10 ms·
Gates to students: Don’t try to be a billionaire, it’s overrated
- jwingy 15y agoMaybe it's because I didn't read the transcript of the talk, but it sounded like someone tried to ask him his opinion of money in politics and about money being able to buy influence and power, and unfortunately it looked like he failed to address that. If that's the case, that was a very disappointing missed opportunity by him I think.
- rythie 15y agoDo people really try to become billionaires? they start companies intending to become (multi-)millionaires and they do better than expected and become billionaires.
- scottkduncan 15y agoI think some people do set out with the goal in mind of becoming a billionaire and I don't think these people succeed. Like you said, I think people who do become billionaires are fixated on a more proximate goal (like starting a company that serves an important need) and end up exceeding their initial expectations.
- rythie 15y agoYou're right, I was working backwards from the life-stories of billionaires I've read about. There are surely a vast number that wanted to become billionaires before they were even millionaires and failed.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- breckinloggins 15y agoThis was an important thing for me to read. For the past several years I have been trying hard to deprogram myself of the "richer is better" mindset. Part of my problem has been the assumption that richer people believe themselves to be better than those less rich, to the point that someone like Bill Gates would think less of someone who "only" had a couple million dollars. I'm slowly weaning myself off of this damaging viewpoint. Something that has really helped have been TED Talks: it's awesome to see a room full of people - some of them hugely wealthy and successful - looking with absolute respect and awe at the presenter on stage talking about (say) the intelligence of crows. This answer by Gates really helps further cement the idea in my mind that, yes, having more money is great to a point, but in the end, what have you DONE with your life? What have you MADE that brings value to the rest of the world? Those are the kind of things that bring true respect to you, from the rich and non-rich alike.
- alexhaefner 15y agoI find it increasingly bizarre, day by day, that people are so fixated on money and not value, or meaningfulness. There's something about the way that money is discussed on HN that I find odd, but I haven't quite put my finger on it yet. Maybe it's that there can sometimes feel like a larger emphasis on politics or money than the things people have actually created... maybe. I'm not sure. I'm still working on figuring it out. Anyways, cheers to you!
- nickpinkston 15y agoTotally - the startup scene now seems to be trending more Hollywood than real meaning. There's so much awesome talent going to optimizing coupons, and not to improving the human condition.
- cynest 15y agoBut would they even be in the startup scene if it weren't for the profits? The chance at being the next x or y and making enough money to retire in luxury before the age of 30 is a nontrivial motivator when considering creating a startup. Looking at certain startups it's patently obvious that helping humanity was not a primary concern.
- slowpoke 15y ago> it's patently obvious that helping humanity was not a primary concern. But that's exactly what your parent is criticizing. There are genius people in the startup scene whose talents would be better applied to solve problems that actually matter, and not "optimize coupons".
- mattgreenrocks 15y agoThe problem is the inanity of the culture is glorified. Techcrunch is often just entrepeneurial porn. The community could do so much more if it first asked, "what does this do for people?" rather than "does it make us a billion dollars?" There's plenty of opportunity out there -- especially if you focus on delighting your customers.
- davidjohnstone 15y agoI'm not speaking from experience, but based on what I've read, this makes perfect sense. Happiness/life satisfaction doesn't improve with more money. You need enough money to be comfortable (i.e., a roof over your head and food on the table), but after that it has no effect. With $5M you buy an excellent house anywhere, send your kids to the best schools, drive a very nice car and have plenty of money left over for traveling the world. $5B will get you more houses, cars and a massive yacht, but why do you want those things? If you want it to beat your neigbours, then you'll always be unsatisfied since there'll always be people with more (except when you get to the level of Gates), but more importantly, people get used to good things. I have seriously impressive camera equipment. A few years ago I would have loved to own such high quality gear and would be using it all the time. But now, most of the time it sits on a shelf in my bedroom. And I imagine it would be exactly the same if I owned a Ferrari. Or a fleet of them. And then you have the super-rich people problems, foremost is worrying about their children. A well-meaning relation telling them that they'll never have to work a day in their life isn't going to do much for their drive to do something with their life. And finally, most rich people, whether they're worth tens or hundreds of millions, don't consider themselves financially secure, but they think they would be if they increased their wealth by 25%...
