4 ms·
> Republicans: mental health is definitely an issue that needs to be solved If this were true, they would have proposed legislation to fund healthcare.
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> Republicans: mental health is definitely an issue that needs to be solved
If this were true, they would have proposed legislation to fund healthcare.
- dotty- 4y agoHe's addressing each party, not describing each party's beliefs.
- jressey 4y agoThe commenter is comparing a core GOP belief: Minimal gun control with a fringe Democratic belief: Defund the police. Any comparison of the parties can't be done in good faith.
- bmmayer1 4y agoThis does not seem like a charitable interpretation of the point OP is trying to make.
- Bud 4y ago"Defund the police" is more of a Republican parody of Democrats than anything else. It's a Fox News slogan. No substantial portion of the Democratic Party supports this, or ever has. But it's a great way to lie about your political opponents to keep anything rational from being done about gun violence or other issues.
- zozbot234 4y agoThe slogans "Defund the police" and even "Abolish the police" were in fact quite common in BLM protests and the like. They're not something that Fox News just came up with to ridicule Democrats. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defund_the_police https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defund_the_police
- z9e 4y agohttps://rsc-banks.house.gov/democrats-push-defund-police https://rsc-banks.house.gov/democrats-push-defund-police Plenty of prominent Democrats quotes here that say otherwise.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoHmmm ‘Defund the police’ is what you see on the signs at democrat protests. When you get in a discussion, it’s not quite what they mean, but that just means it’s a stupid slogan where you have to redefine every word to get at what you mean. Human politics and all…
- thaway2839 4y agoI don't understand what you mean. It's very clear that Republicans don't actually believe that improving mental health or mental healthcare is actually a solution to gun deaths, but only use it as a distraction from improving gun regulations that are desired by over 80% of Americans, including a majority of gun owners. Democrats on the other hand actually do understand that mental health issues are a part of the gun problem, and therefore provide solutions to tackle it both by improving mental health care access, as well as improving background checks to prevent those with mental health issues from accessing lethal weaponry easily.
- buggythebug 4y agoIt is true - doesn't mean they're going to do anything about it, though.
- dylan604 4y agoOr increase the money spent on caring for unwanted babies given to adoption since that seems to be the only recourse they deem acceptable
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoWhat does “funding healthcare” mean in this context? I ask because, in my experience, most of the people on the left use the term healthcare with the implication of adopting ‘single payer, free at the point of service’ - something far too radical for Republicans to support.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt means any kind of idea to fund healthcare. Repubs have brought zero to the table other than cutting taxes. And cutting Medicaid expansion (reducing funding for healthcare) in Repub states. In general, “fund x” means a wealth transfer from wealthier people to poorer people to pay for “x”, and Repubs have no track record of this outside of military/police/security ventures.
- al_borland 4y agoWasn't the ACA essentially the Republican plan? I didn't follow it closely, but I remember hearing at the time that Obama basically went with their plan, as it was the only way he could get some kind of health care reform passed. If Republicans believe that healthcare for working adults is best covered by the private sector, then the government doesn't need to do anything to fund that. If the government did take it over, there is no guarantee it would include mental health aspects or if it would just expand sick care to all. There are a lot of assumptions that a government funded plan will be the exact plan everyone wants, but that is very unlikely, because everyone wants something different.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoACA is not the Republicans’ plan, they solidly voted against it. See Senate vote by state: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordable_Care_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affordable_Care_Act ACA only happened because of Democrats pushing for greater access to healthcare, but also had to heavily compromise to win the votes of a couple senators who had insurers’ interests at heart.
- 4y ago
- marcinzm 4y agoAs I understand it mental healthcare as it exists right now literally cannot handle a large influx of patients. Good mental health professionals are often no longer taking any insurance since the demand is so high and they can not deal with the hassle. So simply doing something like government insurance for everyone will not help the situation.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Good mental health professionals are often no longer taking any insurance since the demand is so high and they can not deal with the hassle. Everybody deals with hassle, they just need to get paid for it. People that need mental healthcare have no money to pay for it. Why would smart, capable people go to work in a field where the pay is not commensurate to quality of life at work? Simply doing something like paying people in mental healthcare competitive wages would help. Why would it not? Money serving to incentivize is the basis of our society.
- marcinzm 4y agoGiven that the US already has the highest health spending per capita I feel dumping more money into it is a horribly inefficient idea. At some point you run out of people to tax to get that money from.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoThis defeatist attitude is why only wealthy employed people have access to good mental healthcare right now. We can't throw our hands up in the air and claim it's impossible because there's more than 1 problem. We have to fix both problems.
- marcinzm 4y agoIsn't that the point of the original comment that started all this? You can't simply shove a band aid on top of the mental health problem and expect it to magically get better in a year. This is a complex problem that will require a complex long term solution which will itself take a while to show results.
- bko 4y agoGovernment healthcare (medicaid/CHIP and medicare) have gone up consistently over the decades (especially medicaid, even as a percentage of GDP). [0] The US spends more than any other country on public health care per capita than any other country in the world. Over 50% more per capita public expenditure than the runner up Norway. [1] I don't know if money is the problem [0] https://www.crfb.org/papers/american-health-care-health-spending-and-federal-budget https://www.crfb.org/papers/american-health-care-health-spen... [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/283221/per-capita-health-expenditure-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/283221/per-capita-health...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat could be 95% spent on extending 80+ year olds lives for 6 months. But pay for mental healthcare workers is bottom tier, especially since the government does not have an incentive to properly reimburse work done for poor people. Certainly, there are huge issues with laws around involuntary commitment to mental institutions also and the legal costs there, but I figure the first step is creating the quality mental health institutions in the first place. It is also possible this is simply an intractable problem (I think the needed expenditures are far too big to be politically palatable), so we will just trend towards a situation where those that can afford to, erect walls and security and whatnot around their lives, like other countries with large gaps in poor and rich.
- arcticbull 4y agoThe government takes all the worst 40% of customers (the poorest and the old) out of the pot, socializes them - leaving the free market to profiteer on the customers who need the least care. The generally healthy 26-65 year olds should be pooled in. Medicaid requires you basically give up your house - and most health plans normal people have come with deductibles too high to actually use. So poor folks don't seek preventative care until it's too late, pushing up prices for everyone. The whole thing is unconscionable, and the price tag you point to is a function of massive structural inefficiency and not something to be proud of. Canada provides healthcare to 100% of the population for half the per-capita cost. Norway, 66% of the per capita cost. There is no true free market for healthcare, anywhere. A free market requires voluntary agreement between buyer and seller, but regional monopolies saying 'pay up or I'll let you bleed out on the floor' ain't it.