3 ms·

It's not you; it's that pg has said many times (and I agree) that fragmenting the front page is a bad idea. We must all see the same front page to judge the sam

• DanielRibeiro 15y ago
  Interesting. However, many people already filter the first page, let it be by points, or by the twitter accounts: http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc20 http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc20 http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc50 http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc50 http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc100 http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc100 http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc150 http://twitter.com/#!/newsyc150 And from each filter, people auto-select things that interest them. Sometimes I only see a story when it is retweeted to me. And this you can't prevent. It lies on the fact that different people have different definitions of what "quality" means. Which is the core problem highlighted by linked blog post.
  • jvdongen 15y ago
    The front-page of HN is a filtered list in and of itself. And I for one actually like the result. Some people would like to see a different filter and thus create one, because they can. That is indeed not something you can, or should want to, prevent. But the fact that some people create their own filters is not a motivation to not tweak the HN front-page filter in such a way that the front-page matches the intended goal (pg's goal in this case, presumably adopted by the majority of HN readers, more-or-less codified in the guidelines) as closely as possible.
  • ThaddeusQuay2 15y ago
    "The core problem ... lies on the fact that different people have different definitions of what "quality" means." The user is not the problem. The user is the solution. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3170840 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3170840