5 ms·
I like that in US, UK, Canada, DE censorship is called filtering.
by hulitu 4y ago
I like that in US, UK, Canada, DE censorship is called filtering.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoIt's only censorship when China or other oppressive regimes are doing it. We call it "filtering", "anti hate speech", or "anti child-porn".
- refurb 4y agoEnforcing a contract and IP law is not censorship any more than foreclosing on a house due to non-payment of property taxes is "violation of private property laws".
- codetrotter 4y agoWhy is that not censorship, but China enforcing their laws is? I think copyright enforcement should be seen as a form of censorship, regardless of whether or not one agrees with copyright laws. This Wikipedia article about internet censorship seems to have been partially written by people who think that copyright enforcement is a form of censorship as well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship
- sofixa 4y agoThe intent behind the actions matters. China blocks content it is afraid of ( gays, Tianenmen, Taiwan is kind of a country, etc.), while US, UK, Canada, EU, usually block content that violates copyright law. The most recent exception i can think is the "blocking" ( it really isn't blocking, it's removing from some platforms) of Russian state sponsored propaganda, which is also quite easy to justify.
- trasz 4y agoYou could say this the other way around: China blocks content that violates the law, US blocks content Congress was lobbied (let's pretend that's not a legalized corruption) to block.
- lupire 4y agoCopyright is in the US Constitution.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trasz 4y agoSo is “subverting the government” in Chinese one. (I suppose.)
- nybble41 4y agoThe US Constitution gave Congress the power—but not the obligation–to enact copyright laws in pursuit of certain social goals. A mistake, IMHO, but it was certainly mentioned as something Congress could do at its discretion. And then the First Amendment promptly nullified that power by categorically stating that the freedom of speech shall not be infringed. Distribution of content is speech, and copyright enforcement penalizes it, which infringes the freedom of speech. This is how the exceptions for Fair Use came about, by attempting to reconcile the Copyright Clause with the First Amendment, but Fair Use is only a half-measure which does not fully avoid the infringement of the freedom of speech. When you have Rule A saying that you may do something and Rule B saying that you must not do that thing, they don't combine to create a compromise rule which says that you can do that thing most of the time with a few narrow exceptions.
- notafraudster 4y agoIt's possible that "censorship" denotatively means suppression of any speech (including the parade of horribles -- viagra spam, stolen IDs, abuse content, etc.) and connotatively means suppression of speech with at least some political valence. Or alternatively that it's denotatively ambiguous and has multiple connotations. A case that sort of rubs up against this in the U.S. -- I use an American example because in Canada s.1 circumscribes all legal rights, including freedom of expression, so it would be academic whether this raised speech concerns or not -- is Morse v. Frederick. In this case, a student, Frederick, raised a banner that read "Bong Hits 4 Jesus" in front of some television cameras. The behaviour occurred off school grounds but nearby, and during an event that students were allowed to leave school early to attend. The school suspended Frederick because his banner promoted drug use. A lot of the ruling relied on parsing what category of speech this banner was. One argument is that it was essentially dadaist, absurdist speech (Frederick's claim. Another argument is that it was promoting criminal behaviour (the school principal's claim; Roberts, Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, and Alito in the opinion). Another argument is that it was political speech, aimed at contesting a public policy (Stevens, Souter, Ginsberg in dissent; Alito and Kennedy in concurrence) Although there were other issues in the case, namely to do with how speech is regulated within schools and whether this constituted a school event, one of the undercurrents is that constitutional protections for political speech seem to be more crucial to many of the justices than constitutional protections for gibberish speech. So I don't think it's crazy to suggest, at a minimum, that there exists a well-support denotative use of "censorship" that specifically refers to speech with political characteristics, rather than all speech. Through that lens, copyright enforcement could either be censorship (to the extent that the enforcement is designed or has the effect of prohibiting the dissemination of political speech or prohibits commentary on a public policy) or not (to the extent the content being restricted is fundamentally apolitical). And this is true even if there are other denotations that consider stopping any speech to be censorship.
- shkkmo 4y agoEdit: all the legal references are in a US context Censorship is prohibiting speech or blocking a speaker because of the content or alleged content of their speech. Not all censorship is unconstitutional. The legal blocking of curse words amd nudity on broadcast TV is clearly censorship regardless of if the intent or effect of cursing while nude on TV is political. It is true that free speech protections against the censorship of political speech do tend to be stronger. Also generally speaking, rules that prohibit speech in certain contexts or manners without regard for their content or the speaker (thus not censorship) tend are held to a lower standard for legal justification than laws that do engage in censorship. In this case, the question is does this type qualify as "not-censorship" because somehow blocking "content that infringes our IP" is not restricting speech on the basis on its content. To me it seems obvious that this is a restriction of speech that depends on it's alleged content.
- franga2000 4y agoThere are different laws. Enforcing laws that limit freedom of information is censorship, be it net filtering or burning books. Enforcing copyright laws is not - you wouldn't call customs intercepting a truck of illegally copied DVDs censorship. It's not about who does it, it's about why they do it. Is blocking illegal-due-to-copyright content a slippery slope to blocking illegal-because-opressive-regime-said-so content? Yes. Is "slippery slope" a bad argument? Also yes. I agree having court-enforced IP block lists controlled by private companies is bad. But that isn't censorship, it's just stupid.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shkkmo 4y ago> you wouldn't call customs intercepting a truck of illegally copied DVDs censorship I might, depends on the context. Copyright laws can indeed result in censorship. Let's say those DVDs have an additional commentary track. > But that isn't censorship, it's just stupid. So when your IP address gets block in Canada for a year, regardless of what content or speech it was engaged in amd without any attempt to verify that you indeed were sharing content out of copyright, you aren't being censored? Come on.
