3 ms·
It’s never been achieved because it would never work. I mean the USSR was willing to murder people who opposed the idea and it still failed. And China tried i
by refurb 4y ago
It’s never been achieved because it would never work.
I mean the USSR was willing to murder people who opposed the idea and it still failed.
And China tried it and abandoned it out of failure true.
Your rationale is the “no true Scotsman” fallacy.
- cloudfifty 4y ago[dead]
- int_19h 4y agoIt's never been achieved because it was never really tried. To reiterate, what USSR and China had was not communism even according to themselves - I'm not even talking about impartial outside observers here! - so, pray tell, how is it the "no true Scotsman" fallacy?
- refurb 4y agoBoth China and the USSR conducted mass collectivation, land reform, commune models among other things to move away from capitalism to a communist model of public ownership. They even killed dissidents, violently oppressed public protests and starved their own people in the attempt. And it was a massive failure. It's a "no true Scotsman" fallacy because as long as attempts at moving to a communism model fail, supporters will just say "that wasn't true communism" ignoring the fact that if you can't actually create a functioning communist system that's indicative of failure of the model itself.
- int_19h 4y agoLike I said, everything that you have describe was not communism - it was a particular recipe for supposedly building it. And yes, that recipe was a massive failure, and few people on the left believe that it could have ever been anything but. But here we're talking about communism naturally arising out of technological post-scarcity. What does that have to do with Soviet model of "public" (actually, state) ownership, or killing dissidents, or violently oppressing anyone?