3 ms·
I agree with your basic point, and it certainly applies to both political tribes. However, > a few isolated instances of innocent people being falsely convicte
by mindslight 4y ago
I agree with your basic point, and it certainly applies to both political tribes. However,
> a few isolated instances of innocent people being falsely convicted or forced to plead guilty as proof that such errors are pervasive and undermine the integrity of the justice system
The justice system does not operate on a best effort "good enough" basis. When the "justice" system harms an innocent person, it takes on the exact role of a criminal attacking a victim and does so in all of our names. The victim would have been much better off if the system had not been given power in the first place! Thus, we should insist that the false positive rate for the justice system must remain extremely low, lest it effectively function as the injustice system.
Furthermore, we should insist that the people operating the justice system are held accountable under the same laws that they uphold for everyone else. Otherwise all those lofty ideals come across as quite hollow.
- rayiner 4y agoAll human systems operate on a “good enough” basis. You can tweak the knobs to trade off false positives versus false negatives in whatever balance is politically viable. But there will always be false positives, and in such a huge country even a systematically low false positive rate will generate many outrage-inducing stories of injustice. Both election results and criminal verdicts are, and should be seen as, statistical determinations with error bars. All we can control is the size of the error bars, and we can control those only by trading off other things we care about (cost of the system, speed of the system, etc.)
- mindslight 4y agoJust focusing on error rates leaves out the details by which false positives are created, which are very important to everyone's individual sense of justice. For example, one of your examples was "forced to plead guilty". The word "forced" implies something else responsible for the erroneous outcome. Rather than merely saying that was a "false positive" that could be tuned, we should focus on that specific thing responsible - if it was the system's high-stakes dynamics depriving a person of their right to a trial, then those dynamics need to be reformed. If it was a bad faith prosecutor/cops pushing falsities to get a baseless conviction, then they need to be criminally prosecuted for abusing the power of the state to suit their own personal ends. Everybody knows that bad things do occasionally happen. The outrage isn't merely due to the initial miscarriage of justice, rather it's the nonchalance of the entrenched system shrugging it off rather than reifying and prosecuting its own crimes.