3 ms·
"And no amount of training is a reasonable substitute for the autopilot with a habit of nosediving" If they would know that the system even existed then maybe
by giantg2 4y ago
"And no amount of training is a reasonable substitute for the autopilot with a habit of nosediving"
If they would know that the system even existed then maybe they would have known how to disengage it.
Yes, the design was flawed. Even then, you train for equipment failures because everything can break. It's hard to do that if your not even told that the MCAS exists.
The training aspect still squarely places blame on Boeing and the FAA for crearing/approving a design that didn't mandate additional training.
- dTal 4y agoMy memory is fuzzy here, but wasn't it the case that even with training, you only had a window of a few seconds to disengage the MCAS before the aircraft became unrecoverable? If you waited too long, it cranked the jackscrew to its extreme position, and there was no way to un-crank it with the MCAS disabled (i.e. MCAS had exclusive control over it). That seems like an unacceptably fragile failure mode to me.