3 ms·
Study shows e-bike riders get more exercise than cyclists
- shlip 4y agoTitle is misleading. It should read "e-bike riders switching from private motorized vehicle and public transport get more exercise", which is less of a surprise. And real bikers switching to e-bikes still lose physical activity, though not as much as if switching to no activity. Which is still not much of a surprise. Quote from study page: "Therefore, this data suggests that e-bike use leads to substantial increases in physical activity in e-bikers switching from private motorized vehicle and public transport, while net losses in physical activity in e-bikers switching from cycling were much less due to increases in overall travel distance." Link to study : https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259019821930017X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259019821...
- withinboredom 4y agoThat checks out to me. I occasionally rent an ebike to go much further, faster, than taking public transport or my regular bike.
- belorn 4y agoThe study created three groups from the general populations; e-bikers, cyclists and non-cyclists. They then looked at which of the three groups had more exercise. That is a correlation study and as with all correlation studies done in history, correlation does not mean causation. I do agree that the title is wrong, but maybe for a different reason. E-bike riders don't get more exercise than bikers. E-bike riders have more exercise than bikers on average. The theory of the study is that E-bike riders on average uses their bike more often than cyclists, and thus they get more exercise. What the study does not say is that e-bikes are the best method for exercise.
- cma 4y ago> As it turned out, electric bicycle riders ended up slightly edging out pedal bike cyclists in terms of total exercise each week. The study’s authors largely attribute this to the increased amount of time that e-bike riders spend on their bikes, compared to cyclists and the longer-distance trips taken by e-bike riders. Could just be people more involved in a hobby who buy more expensive stuff at greater personal cost tend to practice the hobby more and not have anything to do with the "e" part of the bike.
- pornel 4y agoI think it's the opposite: e-bikes are bought for commuting in cities. They're cheaper than a car, and can even be cheaper than an annual ticket for public transport. They're quick (not stuck in traffic jams) and unlike a classic bike allow reaching the destination without getting sweaty. OTOH people who like cycling for the sake of it prefer real bikes that don't take the fun and challenge away with a wobbly torque sensor.
- victorstanciu 4y agoAs shlip already mentioned, the title is misleading, and not what the study concludes at all. That being said, I can put in my own two-cents-worth of anecdote on the subject. Since I converted[1] my bike to an e-bike, it's way more fun to ride, so I ride it a lot more. I definitely feel that I'm getting more exercise than before, because I'm still pedaling just as hard when I ride, only I go faster and farther. 1: https://tegowerk.eu/posts/trek-820-update/ https://tegowerk.eu/posts/trek-820-update/
- Doxin 4y agoI can heartily recommend anyone surprised by this to have a go on an e-bike. It's so much fun. I was pretty skeptical about the whole concept until I had a go on one. I had to refrain from going *wheeeeee*. I can easily see how the amount of added fun incentivizes cycling to the point of getting more exercise than on a regular bicycle.