread.html http://freeenergytruth.blogspot.com/2011/10/ecat-1mw-test-up...
- mechanical_fish 15y agoI don't buy this either-or headline. Either the magic trick is going to impress the audience, or there will be claims of some sort of tragic last-minute technical difficulty that could be worked around with a bit more research. Either way, the game is likely to continue. Maybe one mark or another will drop out of the con, having endured one too many cycles of investment followed by disappointment, but there are new marks being born every day. Perpetual motion machines are a really old dream. The dream outlived Clausius, Kelvin, and Carnot and it will outlive us. Dreams are durable.
- ck2 15y agoBut the claim is not that the output energy will be a "little bit more" than the input - the claim is it should be obviously much more. So there has to be a clear result, where no amount of tweaking will fix the base principle if it's erroneous?
- mechanical_fish 15y agoOh, there is always a third option in science: "Oops, the box would have given us a definitive yes-or-no answer if only the fuse hadn't blown, and gosh darn it, the local stores have no fuses in stock. Oh, and these fuses are special and cost $750,000." You'll learn all about this phenomenon in years two through six of your seven-year Ph.D. program in experimental physics. ;)
- thyrsus 15y agoI learned it in my first year physics course: to a good approximation, accuracy of results = log(log($equipment_cost)).
- jmaygarden 15y agoSo, 100% accuracy cost $10 billion?
- dfranke 15y agoI think what he means is "systematic_error = 1/log(log(equipment_cost))"
- mikeash 15y agoFor best results, purchase all equipment in Zimbabwean dollars.
- swombat 15y agoSounds about right! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Hadron_Collider#Cost http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Hadron_Collider#Cost > With a budget of 7.5 billion euros (approx. $9bn or £6.19bn as of Jun 2010), the LHC is one of the most expensive scientific instruments ever built. If only they'd put in $1b more, they'd have found that Higgs boson by now.
- jodrellblank 15y ago
- zipdog 15y agoI agree it will continue. Although a true perpetual motion machine is impossible, there's no reason that a device couldn't produce seemingly unlimited energy. The total energy of a mass system is incredibly high. At some point (maybe a long way from today's tech) we may be able to extract a constant portion in a controlled fashion in a small device. That carrot will lead many people to try and fail. What's great is the empiricism of energy: we can measure the input and output precisely (given enough effort), and so its pretty easy (comparatively) to tell whether the box does what it says on the lid. Even this demo shows that: the consultants will only pay once the machine shows that the numbers add up.
- redthrowaway 15y ago>Perpetual motion machines are a really old dream. The dream outlived Clausius, Kelvin, and Carnot and it will outlive us. Dreams are durable. FWIW, it's not perpetual motion. This is not a claim of free energy, but a claim of matter being converted to energy in a way physicists deem exceedingly unlikely. I, too, would be incredulous of any positive result, but it's not claiming to violate thermodynamics.
- dlikhten 15y agoIts not perpetual since you put in a smaller energy than you get out, but you still consume a fuel that is extremely plentiful everywhere in the universe. Perpetual = outputs more energy than it uses while consuming no fuel, so it fuels itself + some output.
- lukev 15y agoWhile I don't disagree with you, I do have a nit: they're not claiming this is a perpetual motion machine, which is categorically impossible and an incontrovertible indicator of a scam. They're claiming it can derive energy from nuclear fusion of hydrogen atoms. This has not been proven to be impossible. In fact, we know it's possible (albiet at much higher temperatures.) Therefore, there is at least a logical possibility that it's legit, even if their behavior doesn't indicate that so far.
