3 ms·
We Don't Throw People Away
- EddieDante 4y agoI'm sorry, but who is Freddie de Boer kidding? We throw people away all the time. It's just that the people we discard usually aren't conventionally attractive wealthy white women. Moreover, I have no use for forgiveness; I do not want to be "forgiven" if I say something that offends you. To be forgiven by you implies that I answer to you, and I don't answer to my equals.
- isitmadeofglass 4y ago> from the point of view that Amber Heard is a human being who has clearly suffered and is now facing immense public backlash Why do people keep taking this odd stance? The reason she is facing backlash is exactly because she didn’t suffer, her stories were lies, she got caught in a multitude of lies, and it’s clear her claimed suffering was a made up extortion scheme. That is why the er is backlash that is why social media is eating her alive. You can’t just pretend she was a real victim and then try to cast the social media response in the light of that hypothetical, since people would not be calling her out for lying if she had not been lying. > I think you can be sympathetic to Johnny Depp’s side of the case and still see Heard as someone who was sharing what seemed to her to be the essential truth of her situation. No, no you cannot. If I go out of my way to craft a narrative that someone abused my and attempt to blackmail them with it, then throw out a plethora of probable lies, you cannot just say that this was “essentially true to me”
- torstenvl 4y agoForgiveness is for the penitent. Forgiveness is also for transgressions. Opposition to "cancel culture" is in some part due to not seeing the underlying issues as moral faults. It wasn't a moral transgression for Prof. Christakis to suggest that social change come via social interaction rather than authorities. It wasn't a moral transgression for Bret Weinstein to say "On a college campus, one's right to speak — or to be — must never be based on skin color." It wasn't a moral transgression for Emmanuel Cafferty to crack his knuckles or for Greg Patton to give an example of filler word usage in Mandarin. All of these are a far cry from falsifying an allegation of abuse. Lastly, reciprocity forms the linchpin of human moral systems. Bruce Schneier, Liars and Outliers (2012); Yuval Noah Harari, Sapiens (2015); Robert Sapolsky, Behave (2017). That includes not only reciprocal altruism, but penal reciprocity. "If any one bring an accusation of any crime before the elders, and does not prove what he has charged, he shall, if it be a capital offense charged, be put to death." Hammurabi, Code of Laws (King translation.). Johnny Depp lost significant work and was a pariah due to these false accusations. I don't think it's excessive to view that as unjust, and to want the perpetrator of that injustice to experience the same. That isn't cancel culture, that's just wishing for bad people to get a taste of their own medicine.