3 ms·
> Instead, we're loosing the apps we had, and march towards dumb UIs and needlessly containerized apps a la snap/flatpack. There is a very real need behind app
by mschuster91 4y ago
> Instead, we're loosing the apps we had, and march towards dumb UIs and needlessly containerized apps a la snap/flatpack.
There is a very real need behind app containerization: distributions are exceedlingly slow to pick up updates in a time where web applications routinely run on a "merge request passed, 5 minutes later it's on production" model. On top of that, distributions routinely run into the problem that package A wants a new version of library B, but the other applications haven't been updated to use the new version yet, so everyone is stuck until all applications in the distribution have been updated.
Also: Most people use LTS distributions and let's be real no one wants to be stuck with a 2 year old browser that only gets backported security patches. Distributions had the chance to move to a model of "the core is stable but the applications the user uses are flexibly updateable", and they blew it completely.
- tannhaeuser 4y agoThe question you should be asking is why do we need all this if the desktop app "market" is contracting and I'm using just the same old apps on Linux I used 15 years ago. To the detriment of alt-OSs like FBSD and OBSD which I always loved. Why would I want frequent browser updates all the time when the web is 30 years old, and also contracting? As I type this (not making this up!) FF prompts me again to restart because updates - why? I'm sick of browsers updating more frequently than the very few sites I still go to; Moz should be producing an essential browser instead of participating in this drivel. It works just fine on my old 2016 XPS with Ubuntu ESR and infrequent updates. You can read my comments to see I've praised Ubuntu, Dell (XPS, specifically), and Lenovo in the past. But I'm on my third Dell (Latitude/Precision so no consumer crap) with fatal hardware defects ootb within 8 months that various customers found necessary to send me for work (to run stunts like Docker-on-Windows or something), while my Thinkpad's miniscule track pad with uneccessary mechanical parts is collecting dust, and mechanically blocking due to it. Right now I think I've got enough of it already and am going back to Apple which I've used on and off since around 2003.
- jen20 4y agoA different question might be whether the native app market is contracting because operating system distributions handle updates so poorly.
- dTal 4y agoSetting aside the fact that rolling release distros are 1) a thing and 2) highly popular, I have to believe that these are problems that are within our capacity as engineers to solve without just saying "screw it, we'll give each program its own OS". In fact in some sense they are already solved, from a technical standpoint - you can install Debian, with its crufty out of date repos, and then download Firefox from its official website and run it right in your home directory. There you go, stable core and bleeding edge application. What's the problem?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoConsider that FlatPak is popular for this case and distributing the way you describe isn't for a good reason: having to deal with all the many and varied dependencies and configurations on any given distro is a giant pain in the ass. People have been screaming this at Linux Desktop evangelists for 20 years about this and mostly fallen on deaf ears, so it is no wonder Linux Desktop is still in a distant 3rd place in the desktop market.
- dTal 4y agoDistributing binaries (that run on any distribution) is not unpopular. Off the top of my head, Firefox, Blender, VSCode, and Arduino IDE are all distributed as simple tarballs with binaries + libraries inside. Many more applications are distributed as AppImages, which are not much more than self-extracting versions of those same tarballs. It's very simple: build against a mature version of GlibC, and bundle everything else. You know, exactly like you'd do on Windows.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoThis is a very recent trend that I am quite happy for, but it has not been the trend for the vast majority of Linux Desktop's existence and hardly encompasses even the majority of desktop software. > It's very simple: build against a mature version of GlibC, and bundle everything else. You know, exactly like you'd do on Windows. Windows has backwards and forwards compatibility guarantees that Linux userland simply does not have, and Windows doesn't have anywhere near the fragmentation that Linux has either. This is not nearly as simple as you claim it is or FlatPak wouldn't have been invented in the first place. I like AppImage a lot, conceptually, because of its simplicity. But that same simplicity, combined with the ludicrously fragmentary nature of Linux Desktop, has meant that I've had a lot more problems getting AppImages that work than I have getting FlatPaks that work.
- Anthony-G 4y agoRegarding Linux distributions, I personally find that Ubuntu LTS occupies that sweet middle-ground between bleeding edge and stable software. I find RHEL is too stable (old) and I’d prefer any of Fedora, Debian stable or Debian testing to RHEL (haven’t used anything else). > no one wants to be stuck with a 2 year old browser that only gets backported security patches Most people I know – both technical and non-technical alike – would be quite happy with a browser that only gets non-security updates every year or so. The non-technical users tend not to care about new features. And almost nobody likes UI changes (that often aren’t objectively better, easier or more intuitive than the previous version). I now install Firefox ESR on the few PCs that I manage for end-users and it has been better for everyone.