- cbr 15y agoI think they're actually claiming something weirder: hydrogen combining with nickel to make copper. http://daily.wired.it/news/scienza/fusione-fredda-bologna.html http://daily.wired.it/news/scienza/fusione-fredda-bologna.ht... "the hydrogen atoms penetrate into the nickel and copper turn. Or at least, this is our interpretation." (gli atomi di idrogeno penetrano nel nichel e lo trasformano in rame. --- translated by google)
- VladRussian 15y agoall these cold fusion schemes use "input/output < 1" energy demonstration as a prove of the fusion. A lot of unaccounted chemical reactions can happen inside - for example, they split water into hydrogen and oxygen and the oxygen would burn with nickel - you'd have energy gain if nickel burns better than hydrogen (i just don't remember what produces better reaction though) The real scientific approach would be to demonstrate the real indicators of supposed reaction. Be it fast neutrons, alpha or some specific radiation frequency. Because when hydrogen supposedly fuses with nickel (lets forget for a moment that nickel is past the iron in the periodic table and thus isn't expected to produce much of, if at all, a fusion energy gain) the energy is released in some very specific and detectable form - either some particle like alpha or some photon of pretty specific frequency and there is nothing easier to detect than that ... much much easier than to compare input/output energy and trace the heat loses/gains through the piping, etc... I'm a firm believer in the fusion as a practical energy source. We have upper bound - 10Kt thermonuclear weapons that produce net energy gain, we have lower bound - Z machine (my personal favorite as it is just a miniaturized thermonuclear bomb process, which is well proven at Kt scale, with X-rays produced by electric discharge (at 15% efficiency of electric power to X-rays conversion!) instead of nuclear fission primary), Tokamaks, fusor, polywell, NIF with some of them reaching output levels of tens of percent of the input energy. The sweet spot is somewhere in between. It takes money and time to develop it. ITER or even order of magnitude bigger ITER will get us there. The cold fusion which is unknown (in particular it doesn't have such proven upper/lower bounds) and when presented in such unscientific fashion it just undermines the public support, ie. funding for development of proven (in the sense mentioned above) technologies.
- jakeonthemove 15y agoWell, Rossi seems to believe in it, and I really hope it works. If it does, it'll not only be useful for generating power, but could conceivably be adapted for jet engines, ships and other vehicles, making everything cheaper. I guess we'll see in a few days...
- catnip 15y ago10 bucks on the Italian.
- cbr 15y agoIt looks like the most recent test did not convince people, so I doubt this will be proved either way today. In the past, they've not been very careful with measurements: http://www.physorg.com/news/2011-08-controversial-energy-generating-lacking-credibility-video.html http://www.physorg.com/news/2011-08-controversial-energy-gen...
- ck2 15y agoIs this "motorola solutions" actually part of the real Motorola? http://www.mail-archive.com/vortex-l@eskimo.com/msg52921.html http://www.mail-archive.com/vortex-l@eskimo.com/msg52921.htm...
- mindcrime 15y agoLooks like "Motorola Solutions" is the other half - besides "Motorola Mobility" (the bit that Google is buying) - of the old Motorola, Inc. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_Solutions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_Solutions Not so sure about this "Bob Higgins" though. I didn't find a Bob Higgins at Motorola on LinkedIn (granted, it was a quick and fairly superficial search). Edit: Ok, upon further review, I did find a Bob Higgins @ Motorola, so he's real at least. Hard to say much beyond that... What I do find suspicious though, is this: Take a look at the results from this search: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=bob+higgins+motorola&oq=bob+higgins+motorola http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=bob+higgins+motorol... and look at all the domain names on the first page. ecatinfo.com ecatreviews.com ecatfusion.com buyecat.com ecathome.com ecatexport.com energycatalyzernews.com rossireactor.com rossigenerator.com ecatnews.com I mean, somebody has really poured a lot of energy into promoting this thing, and it hasn't even been properly verified yet? This comes off as a bit scammy to me.
- cbr 15y agoOr they're optimistic, and want to be in a good position to capitalize on it if it works?
- 15y ago
- bdonlan 15y agoI'm not going to believe it until they show a closed system, with only a hydrogen (or water) input, producing enough energy to sustain its own reaction for an extended period of time.
- VikingCoder 15y agoI'm sorry, but how is it at all difficult to figure out if a black box has more or less total electrical output than input? You put in electricity, but output steam? Fine, use a steam turbine to make out electricity, or whatever technology you want. If the delivered output is not greater than the delivered input, you fail. If you suspect batteries, run the test longer. If you suspect that there is another process going on, then you have to open the black box, and look for unintentional wear and tear - are you accidentally performing another chemical reaction that is providing energy? If so, over a long enough period, it'll be obvious. Debates about exit velocity of steam seem like a giant waste of time.