- rkagerer 4y agoIn fairness there are a few safeguards and the whole order sunsets at the end of this season, so I hope that distinguishes it a little bit from similar measures by more oppressive regimes.
- trasz 4y agoWhat makes you assume those oppressive regimes don't have similar safeguards?
- rkagerer 4y agoDo they? eg. Once they identify an undesirable topic would they limit their censorship of it to just a single year? Do blocking orders there come with explicit legal recourse for users who believe they are affected inappropriately to petition an impartial court for exclusion (and potentially collect damages from the party that blocked their IP)? Actual questions, I'm genuinely interested.
- trasz 4y agoNo idea about China, but in US “they” can, using a secret sentence from a FISA “secret court”, legally prohibit you from absolutely anything, and if you complain to anyone you go to jail.
- kube-system 4y agoBecause most oppressive regimes have authoritarian systems of government.
- franga2000 4y agoTo be fair, there is a difference. Censorship means suppressing information and carries a connotation of "the government doesn't want you to know something". Filtering is one way to achieve that, but it can also be used for other purposes. Blocking illegal content isn't censorship. It creates the technical framework and weak precedent for censorship and I agree we shouldn't do it this way, but it's not more censorship than seizing a bunch of copied DVDs at the border would be.
- weberer 4y ago>Blocking illegal content isn't censorship That's a nonsense statement. Declaring something illegal is how governments censor.
- franga2000 4y agoIt's also how they prevent and punish genuinely bad behavior, which is why you need to look at why a certain thing is illegal, not just whether it is or isn't. Does the law say "you may not write bad things about the government or good things about gay people and if you do we'll block your site"? Anything blocked under that law is censorship. Does it say "you must have permission from the rightsholder to distribute any copyrighted material and if you don't we'll block your site"? Blocking under that law, whether you agree with it or not, isn't censorship.
- sib 4y ago"you must have permission from the rightsholder to distribute any copyrighted material and if you don't we'll block your site"? Blocking under that law, whether you agree with it or not, isn't censorship. But that is not "illegal content" - that is illegal sharing of legal content. The government making content itself illegal is much much the definition of censorship.
- scarface74 4y agoSo would you be okay if a company “illegally” used and distributed GPL software?
- ramchip 4y agoCensorship: "the suppression or prohibition of any parts of books, films, news, etc. that are considered obscene, politically unacceptable, or a threat to security." This is bad, but it's really not censorship in the same sense that China censors Tiananmen Square, etc. You can talk about the NHL game, write about it in the news, share screenshots, teach it in school, upload an animated recreation on Youtube...
- dotancohen 4y ago> upload an animated recreation on Youtube Actually, that one would be a derivative work and thus disallowed.
- trasz 4y ago>China censors Tiananmen Square https://www.quora.com/What-do-Chinese-citizens-particularly-the-young-adults-think-about-events-such-as-the-June-4th-Incident-aka-the-Tiananmen-Square-massacre-when-information-around-it-has-been-so-heavily-censored/answer/Yiran-Chen-15 https://www.quora.com/What-do-Chinese-citizens-particularly-...
- mike_d 4y agoIf a government tells ISPs to block a website because it is publishing information unfavorable to the government or its leaders, that is censorship. When a government tells ISPs to block content that it believes doing so serves a greater good, that is filtering. You can argue all day about the greater good and if filtering is justified, but the difference is China explicitly censors opposing viewpoints.
- aljungberg 4y agoFar would it be for a government to describe censoring opposing viewpoints as “blocking content for the greater good”, right?
- int_19h 4y agoIt's censorship in both cases. What, you think governments that censor don't do so in the name of the "greater good"? It's just that one "greater good" is considered valid enough a justification (by some), while the other one is not.
- sacrosancty 4y agoNot sure it's that clear. Some of China's censorship is in the name of social harmony, which is arguably the government believing it's doing good. Nobody wants riots and civil war, do they? If Germany blocks sites promoting the Nazi party, is that doing good because such promotion does bad, or is it censoring an opposing political viewpoint that's competing with it for power? Even if the government has the support of most of the population, it's still a political power struggle between them and the Nazis.
- ratboy666 4y agoGodwin's law prevails.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoYou can pretty much justify anything with the "greater good" slogan. Women wearing Burqas, greater good of lowering promiscuity and increasing family stability is how politicians justify it in the middle east. Democracy is done in America if more people think the government controlling what people read and think is some sort of social good. You can have good intentions, but still cause terrible things to happen. In the last year we saw government's pushing experimental drug on healthy young people in order to add a few extra months of life to 75+ year olds with multiple health conditions, and the extremely obese. Locking down, destroying small business and causing serious food price inflation, that will send millions of people around the world into absolute poverty. A drug that did not stop transmission, had pages worth of short-term side effects, and yet to be determined long term effects. One thing it did not due, was lower the 3x jabbed from catching covid, since they get infected now at highest rates now. How long before we go from "safe and effective" to "no one forced you to take it". It really is debatable what if anything governments COVID policy accomplished. Why shouldn't people be able to debate it?
- Maraguy 4y agoIt's a more "palatable" word for the population.
- newaccount2021 4y ago