3 ms·
The huge issue with all kind of military movies and stories is their relationship with what it means to be a man today. Society has a certain set of expectatio
by atoav 4y ago
The huge issue with all kind of military movies and stories is their relationship with what it means to be a man today.
Society has a certain set of expectations what men should be: Self sufficient, independent, strong, unfazed by tragedy, violence and struggle, constantly operational, hard working, putting others before yourself, stoic, ... Naturally these expectations collide with reality at some point or another. Naturally no man will feel like they meet that standard all the time, and even if they did, it might just be that it makes them unhappy to be like this.
The stories we like are often a reflection of who we like to be and which world we want to be prepared for. Imagine yourself to be an powerful fighter, an witty hero, the one who turns the tide is an old fantasy, and a powerful one. And those falling the easiest for these fantasy are typically those who struggle with their role as a man in the society they live in. Not feeling like a man, they try hard to imitate the things they think real men consist of. The easiest being carrying a weapon. The whole culture that developed around weapons is testament of that. People often say guns and rifles are "just a tool" — but you don't often see people posing on facebook pictures with a saw, a hammer or a screwdriver for some reason. So why do people feel the need to show that a weapon is part of their identity? It makes them feel like a man. Or at least: nobody can now question they are indeed a man, because everybody knows: The manliest thing there is, is a guy with a gun. But is it really?
Movies like these play into that unfulfilled need to feel like a man. They give men the idea there could be a meaning behind the meaningless, so they just carry on and do their thing. I don't think anyone in Jollywood has ill intentions when feeding those needs. There is an audience and they cater to it, with the side effect of strengthening the somewhat weird believe that wielding a weapon is what makes or breaks your gender identity. I have never really worried about being a man. Those who really do worry will call out other men as feminin or gay. Not being a man is their worst fear. And now they define a man ex negativo as the opposite of everything they think is feminin. Not a free man, but someone defined by the pressures of society.
For me as an man I see movies like these as a chance to reflect on what I think a man should or could be. And where I beg to differ with the rest of society on that topic.