- Tloewald 15y agoYes it does seem to beg the question, doesnt it. Most of the issues with the experiment could be addressed very easily, e.g. A transparent pane to verify water level or absence thereof in the "chimney", simply showing the steam being output vs. sending it into a drain. The possibility that it's wet steam vs dry would more or less perfectly account for the 6x ratio. Here's the thing: if this were real, Rossi wouldn't care about satisfying skeptics if it meant distracting him from meeting project goals. If it's a hoax, act like it's real.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoI'm not reading the details of this particular experiment, because I'm wasting enough time talking about it as it is. ;) But you have to understand the nature of real prototype devices. Take it from someone who has built many semiconductor lasers that worked so badly that it took hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of specialized equipment to learn that they worked at all: The first transistor probably didn't work very well. The first laser didn't produce a lot of power or have a very long lifetime. Famously, the first several thousand Edison light bulbs didn't work well enough to be viable products. The difference between success and failure in an early-stage experiment is often small, and often statistical, and is often so ephemeral that you yourself have crises of faith in the results. And that's for the kind of phenomenon that eventually turns out to be tremendously important! And this is the problem. On the frontier, the difference between a promising sign and a statistical fluke is small. It's a territory ripe for self-delusion and fraud. You ask me to run a steam engine. Well, okay, suppose I can do that for five minutes. But then a piece of duct tape comes unstuck. You say: Replace that duct tape with something more durable. I reply, okay, sure, can you lend me the necessary $1500? (I was trying to save money with the duct tape. Half the parts are duct tape. Prototype device, remember?) You ask me to run the test longer. Well, okay, I can run it until my special catalyst runs out. You say: Get more catalyst. I reply, okay, sure, can you lend me the necessary $10,000? (The catalyst is expensive in small quantities, you see, but in the future we'll have economies of scale.) You ask me to open up my black box and submit every part to detailed analysis. We'll hire an independent laboratory and they'll handle all of it. I reply, okay, sure, can you pony up the necessary $10 million? And then the independent laboratory finds a suspicious anomaly. Oh dear, I say, I didn't realize that was happening. Maybe I made a mistake. I'll have to go back to the drawing board. Can I have a $1m grant to go back to the drawing board?
- brudgers 15y agoI remember Fleishmann and Pons announcement back in the late 80's - personally, the gross theory of bringing together Deuterium atoms close enough to create fusion using a catalytic surface still seems plausible to me,even if their experimental results were never supported at "a university without a division I football team." Of course, I am probably biased because back in '89 I did my first presentation using computer generated materials on the subject for a Science Education course - overheads printed with my StarMicronix NX1000 from images generated with EA Deluxe Paint on the Amiga 500.
- ajross 15y agoThe difference though is that F&P were real scientists who simply happened to be wrong. They published their work in a way that could be replicated, and those experiments found their results were in error. They were shamed and embarassed, but they played by the rules and were doing real science. This nonsense is pure charlatanry and fraud. An "inventor" working alone and discovering new fundamental physics without published results or peer review needs to be viewed far more suspiciously.
- brudgers 15y agoActually, Pons and Flesciemann announced their results at a press conference prior to publication, which was extremely detrimental to their credibility without regard to the validity of their science. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_fusion#Announcement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_fusion#Announcement
- tensor 15y agoI remember seeing an interview with one of them and he claimed that he never wanted to do that announcement. Rather, he was pushed into it by the University and was probably more responsible for ruining his career than the experiment not working. As for the experiment, as I recall it did produce neutrons, an expected byproduct of fusion. There was certainly an interesting reaction going on but it turned out that it wasn't fusion.
- 15y ago
- yaix 15y agoI hope he has some bodyguards. If this would be true, there are a couple of countries with lots of oil that would not really like this idea to become reality. But then, as the article says, chances of it being true are small, unfortunately.
- shin_lao 15y agoNot really. 1/You still need oil to make plastic 2/You're not going to go "all electric" any time soon
- yaix 15y agoLet's say the oil price would dive vertically. And with free electricity, you could make synthetics and synthetic oil cheaper than digging for it. For some countries this would mean ruin. (Not to mention the US, having just spend so much money to take over Iraq.) But it would also relax many international conflicts. Suddenly, nobody would be interested in the Spratley and Parcell-Islands anymore, for instance.
- shin_lao 15y agoYou're writing a science fiction story. Of course technology from the XXIInd century would likely disrupt the economy of the early XXIst century... Even if electricity were free (and cold fusion wouldn't make it free, you need to build a factory, have people operate it, build power lines, convert the electricity...), how do you make synthetic oil? Which property would that synthetic oil have? Could it work to make gasoline? Could we build plastic with it?
- yaix 15y agoCurrently usually from biomass or coal, see almighty wp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_fuel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_fuel The factories would not being build in the few countries that currently supply the vast majority of the oil the world consumes. A number of countries (Venezuela, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, to name a few) would lose 99% of their income overnight. Maybe its the wrong place to discuss the political implications of technical inventions here on hn, though. (I am a little annoyed that some people seem to just down vote anything they lack knowledge about. What do you mean by "science fiction story"??)