- qq66 15y agoWhat $5B gives you isn't more cars, it's the ability to finance anything that you find meaningful to you (public health for Bill Gates, movies with a message for Jeff Skoll, other startups for Reid Hoffman).
- hansy 15y agoA million dollars isn't cool, you know what's cool? Not a billion dollars. But yeah I always wondered what the threshold of wealth is when you literally can do anything you want without any thought to how much.
- pacaro 15y agoWithout trying to be fatuous, this depends on what "anything you want" means.... If you want to go to the bar and have a beer, you might already be rich. If you want to go to Mars, you might never be wealthy.
- robryan 15y agoYeah, there is definitely a limit to how much you can gain which is useful to spend purely on your own confort and entertainment. When you think of worthy projects you could contribute funds to though I don't think there is any limit to the amount of money that would be useful.
- hansy 15y agoAn excellent point. Money and philanthropy are a deadly combo.
- nickpinkston 15y agoYou know what's cool? Actually making a difference in this world. Fuck anything for money's sake.
- lincolnq 15y agoI posted this as its own link, but it's worth reposting here: Jaan Tallinn, founder of Skype, at the most recent Singularity Summit, talks about what to do with your money and how to make a difference. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84G6An1Ff2E http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84G6An1Ff2E
- Permit 15y agoAnyone know if there's a recorded version of the talk I could watch? It sounded like an interesting event.
- toxic_madness 15y agoI am a UW student who went to this talk. It was an interesting event. I think Gates' response to the student who asked how to be rich was the most memorable part for me. At the department website it says the talk will be archived, but the link doesn't seem to be active: http://www.cs.washington.edu/events/billg_oct27_2011/ http://www.cs.washington.edu/events/billg_oct27_2011/
- irollboozers 15y agoThere were plenty of TV cameras everywhere recording. It'll surface somewhere, likely on the UW CSE pages. For me watching the Kinect render the images so smoothly and immediately was pretty cool. Then again I was stuck 4 floors up and couldn't see anything.
- toxic_madness 15y agoYeah, I was on the 5th floor. I had a good view actually, but it was a little bit hard to hear, especially at the beginning while everyone was still moving around, trying to find a place to stand.
- irollboozers 15y agoI was surprised by how much he seemed to know about research happening here at UW. I ended up leaving shortly after he started the Q&A. The crowd was too fanboyish for me to handle.
- bgentry 15y agoI would primarily like to see/hear a recorded version of the talk because the "transcription" in the article is very tough to follow.
- jacques_chester 15y agoBen Elton explained the diminishing marginal utility of wealth in his book Stark in this fashion: "A man only has one stomach and one dick".
- nitrogen 15y agoAt the risk of overextending the idea (and definitely tongue in cheek), most everyone has two eyes and four limbs -- more money buys better-looking TVs and interior design for those eyes, and lots of fun activities for all those limbs, like really big yachts and private lakes.
- tonyedgecombe 15y agoI bought a new TV a couple of years ago and was most disapointed to see the same old garbage spewing out of it.
- simonsarris 15y agoReally? The world of film is vast and wonderful. Perhaps you needed new (different) content more than a new TV: www.criterion.com
- taylorbuley 15y ago“I can understand wanting to have a million dollars, it’s freedom, but once you get beyond that, I have to tell you, it’s the same hamburger." The declining marginal utility of money, defined
- Hitchhiker 15y agoI think the subtle value lesson he was trying to get across to these kids is to avoid making money ( i.e. a certain amount of it ) as the goal. Humble, self-effacing and smart answers. Oddly enough, I know very few people personally who set out with an exact locus on their future net-worth. Many, in my and the upcoming generation, aspire to have meaning over / along with money.
- dendory 15y ago....says the billionaire. Sorry but it's true.
- mrleinad 15y agoWell, if a poor person would say that, you'd think that he's trying to fool himself to accept his situation. I think a billionaire knows better about that.
- dendory 15y agoHe could give me a billion, and then I'll tell you.
- option1138 15y agothis I see such bad financial advice coming from those who obviously have never made money (shouldn't be surprising, I guess). And then when someone comes along who has made a lot of money, most people ignore what they have to say.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- plink 15y agoDid Boris Badenov or Tonto transcribe the talk? Me having trouble finding definite articles therein.
