2 ms·
>Math Myth Conjecture: If one restricts one’s attention to the hardest cases, namely, graduates of top engineering schools such as MIT, RPI, Cal. Tech., Georg
by coldtea 4y ago
>Math Myth Conjecture: If one restricts one’s attention to the hardest cases, namely, graduates of top engineering schools such as MIT, RPI, Cal. Tech., Georgia Tech., etc., then the percent of such individuals holding engineering as opposed to management, financial or other positions, and using more than Excel and eighth grade level mathematics (arithmetic, a little bit of algebra, a little bit of statistics, and a little bit of programming) is less than 25% and possibly less than 10%.
So? How does this follow:
"Acceptance of the conjecture should have revolutionary educational implications . In particular, it undermines the legitimacy of requiring higher mathematics of all students. Such mathematics is actually needed by only a minute fraction of the workforce."
The conjecture (if it holds) just states that only few use higher mathematics.
Not that things wouldn't improve if more used them, and also if more "commoners" had a better understanding of basic mathematics (because even "basic algebra" and "excel" are way above tons of people)...
Starting with:
"The math myth is the myth that the future of the American economy is dependent upon the masses having higher mathematics skills".
And concluding that it is false, because "even the vast majority of scientists just use little and lower level math" is a non sequitur.