- wavephorm 15y agoWhew, and here I thought some startup was launching a Coldfusion PaaS.
- brador 15y agoWho writes an article like this and doesn't give a TIME for the presentation? Are we in the 1990's here?
- thedangler 15y agoWill it be live streamed?
- dhughes 15y agoI read that as "live steamed"?
- ErrantX 15y agoI've been following this for a little while; just of idle interest. Unfortunately everything about the way Rossi acts in relation to the project screams scam. I bet nothing conclusive comes from this test..
- alexhaefner 15y agoI was speaking to a nuclear physicist about Fusion, and he stated that really was being used to verify nuclear models for making bombs and such, and that it would never be practical for power generation.
- carbocation 15y agoHe's referring to the National Ignition Facility, but that's not the only project. In Europe, there is ITER. And the NIF has recently gotten serious about trying to actually do fusion for power generation. This isn't to say that fusion power generation will be a reality anytime soon, so on that most critical point I'm sure the nuclear physicist is correct.
- alexhaefner 15y agoI'm not really sure why I am getting downvoted. I was talking to a friend about this and a nuclear engineering ph.d. candidate at the University of Michigan working on plasma physics started talking with me about it and essentially echoed the same sentiment. I'm paraphrasing, "One of the jokes of Fusion is that it's always 50 years off... It's sexy, but in reality it gets funding because it happens to be what we build nuclear bombs with, and because we can't do live simulations anymore, we build supercomputers and fusion experiments to verify our bomb making."
- carbocation 15y agoI don't know why you're getting downvoted, either. Your comment contributed positively to the discussion. No need for downvotes here.
- corford 15y agoTime to short BP, Exxon et al? :)
- greggles 15y agoJournalist uses accurate headline or false dichotomies presented as fact today.
- russell 15y agoHere is an article from a 2009 60 Minutes show about the work of Michael McKubre at SRI. He has been able to get excess energy. but not large enough or reliably enough to claim complete success. He thinks it's some kind of catalytic surface effect. I've known McKubre for a long time. We were neighbors in the 90's. He's a good honest man. He may be mistaken, but he's not a fraud. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_McKubre http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_McKubre I'm inclined to accept that some kind of low energy nuclear process is going on, although it is not fusion as we know it.
- ars 15y agoThere are two main causes for "not large or reliable enough". The reason for "not large enough" is calorimetry. When you hydrolyze water some reforms back into steam and escapes. So you subtract that energy as lost in your calculations of output - input. The error is in not correctly calculating how much energy is actually lost vs left in the experiment. Good experiments don't allow any steam to be lost, they are perfectly insulated and keep everything inside the cell. Unfortunately it's extremely hard to do this accurately. (Or you can generate so much energy it's more than the input without subtracting the losses, but no one has ever been able to do that.) The reason for not reliably, is that experiments look for signs of radiation. Palladium is sometimes sourced from refined nuclear waste. It's refined extremely well, it's perfectly safe. But it has just enough residual radiation to cause very strange data for the experimenters: One batch of palladium works great, the next batch doesn't work at all, and they can't figure out what's different.
- russell 15y agoExactly. One of the reasons that Pons and Fleischman got into such trouble is that their calorimic measurements were very inaccurate. They also tried to measure neutron radiation but their equipment wasnt up to the task. McKumbe mentions that the quality of the palladium varies greatly from source to source. Since one theory is that the fine structure of the palladium forces the deuterium atoms so close that they fuse, I infer that the nature of the fine structure is important and could vary greatly from source to source. Impurities could be the key or the poison.
- drtse4 15y agoAlways thought that this is a scam considering his past. How many of you know of the Petroldragon thing he did in the seventies? Interesting story (still not clear if it was a scam or not) http://translate.google.com/translate?ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF&u=http%3A%2F%2Fit.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FPetroldragon&sl=it&tl=en http://translate.google.com/translate?ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF...
- pdx 15y agoPlastic pyrolysis and then subsequent cracking to diesel is not a scam. In fact, I know the guy behind http://www.agilyx.com/ http://www.agilyx.com/ which is doing the same thing. That Rossi attempted this in the mid 70's is interesting to me, and gives him more credibility, not less.
