3 ms·
"Don't aircraft have more or less standardized controls and displays?" Commercial pilots (and military) are required to train and qualify on a particular aircr
by giantg2 4y ago
"Don't aircraft have more or less standardized controls and displays?"
Commercial pilots (and military) are required to train and qualify on a particular aircraft before being allowed to fly it. Controls can differ, but it's generally the difference in flight characteristics/handling that is the difference. Although we can see that the different computer related controls and lack of training were a factor in the Max crashes.
- ncmncm 4y agoThe main cause was completely insane specifications. With a reasonable design the plane would not have become uncontrollable under any possible sequence of events, training or no, familiarity or no.
- giantg2 4y agoTrue, but we live in an age where we we trust our lives with computers so that we can do things we couldn't do otherwise. Flight control computers are necessary for most new commercial and military aircraft because they're fly by wire or can be uncontrollable by nature (Max, V22, etc). We're at the point that the FAA and people in general don't care about an inherent instability if the computer can fly it.
- ncmncm 4y agoThe computer was not flying it. The computer was actively fighting the pilot, who was desperately trying to keep it flying, while the computer was forcing it to crash instead. To be clear: with the computer entirely powered off, the plane would have flown just fine. Not exactly like other 737s, but more like them than anything else.
- giantg2 4y ago"The computer was not flying it. ... the computer was forcing it to crash instead." Sounds to me like the computer was in fact in control of the plane if it causes it to crash. The "computer" is the MCAS system that sits between the pilot and the actual control surfaces. This is a fly by wire aircraft. Yes they could have turned the MCAS off and had it fly ok... if they even knew it existed. Although they weren't trained on the different flight characteristics they would experience with it off either. "with the computer entirely powered off, the plane would have flown just fine." Just to be clear, if you had a total computer failure or power down, a fly by wire aircraft could not function. I assume you are only talking about the MCAS.
- ncmncm 4y agoNo, 737MAX is not a fly-by-wire aircraft. The controls are physically connected to control surfaces via actual physical cables. But, the computer can yank on those cables, and it can also run the elevator trim up and down, and does. So, no, I am not just talking about "the MCAS". There is no such thing. That is a software feature that is part of the autopilot system, not any sort of hardware. They could have pulled the circuit breaker on the whole flight computer, and flown without it.
- dTal 4y agoAh yes, the training on what to do if the computer suddenly decides to crash your airplane out of the blue. I feel this framing mis-allocates blame away from Boeing and towards airlines. The MAX was specifically designed to not require a new type rating (they have now introduced one). And no amount of training is a reasonable substitute for the autopilot with a habit of nosediving into the ground because you were too cheap to build fault-checking into your AOA sensor subsystem (an oversight that should have made the MAX fail certification).
- giantg2 4y ago"And no amount of training is a reasonable substitute for the autopilot with a habit of nosediving" If they would know that the system even existed then maybe they would have known how to disengage it. Yes, the design was flawed. Even then, you train for equipment failures because everything can break. It's hard to do that if your not even told that the MCAS exists. The training aspect still squarely places blame on Boeing and the FAA for crearing/approving a design that didn't mandate additional training.
- dTal 4y agoMy memory is fuzzy here, but wasn't it the case that even with training, you only had a window of a few seconds to disengage the MCAS before the aircraft became unrecoverable? If you waited too long, it cranked the jackscrew to its extreme position, and there was no way to un-crank it with the MCAS disabled (i.e. MCAS had exclusive control over it). That seems like an unacceptably fragile failure mode to me.
- otikik 4y ago> Ah yes, the training on what to do if the computer suddenly decides to crash your airplane out of the blue. My expectations might be too high, but yes I expect their training to include something along those lines. Perhaps not "computer is trying to kill you" specifically, but "computer is off or malfunctioning". And I would expect the airplane to have a secondary/backup computer at minimum, these systems are supposed to be heavily redundant after all).