- bfe 15y agoBillionaire-scale conspicuous consumption is certainly overrated. But Gates's own example shows how wonderfully useful and fulfilling it can be to have tens of billions of dollars to mobilize in a really heroic cause, like working to eradicate various infectious diseases from the human experience. Just to get started, as long as we don't have clean water, plenty of food, proper healthcare, good education, meaningful personal freedom, and a well-functioning legal system for every human being in the world, cheap carbon-neutral energy, strong environmental protection and sustainable ecosystem conservation throughout the world, a cure for cancer, a complete genome and proteome and extended phenotype encyclopedia for all life on Earth, telescopes that can image Earthlike planets in other galaxies and the first stars to ignite in the extremely early Universe, robots crawling around under the surfaces of Europa and Enceladus and screaming through interstellar space toward Alpha Centauri and Epsilon Eridani, and human colonies on Mars and the asteroids and in the clouds of Venus, there will be plenty of interesting and valuable things to do for someone with tens of billions of dollars to throw at an ambitious project.
- hugh3 15y agoBut Gates's own example shows how wonderfully useful and fulfilling it can be to have tens of billions of dollars to mobilize in a really heroic cause, like working to eradicate various infectious diseases from the human experience. Maybe. But it doesn't particularly make me want to be a billionaire. If the main satisfaction you get out of having $100 billion dollars is giving it all away again, I'd rather let someone else make those $100 billion dollars and give 'em away. I figure Bill Gates made $100 billion and gave it away so I wouldn't have to. Thanks Bill!
- ehsanu1 15y agoThe point of making the billion dollars yourself is having a say in where it gets spent, not in "giving it all away" indiscriminately. Indeed, someone else might choose to just keep their billions in the family, for the sake of obnoxious levels of luxury. I'm sure there are some billionaires exactly like that. Anyways, the whole problem with trying to become a billionaire is that it's really a lottery. Sure, someone determined could probably earn a few million through effort alone, but becoming a billionaire requires a special mix of smarts, hard work, and luck. Mostly luck, disproportionately so. You can't just will yourself to earn billions.
- dbbo 15y agoI thought those "notes" were really poorly transcribed. Did the author really not have time to turn them into sentences? "Personally like to thank you for saving me winter algebra last year through Khan Academy investment." "Africa, 800m today will be bigger than China or India, 20M in 2040. In terms of stability, education." "Politics and role of web?" "Student question on negative impact of technology." I understand that he was just trying to get the gist across, but this is a news article. I would have rather read a more readable article an hour later.
- salvadors 15y agoThey probably had something else to do in that next hour. Lots of events like this go completely unreported precisely because the notetaker doesn't want to publish them until they get around to going through and tidying them up, which, of course, then never happens. Generally I'm happier with rough notes like this than if they don't get published at all.
- Eyght 15y ago"If you’re motivated to learn physics, read Fineman’s book." Made me shudder.
- zobzu 15y agoWhat he says actually is "get 1 million" "you don't need a billion" Well yeah. 1 million is pretty cool. It means you're free to do whatever you like. Cause hey i'd be pretty happy with 1 million. Or half that. Or quarter that. Or less.
- hugh3 15y agoA million bucks isn't much nowadays. Certainly not enough to retire comfortably in the US (yes yes, I know we've had a recent rash of articles on how to retire on $9000 a year or whatever, but I don't wanna live in a trailer park). I reckon you need at least $2 million, preferably $4 million, before you have enough money to never have to worry about money again. Still, I like to think that Bill Gates, having been a many-billionaire since the 1980s, has lost track of what the hell a mere million dollars is worth nowadays.
- Goladus 15y agoI think it's more likely he wasn't worried so much about gotcha-style internet scrutiny than making a general point about diminishing returns.
- deniszgonjanin 15y ago"But would you rather be underpaid or overrated?" - Jay-Z
- getsat 15y agoCan't knock the hustle.
- rdl 15y agoI'd rather have $10mm in personal wealth and control of $10b for interesting investments/research/etc., vs. a personal $100mm. Even $10b isn't enough to accomplish every large goal, but being able to do cheap LEO satellite launch (space cannon), real free trade zones internationally, and robotic space missions to mars, the moon, etc. would be amazing. Plus anonymous electronic cash, and trusted computing.