- merraksh 15y agoEvent tweeted at https://twitter.com/#!/22passi https://twitter.com/#!/22passi In Italian only :-(
- riffraff 15y agonot much beef apart from the interesting fact that AP has the exclusive of the event https://twitter.com/#!/22passi/status/129811500599746560 https://twitter.com/#!/22passi/status/129811500599746560
- merraksh 15y agoIndeed. The eCat website was pointing at that tweet feed and I thought it would be updated more often.
- ajays 15y ago"If it fails to perform, Rossi will not get paid" ... This is the key part.
- cshesse 15y agoThe key part is when the anonymous buyer remains anonymous. If his invention works, why not patent it and let everyone see the internals? EDIT: Looks like there supposedly is a patent: "a method and apparatus for carrying out nickel and hydrogen exothermal reactions," with production of copper, though I haven't found the patent itself. http://www.nyteknik.se/incoming/article3080659.ece/BINARY/Rossi-Focardi_paper.pdf http://www.nyteknik.se/incoming/article3080659.ece/BINARY/Ro... Seems like someone would independently make one though.
- clistctrl 15y agoThe patent would have to be applied for before it is offered for sale.
- mhb 15y agoIt is for real and it's delicious: http://www.coldfusiongelato.com/ http://www.coldfusiongelato.com/
- squozzer 15y agoIf it works, we'll just figure out a way to make nickel (or whatever material eventually becomes the catalyst) scarcer. For that matter, it might trigger a Water Rush because the assholes who run the world's govts don't like to share. If it doesn't work, then it's BAU...
- mrb 15y agoMy bet: either the experiment will fail with a "strange" technical issue, or the "anonymous customer" will report a success but will choose to remain anonymous and not provide any more information (because he is nothing more than one of Rossi's lies).
- chalimacos 15y agoThere is a (unfounded) rumor that Google is the client behind the test: http://ecatinfo.com/e-cat/e-cat-info-hints-sat-google-being-rossi%e2%80%99s-customer http://ecatinfo.com/e-cat/e-cat-info-hints-sat-google-being-...
- ck2 15y agoupdate: "customer satisfied" http://www.ecatnews.net/2011/10/28/e-cat-plant-shutting-down-customer-satisfied-peswiki-via-twitter/ http://www.ecatnews.net/2011/10/28/e-cat-plant-shutting-down... http://twitter.com/#!/PESNetwork http://twitter.com/#!/PESNetwork wiki updates http://peswiki.com/index.php/News:October_28%2C_2011_Test_of_the_One_Megawatt_E-Cat#Updates_and_News_Regarding_October_28_Test http://peswiki.com/index.php/News:October_28%2C_2011_Test_of... photos from earlier this month http://peswiki.com/index.php/News:October_28%2C_2011_Test_of_the_One_Megawatt_E-Cat#Photos http://peswiki.com/index.php/News:October_28%2C_2011_Test_of... maillist discussion http://www.mail-archive.com/vortex-l@eskimo.com/ http://www.mail-archive.com/vortex-l@eskimo.com/
- james33 15y agoAll they give is a tweet? Seems sort of fishy...
- flog 15y agoWhy would the customer be satisfied if the 1mW plant is only outputting 470kW? I'll believe it when I see it.
- ck2 15y agoThey could always claim half capacity was a trial. The real question is how much power was put into it, for how long, to get 470kwh out of it, for how long.
- carbocation 15y agoWhy is this business's website displaying AdSense ads?
- jQueryIsAwesome 15y ago"Someday this is gonna work and it will be awesome! In the mean time please invest huge amounts of money in us!" This guy have the same business model as Groupon.
- davorak 15y agoThe article was a disappointment. It was full of hype and no substance. The article pulled people in with a head line claiming a potential science and energy break through but whose contents focused on vague details of the human story around it. Bait and switch I say. That is what I expected though from the head line. Just like I would expect it from the below headlines: "Homeopathy either becomes reality or proved a scam today" "Perpetual motion either becomes reality or proved a scam today"
- th0ma5 15y agoHere's a video that was just posted http://youtu.be/7sZHOQ6P-Rw http://youtu.be/7sZHOQ6P-Rw
- cshesse 15y agoRelevant Richard Feynman story: http://www.indian-skeptic.org/html/fey1.htm http://www.indian-skeptic.org/html/fey1.htm
- 46Bit 15y agoI give it 12 hours before everyone realises this is a pile of bull.
