4 ms·
The only use case I see to this is a non-electronic cold storage. Which is cool, but then do we really need all the fancy note cutting?
by godelski 4y ago
The only use case I see to this is a non-electronic cold storage. Which is cool, but then do we really need all the fancy note cutting?
- cyphertruck 4y agoExcept apparently you need to be online to send them the info after you cut the note. So its not really cold storage. What if their company shuts down? You can do cold storage by securing seeds on metal, such as titanium, or any robust material you like.
- ccamrobertson 4y agoNo, still cold storage. If the company shuts down you can use the plaintext user key to claim the funds from the note after January 3rd 2029.
- danShumway 4y agoHow are you doing time-lock encryption in this instance? Is it based off of a separate blockchain contract or is it one of the more traditional methods?
- ccamrobertson 4y agoOP_CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY in the multisig.
- godelski 4y agoBut why time lock it?
- ccamrobertson 4y agoThe time lock lets you optimistically circulate the note prior to the expiration date as even if previous holders know the user key they cannot use it to claim the Bitcoin alone.
- dgrove 4y agoSure, so you add it as part of the P2MS script but that doesn't solve the issue of every re-key costing money
- dgrove 4y agoIs this because you have a time-locked transaction to move the funds from the P2MS to a P2PKH? How does that work when it's "re-keyed"? Wouldn't each re-key move to a new P2MS and have a transaction fee associated with it as well as have a second transaction for the HTLC transaction?
- ccamrobertson 4y agoGifting cold storage is the main case we see here. Namely to someone who might throw out a printed private key. We spoke with many Bitcoiners who know that friends and family lost coins they gave them in the early days simply because a printed private key doesn't have much gravitas.
- dsr_ 4y agoWhat advantage does this have over a thick, pretty foil envelope with nice embossing telling people what the printed code/long barcode/micro-SD card inside is for?
- ccamrobertson 4y agoThe psychology of cash and how people hold and spend it is unique from any other physical financial instruments. They keep it safer and spend less than they would with credit cards or debit cards. A completely foreign object with a printed key might be kept safe -- but it isn't intuitive to do so. We heard multiple stories of people gifting Bitcoin at events like weddings only for private keys to be tossed out with cards.
- DonHopkins 4y agoWhy not just give the newlywed couple a dump truck full of coal, which is much harder to lose track of, so they can burn it to mine their own bitcoin?
- prox 4y agoIsn’t this also just a full circle, where we are back at printing a currency? I already have a secure, self custodial wallet, it’s called cash in my wallet.
- vkou 4y agoYeah, but when you give me that cash to buy a hot dog from me, how can I verify that I am the actual owner of the received cash?