4 ms·
Actually, I don't even understand why this discussion of stability is at all relevant. Let's imagine the software was mature to the point where it literally nev
by mort96 4y ago
Actually, I don't even understand why this discussion of stability is at all relevant. Let's imagine the software was mature to the point where it literally never needed to change again; every last bug is squashed, every desired feature is implemented, the final version of the software is released. What exactly changes? TFA isn't primarily complaining that distros are packaging old versions, after all, but complaining that distros aren't doing enough QA. What would prevent a distro from linking a perfectly mature Bottles against an old version of GTK which has a bug which breaks Bottles?
So even if you have a personal definition of "beta" which categorises this software as "beta"... that's not even remotely related to the contents of the article.
- em-bee 4y agothe article doesn't go into detail about what the problems are. basically only these two sentences hint at the issue: many of these unofficial packages behave abnormally due to the nature of distribution models Bottles is a complex software that receives frequent updates and requires several dependencies at a minimum specific version to properly work but yes, you are right, arguing that bottles is beta seems besides the point. the problem appears to be that distribution packagers seem to think that linking bottles to old libraries is better than not having those bottles at all. if that is really the issue then i agree that this is not always a good idea. unfortunately the article is not clear about that. they could have said: do not package bottles unless your distribution can satisfy the exact version requirements that the bottles need. on the other hand, it is not true that old libraries are always a problem. which brings us to lack of QA to test if those backports actually work. again, the article just hints at the issue without spelling out the problem in detail. Our invitation is addressed to all those who are packaging Bottles incorrectly and/or do not provide adequate tests was added later. in summary though their request is reasonable. they do invite the packagers to work together and are not bitter or spiteful. let's hope that the packagers will listen.