- brc 15y agoI've been following this story for 12 months or more. I've read a lot of criticism and deep discussions that go way beyond my capability to understand. But we should know, soon enough, if it's a fraud or not. Either the thing works as advertised, or it doesn't. Even if this particular test has 'teething problems' I would assume that, within a week or two, all will be known. To me, it's a case of sit back, remain patient and open minded, and watch to see what happens. It's not like he's asking for taxpayer money or subsidies. If he ends up fleecing a rich company or individual, well, that sort of things goes on every day. It would be a drop in the ocean compared to, say, pets.com or any number of mega-flop movie releases. I just don't get the invective directed at this guy and his project. If he's wrong, there will be plenty of time for gloating and schadenfreude. If he's right, a lot of people are going to look very silly with their big statements.
- wpietri 15y agoThe invective comes because he flouts the way scientists normally go about announcing and proving major scientific discoveries. And that matters because the scientific approach is evolved to be very different than what scam artists and loons gets up to. One reason many people are unwilling to be patient and open-minded is that they've already done that in the past, and had their patience worn thin by said scam artists and loons. Another is that they respect (or have worked hard to become) actual scientists who put forth the extra time and effort to properly demonstrate and document novel findings.
- thret 15y agoI guess it is a little OT, but I was interested to read elswhere that room-temperature fusion is already possible, demonstrated and understood using negative muons to produce proton-deuteron fusion reaction. It just isn't possible to generate additional energy with the process. http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/9901037 http://arxiv.org/abs/physics/9901037 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muon-catalyzed_fusion
- Devilboy 15y agoThis is so obviously a scam. 100% scam in my view. The 'customer' is anonymous, clearly just a figment of Rossi's imagination.
- slevcom 15y agoI'm happy to go on record here and the unerasable archives of internet history, risking my own reputation and that of my entire line of descendants, in saying that I am convinced this particular dog and pony show is a hoax.
- djloche 15y agoA few things to update this story: Peter Svensson from the AP was there (as rumored). his report has not been published (yet?) two other journalists were there, and have published: http://www.nyteknik.se/nyheter/energi_miljo/energi/article3303682.ece http://www.nyteknik.se/nyheter/energi_miljo/energi/article33... http://pesn.com/2011/10/28/9501940_1_MW_E-Cat_Test_Successful/ http://pesn.com/2011/10/28/9501940_1_MW_E-Cat_Test_Successfu... You can evaluate these sources as you would like. I however, am waiting to hear what Peter Svensson has to say. AP has reporters all over the world, yet they flew in Mr. Svensson from new york to cover the private event. Now, this may be because he has been successful in gaining access and an invite, or it may be because the company purchasing picked him, I am not sure - it is unusual from an outsider view.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- spullara 15y agoIf you could actually achieve essentially unlimited energy at very little cost you wouldn't tell anyone and would just connect it to the grid and collect your money. There is no reason to "prove" cheap cold fusion.
- fragsworth 15y agoI'm not going to make any claims as to whether or not this is a scam, but your logic is completely wrong. Most people would probably need investors to finance any mass production. To get investors, you (normally) have to prove that it works...
- spullara 15y agoWith cold fusion the claim as always been that it would be small scale, cheap and would easily scale up. You don't need mass production when you can generate unlimited energy for free. The only reason you would need investment would be for the original device (which is required to prove it works anyway), it would then pay for the next set of devices, etc until you owned the earth. If you can't break even quickly on a 1MW generator that doesn't cost anything to run, your device is too expensive to be practical since you are generating about $1m of electricity a year.
- anothermachine 15y agoOk, now it's tomorrow. It was a scam, right?
- BrotherSand 15y agoAn added wrinkle here, reported by Wired: (http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2011-10/29/rossi-success http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2011-10/29/rossi-success ) "The customer's controller, one Domenico Fioravanti, apparently reports to a man whose title is "Colonel". This suggests that the mystery customer might be DARPA, the Pentagon's extreme science wing which, as Wired.co.uk has previously noted, has expressed interestin Rossi's work -- but which might not be quite ready to explain to its political masters why it spent millions on a cold fusion device." I think that goes a long way to explain a lot of the secrecy that the customer engaged in. Rather than being a scam it may actually be the visible tip of a military project. Remember, you can run cars on electricity and trucks on natural gas, but when you run out of oil your army comes to a stop. They have a lot of motivation to find an alternative. As I understand it the process did not achieve 1MW because it got too hot and they had to cool it down. Per Rossi, if it gets over the melting temperature of nickle the reaction stops. But it ran in self-sustaining mode putting out enough power to satisfy the men in uniforms that it works so now they take it back to the USA and tinker with it themselves.