4 ms·
I can only predict that both the people signing this letter and the crypto maximalists are going to be very disappointed that this will somehow be the end of al
by rvz 4y ago
I can only predict that both the people signing this letter and the crypto maximalists are going to be very disappointed that this will somehow be the end of all cryptocurrencies or the full adoption and dismantling of the current system with one cryptocoin being a reserve currency. An example of such is where the critics were screaming over the so-called NY bill on 'banning' of PoW [0], but it turns out that not only it doesn't affected PoS cryptocurrencies, but only affected PoW with carbon methods and not via renewable methods.
As for the same letter [1] being pushed by critics like Grady Booch, ghuntley, Molly White etc al. who many here know in the industry, we would like to also know the ones who are left blank like 'Darren W. Seng' and 'Stephen Diehl' who are the most extreme and prominent names arguing against crypto. But it turns out that they seem to be connected as C-level executives and co-founders of a private blockchain startup named 'Adjoint' [2] that appears to be in direct competition with public blockchains like Bitcoin, and especially Ethereum.
Again it's very strange to see why that wasn't mentioned in the first place and why it's only specifically 'public blockchains' and not all blockchains both 'public' AND 'private'? This critic [3] seems to attack both of them and doesn't see any difference to them at all. Any idea why all of that including something called 'nanocoin' was deleted and scrubbed off of the internet?
Maybe cryptocurrencies like Ethereum (which has smart-contract capabilities) are the reason why the folks at Adjoint are eternally at odds with the crypto industry and are dedicated every single day to totally getting rid of all cryptocurrencies? I'm sure many have tried going down this path and Seng, and Diehl seem to have already deleted their repositories and associations [3] with the whole of Adjoint to pursuing this long utopian conquest and bringing others on board.
These crypto-assets for sure will be regulated, but once again the goal of getting rid of all of them is a similar path that has been trodden by the free-software activists, anti-IoT activists, privacy activists, anti-AI activists and anti surveillance-capitalism activists etc before them and it has resulted in co-existence rather than a complete and total removal or outright total ban on what they were against. Cryptocurrencies are no different and will co-exist rather than wither away. In this latest push, at least they learnt their lesson with this failed petition in the UK [4].
[0] https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2021/A7389 https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2021/A7389
[1] https://concerned.tech https://concerned.tech
[2] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/adjoint-inc https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/adjoint-inc
[3] https://medium.com/@johny.codes/private-blockchains-even-worse-crypto-babble-scams-478e9c783b1b https://medium.com/@johny.codes/private-blockchains-even-wor...
[4] https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/601629 https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/601629
- FabHK 4y ago> it's very strange [...] why it's only specifically 'public blockchains' and not all blockchains both 'public' AND 'private'? There is nothing objectionable with private blockchains (except maybe the hype). They are permissioned, and don't need PoW. As such they're just another data structure: an append-only distributed database that certain people can append to (like git). It is neither wasting energy, nor a scam, nor an unregulated mechanism to move/launder money.
- rvz 4y ago> There is nothing objectionable with private blockchains (except maybe the hype). Is that why companies like Adjoint closed down their products and removed services like 'Uplink' and even basic projects like nanocoin, because maybe they also think that blockchains 'including private blockchains' in their case didn't work for them? So when a company partners with Adjoint and shut downs their solution, the whole chain is abandoned and rendered useless for these clients; assuming you have read the article [3] mentioned by another critic of all blockchains. > It is neither wasting energy, nor a scam, nor an unregulated mechanism to move/launder money. And Adjoint and others still shutdown their private blockchain offerings. Not all blockchains 'waste energy' or neither is the technology a 'scam' (some are but not all of them are) and some of them are compliant with standards like ISO 20020. Otherwise they all would have been destroyed a long time ago.
- ghuntley 4y agoRe: [1] if you are familiar with the developments in the Haskell space (https://medium.com/@kim_crawley/web3-nfts-and-cryptocurrency-are-dangerous-to-society-and-the-planet-and-computer-scientists-cf8932788c48 https://medium.com/@kim_crawley/web3-nfts-and-cryptocurrency...) where circa eight years back what we see today happened in Haskell - concerns for the future of language due to over exposure of risk. It makes more sense and you’ll understand beginning of the entire story arc better of how we got here today. Specifically re: [2] if you haven’t touched blockchain then your opinion is discarded but if you have touched blockchain then your opinion is also discarded. There’s no winning in this space. All critique is off limits because people are concerned that it will devalue their magic beans.