- sayemm 15y ago"Many systems in society are basically poorly designed algorithms." - awesome quote
- jholman 15y agoand a cute one: Student question: Thoughts on health care reform? Gates: I know a lot more about malaria and hash tables. I like hash tables and I dislike malaria.
- cavalcade 15y agoI wish more geeks become billionaires.
- sabat 15y agoIt's amazing how people forget. Bill doesn't have to worry about losing everything he has -- there's no way -- muchless worry about losing his house, getting fired in a recession, or how he's going to get his kids through college. Other than that, and the ability to go anywhere you want, do anything you want within reason, and stay as long as you like -- yeah, I'm sure being a billionaire is overrated.
- chadmalik 15y agoOne thing I think that probably sucks about being a billionaire is being nagged ALL THE TIME. A guy like Gates literally can't walk out the door and go longer than 2 minutes without somebody trying to get money out of him.
- wavephorm 15y agoBut if you try to become a billionaire, you'll be more likely to become a millionaire.
- mavelikara 15y agoBack in my home country, they say "Wish for a mountain, you'll get a hill"
- keithpeter 15y ago"Student question. What advice to someone like me to become someone like you?" "Gates: I didn’t start out with dream of being super-rich." Is it the transcription or has Mr Gates interpreted the phrase "someone like you" in a very narrow way?
- technogeek00 15y agoI was there and although the transcription does take some paraphrasing at points, this is a direct quote. It leaves out that before this the student said something like: "Before I ask my question I want to tell a little story: When I was growing up my parents and friends always asked me what I wanted to be and I would tell them I wanted to be the richest person in the world. Now you are here speaking to me so if A=B and B=C then A=C. Do you have any advice so that I can become someone like you" I assure you the A=B... part is not a random addition by me, she actually said this but I could not tell what it was based off of. Really besides a few questions from students that I felt were a little off topic, Mr. Gate's presentation was really fascinating and I am more than glad that I was able to attend.
- keithpeter 15y agoThanks very much for clarification, and yes, the student who asked the question therefore set the context for the reply. Sounds like a good event! If A = B and B = C then A = C is an example of a transitive relationship in Maths.
- basugasubaku 15y agoI think she is saying if I want to be B, and B is Bill Gates, then I want to be Bill Gates, therefore the question "how can I become like you, Mr. Gates?"
- technogeek00 15y agoThat makes a lot of sense, now that I think about it. Thanks
- ericsantos89 15y agoI would choose a product that touched a billion people over a billion dollar product any day.
- technogeek00 15y agoI would like to somehow find a way to thank Bill Gates for his talk I really enjoyed it. Though out of everything I would say my favorite line by him today was: "If you really want to learn something then get a book and read about it. If you want to learn more about CS read Knuth and actually do the problem sets after each section."
- daimyoyo 15y agoHe didn't say it was over rated per se, he said not to start in business with being a billionaire as your goal. If you create a great product, and a sustainable company the money will follow. There are few things that are consistent across the scores of biographies I've read, but that's one. Create value. The money will follow.
- trolleycar 15y agoThe 1% are on display! Thanks for your opinion, Mr. 1%. He can fix this easily: give his money away. Problem solved. What a troll Mr. Gates!
- kreek 15y ago"Student question. Computer science in education, starting even in elementary school. Good idea? Gates. Hmm. I think computer is a great tool, but if by computer science we mean understanding queing theory and hashing and database indexes, not sure. But knowing how to write a program, prime numbers by algorithm is very interesting test of whether I know prime numbers. What’s really necessary? Geometry? No, probably not. But certainly a level of complex thinking valuable to be exposed to. Statistics very important. Where computer scientist falls in hierarchy, I don’t know." Obviously elementary level students don't need to know queing theory etc. However, I think a lot games developers might disagree that Geometry is not really necessary. There's other uses as well I'm developing a web app for customizing products and I use Geometry every day.
- thomaslangston 15y agoI think geometry in elementary school is the idea being dissuaded, as compared to its prominence in high school today.
- ThaddeusQuay2 15y agoMy considered opinion is that the main reason Bill Gates is spending so much money, is to improve the world just enough to generate more users of Windows, over decades, in developing countries, thereby adding to Microsoft's bottom line, in the very long term, and in doing so, making more money for himself. Think about it: You have to raise living standards for people in untapped markets before they can buy your product, a thing which they now effectively consider an unattainable luxury.