6 ms·
More cyclists are being killed by cars. Advocates say US streets are the problem
- dazc 4y agoI think it's people that are the problem. Car drivers will do the craziest things just to avoid being delayed by a few seconds and the well-being of anyone who gets in their way is of little consequence. As a pedestrian, ironically, one can also witness cyclists behaving in a similarly reckless manner.
- heretogetout 4y ago> I think it's people that are the problem. Sure, and people respond to incentives and the environment around them. Or in this case the lack of incentives (e.g. lack of fines, imprisonment). People can provide solutions, too, like adding better division between car and bike lanes and removing street parking entirely (which would have many other benefits).
- bediger4000 4y agoYes. Cars don't kill people, people kill people.
- ornornor 4y agoWhen there is no enforcement of road laws… chaos ensues. I lived in Ontario for a while. The easiest way to get away with murder there is to kill a cyclist with your car. “Didn’t see them, sun was in my eyes, woopsie” is usually a valid defense. All you get is a 500$ fine if the judge is really in a bad mood. In any case you walk away from it all. Speeding, running red lights, assault with a vehicle as a weapon etc aren’t even ticketed or brought in front of a judge anymore. And that’s been the case for years. Same goes for parking in the bike lane, it’s almost encouraged.
- heretogetout 4y agoFreakonomics published a podcast episode about this sort of thing: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-perfect-crime-2/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-perfect-crime-2/ > I don’t actually want to kill anyone. And I don’t endorse the idea of wanting to kill anyone. But if I did, and I were looking for a way to do it and get away with it, how would I do it? I’d wait ‘til they were outside, walking down the street, maybe crossing at the light … and then I’d run them over in my car. Now, I’d have to make sure that no one knew I was trying to run them over. But they’d be dead and I, especially in New York City, would in all likelihood go scot-free.
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoCyclists are much scarier to me as a pedestrian than cars are. Cars can be erratic but they stay on the road and, at worst, I can wait them out or otherwise almost always avoid them. On the other hand I've had cyclists zoom around me from behind on a sidewalk, surprise me from the front in the dark, or buzz me while I'm on a crosswalk and they're on the road and then they shout "sorryyyyy..." as they keep going. There's nothing I can do about that, it's just a roll of the dice.
- iancmceachern 4y agoYeah but the consequences are wildly different. Even a low speed bus hit will likely end one's time on earth. Not the same for a bike. I mean it's still not ideal, but it's on a different order of accident.
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoI hear you, but my actual experience is that car danger is avoidable. I can, if necessary, stand at a crosswalk and wait as long as necessary for the road to clear, or walk behind an idling car if I think it might accelerate into me, or keep walking until I reach a safer crossing. My few close calls have all been because I got sloppy. Buses especially are slow, easy to see and easy to predict. With bikes, there's not much I can do. I've had bikes pass me from behind at speed on the left on a sidewalk. If I had decided for whatever reason to step to the left at the wrong moment they'd have hit me full on. The worst street injury I've had was when a bike came at me from the front on a sidewalk in the dark from under some trees. By the time I realized it was a bike, it was too late, but luckily I lurched out of the way at the last second. I tripped over my feet and faceplanted at jogging speed but it could have been much worse.
- iancmceachern 4y agoI've personally been biking around Northern California for a decade. I've also been walking around for the same time period. In that time: As a cyclist I've been: Hit by 2 busses. On the hood of 3 cars because they hit me Almost hit by a dozen more. As a pedestrian I've been almost hit by a cyclist a few times. Just once, have a car hit you and end up on the hood of a car and then let's talk.
- h2odragon 4y agoThey've been putting in "bike lanes" on new highways around here for a while; the put some paint on what would've been the road shoulder otherwise and apparently get money from the feds for it. I'd rather ride a bike in the real lane, it'd be safer.
- IE6 4y agoShoulders along highways are also often full of debris (stones, glass, metal, etc.) and other miscellaneous road garbage which make them less than optimal cycling surfaces.
- aendruk 4y agoWhen I encounter bike lanes in this condition I stop for a moment and report it to the city using their mobile app. Typically it’s cleaned up within a few days, but more importantly this closes the feedback loop so it becomes possible for the city to address the problem in the long term.
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoI often walk next to a bike lane that has some freestanding posts separating it from road parking and then a road. Cars sometimes knock the safety posts into the bike lane causing a serious hazard to cyclists. I'll move fallen posts out of the bike lane and up against the curb but the situation is ridiculous. This is in addition to all the other debris you mention.
- Akronymus 4y agoUS stroads are definitely awful. Not just bikes did quite a few interesting videos on such things. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8F5hXqS-Ac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8F5hXqS-Ac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORzNZUeUHAM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORzNZUeUHAM
- midislack 4y ago
- FooBarBizBazz 4y agoI don't understand how "I love cars" has become the "conservative" position in the US, and "walkable cities" has become the "liberal" one. Like, consider StrongTowns. It's lowkey conservative, but it's all about walkability. And, y'know, fiscal responsibility. Or just think about all the examples of nice walkable cities. They're old. They were built before WW2. Where is the ideal? Europe. Or, colonial towns in the Americas. Colonial. You think this is far-left? It'd fit comfortably into my "imaginary" if I were a monarchist! Suppose I wanted to pepper the countryside with quaint English villages, each with a pub and a railway station. I could do that as a neo-Victorian. What is so "conservative" about cars? They're wasteful. They do nothing to cultivate personal virtue. They're big fat degenerate things, which have led to a degeneration of the built environment. They cultivate disability, like Rascal goddamn scooters. The most reactionary thing we could do would be to rip up all the highways that had been built in the name of "progress". The whole point of conservatism is to take inspiration from the past, and the past didn't have a bunch of debauched and fattening living-rooms-on-wheels. That's just Boomer-tier Republican nonsense, which is degenerate, not conservative. Conservatives don't need Big Gulp cupholders. The Sprawl fits into no traditional way of life, anywhere. Build a Shinto shrine to your ancestors. Don't insult them with parking lots and Walmarts. It's unworthy of you, and it's no inheritance for your descendants. It's just a heap of garbage.
- CompelTechnic 4y agoOne risk factor that makes me feel like the world is crazy is how terrible visibility is becoming in newer cars. A and B pillars are getting bigger and bigger, sightlines in the rear view mirror are getting worse too. There is a big problem with the fact that crash tests test for how well you perform in a crash, but not whether you can see what allows you to avoid a crash.