39 ms·
> NIMBYism Can't blame them though, a landscape filled with wind farms is hardly enticing.
by ekianjo 4y ago
> NIMBYism
Can't blame them though, a landscape filled with wind farms is hardly enticing.
- CalRobert 4y agoTo each their own; I think they look cool. Solarpunk, even.
- mbeex 4y agoStart living there. Greetings from Germany
- chki 4y agoI'm living "there" and it really doesn't bother me a lot.
- mbeex 4y ago> I'm living "there". Perhaps not close enough. - look up "infrasound" and "undercutting minimum distances", better use something else than Google for this. - also check the requirements for the base materials: concrete, aluminium, fiber-reinforced plastic. Calculate the energy requirements for producing them. - familiarize yourself with the space requirements (~ two acres of highly compacted soil, not including access roads) - duration and disposal - soil dehydration, other environment impact issues - ... and as always of course, base load capability and storability
- Brometheus 4y agoI live here and I love them.
- pyhtel 4y agoI do live there, they look cool. Greetings from the Netherlands. Seriously though, what is this comment supposed to achieve?
- CalRobert 4y agoHello from the Irish midlands! I live near several large wind turbines and think they're awesome. They also help us stop cutting peat for fuel, which is good because it's a unique habitat and one of the best carbon stores in the world.
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoWhat about the danger to birds? That is much more concerning than mere appearance.
- ls15 4y agoMore than 30 times as many birds are killed by automobiles. The number for pesticides is similar. More than 50 times as many are killed by buildings. More than 300 times as many are killed by cats. https://www.energymonitor.ai/tech/renewables/weekly-data-how-many-birds-are-really-killed-by-wind-turbines https://www.energymonitor.ai/tech/renewables/weekly-data-how...
- kebman 4y agoThe fact that birds are killed in other places is not an argument for making more bird-killing structures when it can be avoided. Especially when the kinds of birds they tend to kill are endangered birds of prey. That is unless the number of bird deaths it causes are negligible.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoYes, it is. We have lots of needs in an industrial society. Torpedoing one effort for marginal benefit when work elsewhere would benefit much more, is astonishingly damaging and wasteful.
- kebman 4y agoNo, it definitively isn't! If it was your intention to mention societal needs for wind power this entire time, then why didn't you? If you don't mention the societal needs, and merely make unsupported claims that "windows kill birds," then you are being woefully disingenuous. Because windows do not kill eagles, but wind farms do! This is an important distinction which your blanket statement does not cover. As for what's marginal, damaging or wasteful, then why is Germany supporting the construction of a woefully and inadequate technology when they have a much better alterative: Nuclear power?
- bakuninsbart 4y agoCompared to what? We've destroyed the vast majority of nature in the name of progress, setting the cut off point at renewable energy seems a bit weird, especially when the alternative to reducing our emissions is completely destroyed ecosystems and probably having to deal with extreme droughts every other year.
- an9n 4y ago> especially when the alternative to reducing our emissions is completely destroyed ecosystems and probably having to deal with extreme droughts every other year. all of this is based on modelling that is open to question.
- danuker 4y agoThe last time the planet saw upwards of 400 PPM CO2 was 20-60 million years ago. I am pretty sure such a change will ruffle a few feathers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleocene%E2%80%93Eocene_Thermal_Maximum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleocene%E2%80%93Eocene_Therm...
- ekianjo 4y ago> Compared to what? We've destroyed the vast majority of nature in the name of progress, What? Since when? Most of the land of the world is still occupied by nature, and with cities expanding and remote villages disappearing the trend is not going against nature as much as you think.
- klausjensen 4y agoIt is a lot better than a landscape filled with Russian tanks.
- jansan 4y agoDo you really think these are the two options to choose from? Really?
- usrusr 4y agoNeither are landscapes filled with houses or roads. Or filled with farms, for that matter, or with tree plantations. Germany isn't exactly full of virgin forests. There isn't a single square mile outside of a few inaccessible mountains that isn't completely redesigned to support the human population. All the supposedly unspoiled landscapes nimbyism cries for are really just green (or not quite so green) factories designed to supply human needs. Adding turbines to the mix is hardly more than a tiny tweak.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoConsidering the size and durability of the foundations and bases (huge amount of reinforced concrete), these will remain peppered in the landscape for centuries. Of course there's also access and wiring. Wind farms are large scale, long term, industrial sites. There are not forests or fields... Covering a country in wind farms (which is literally what's needed to get decent reliable-ish production) is all downsides with a single upside: electricity is renewable with no emissions. Very far from being ideal or even a first choice.
- chopin 4y agoWhat would be the first choice? Nuclear is no option in Germany.
- mytailorisrich 4y ago> Nuclear is no option in Germany. Well, at least you're acknowledging that this is political and ideological, which is always a hindrance on these issues. Nuclear would be a good option. In term of wind, I think offshore wind is much preferable to on-land wind, but I suspect that Germany is also limited there.
- majewsky 4y agoEven if the entire German populace woke up tomorrow in full support of nuclear power, that would not change the immediate issue. We need a lot more electrical energy very soon to phase out combustion as a power source across all sectors (from residential heating to mobility). Waiting for 10+ years for nuclear reactors to be constructed is not a viable solution. As an example for that "10+ years" timescale, you can look at our direct neighbor France: They are now starting the planning phase on new nuclear reactors that are supposed to go on-line in 2035-2037, so 13-15 years from now. And that's in a country that's a) pretty much all-in on nuclear and b) already experiencing power shortages (that are only offset by the ability to import power from other countries such as Germany). There was surely a time where constructing nuclear reactors went quicker in Germany, around the 1960s-1970s, but that's because we had an experienced industry at the time. Once you stop building specific things like this for some time, you lose the specialists required to do so.
- 7952 4y agoA beautiful landscape will still be beautiful.
- ekianjo 4y agoJust like beaches still look awesome when you build concrete resorts with no end on the coast?