7 ms·
I don't think you are overstating it. They have achieved massive amounts everywhere and swiftly wipe out entire companies with ease. But on the other hand, they
by Gigachad 4y ago
I don't think you are overstating it. They have achieved massive amounts everywhere and swiftly wipe out entire companies with ease. But on the other hand, they deliver products that are simply much better than what they replace. Apple completely obsoleted Tile with AirTags, but the airtags work so much better and users are better off for having them.
Are we really better off having competition for competitions sake rather than looking at what delivers the best outcome? Is there any value in preserving the business models of lesser products which are unable to compete on quality and features? Many of these businesses are on shaky ground anyway. BNPL companies are in a dire situation where almost every other financial institution such as banks, paypal, etc all copying their very easy to copy product.
- cowtools 4y agoI think you're leaving out the fact that the airtags system is part of an intrusive global surveilance botnet run by the likes of apple. But I suppose putting all this power in the hands of so few people is worth it if some clueless consumers can find their keys faster. Edit: This may sound ridiculous, but I seriously do not think companies like apple or microsoft have ever contributed anything of value to society. They are merely rent-seeking operations.
- ntSean 4y agoThat does sound ridiculous. They have market dominance because of the value that they offer. IBM is a great example of a company falling from grace; it happens all the time and can happen to Apple. Rent-seeking is a seperate issue, but no different to the Industrial Age and how Railway providers would do the same. We have inadequate governance.
- RNAlfons 4y ago> They have market dominance because of the value that they offer. This isn't true for Microsoft. They're a monopoly for most of the PCs on this planet and since they've been that for years now, changes to a different system which may still work out are hard and sometimes even impossible. Same goes for the mobile infrastructure for different reasons. Someone who "grew up" in the Apple infrastructure will have a hard time changing to Android and vice versa. However people within the Android infrastructure have at least a greater choice of hardware (and for a few of them choice of an Android version).
- theshrike79 4y agoExactly. Microsoft makes so completely bonkers amounts of money just from Windows and Office that they can use it to prop up other branches of their business that aren't generating profit yet.
- dijit 4y agoI love Linux, though my love is waning and I’m starting to see the light of BSD, so don’t get me wrong here… but what you wrote is just painful to read. Firstly, the “botnet” is afaik opt-in and it still has a semblance of privacy in its design. You might do well to inform yourself of how it works and how people have played around with it. Saying that Apple or Microsoft have not added value to the world is just absurd. For one thing; we would very unlikely be running windowing systems of any kind without them. I know that sounds absurd and like it was inevitable, but there was nobody else doing that at the time afaik. Second to that Apple did put a lot of effort into typography on computers, something nobody else was doing: so you can thank them for fonts. Microsoft made popular the idea of ad-hoc file sharing with samba/smb. Microsoft’s office suites, love them or hate them, literally run the world; I can’t even imagine a company that doesn’t interact with excel. Apple created (or at least heavily developed) CUPS; which remains the best way to print on every UNIX system I’m aware of. These are just a few examples, and sure, the history is mired with anti-competitive bullshit and forced attempts at pushing awful technology, but… Such blatant ignorance is unjustified on this forum. I’m honestly ashamed.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y ago> I can’t even imagine a company that doesn’t interact with excel. That's some very poor imagination. I run a company since 2007, haven't opened MS Excel even once since ~2006, ask me anything. Thing is, companies existed long before excel came to be, and will exist long after it will fade away to history.
- dijit 4y agoWhich bank do you use? They all use excel fairly extensively. Sometimes to disastrous effect[0]. Ever been audited? Nearly every auditing company is using excel. Even if you’re not using excel, it is the lingua Franca of spreadsheets. The next closes thing is a CSV which largely exists as an interchange medium. Excel is undoubtedly the world's most used and most popular database software even though there is a multitude of alternative more, efficient and frankly, even more, user-friendly solutions out there. It is frankly ubiquitous. I hate that this is true, but it is reality. [0]: https://www.efinancialcareers.co.uk/news/2020/10/excel-mistakes-banking https://www.efinancialcareers.co.uk/news/2020/10/excel-mista...
- blablablerg 4y agoIf Apple only made better products than their competitors, a case could be made, sure. The problem is things like the 30% shake out on transactions in other apps.
- dijit 4y agoWhy do you force me to defend Apple? Trotting the 30% tax as an Apple exclusive problem is extremely disengenuous. Sony, Microsoft and Valve also charge 30% (and have draconian agreements that are even worse than apples). It’s like Foxxcon all over again; when Apple does the same as everyone else, suddenly it’s a pariah. (For context I’m talking about the suicides at Foxconn due to the abhorrent working conditions, despite the fact that nearly every large OEM and board maker used them: Apple got the most shit). Sometimes I think the media might have a bit of bias against Apple for some reason. Not that the criticism isn’t justified, but it’s definitely not levied even handedly.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoSimilar as they may appear, the comparison between Steam and Apple's AppStore is disingenuous.Valve doesn't prohibit developers from selling the app directly to customers and installing the app on their devices, bypassing the middleman. Apple absolutely locks down iOS devices and direct installation of anything is impossible (testflight and MDM options do not count). This makes these two appstores completely incomparable. Enrolling in one is voluntary, and is done by developers because it is beneficial to them, another one is extortion.
- dijit 4y agoAs far as I understand (I was only working in the same building as uplay/Ubsioft connect) there were rules about payment processing (ie; all games downloaded through steam have to use the steam payments api: this is all I can find on the matter at a glance: https://steamcommunity.com/discussions/forum/0/1755779919109939706/ https://steamcommunity.com/discussions/forum/0/1755779919109...) Second; while you can sell your program in other places, you may not charge differently than steam. Which makes a lot of sense but is quite hard to grapple with in reality. I think there are cheeky “letter of the law” ways of working around this but obviously Valve don’t want that and then look for other reasons to just drop your entire catalog at random (this was not done by Ubisoft, despite the title and article claiming that: https://gamerant.com/ubisoft-remove-game-steam/ https://gamerant.com/ubisoft-remove-game-steam/) After all; why go outside of steam if it’s not cheaper?
- sngz 4y ago> Apple completely obsoleted Tile with AirTags, but the airtags work so much better and users are better off for having them. not on android
- theshrike79 4y agoThere are no technical barriers on Android manufacturers adding AirTag support to their phones. The whole system is open. But they won't, because they'll lose face and control of the data.
- sngz 4y ago> AirTags are different from other Bluetooth trackers like Tile because they rely on Apple's U1 chip to provide complete functionality. Functionality is limited in iPhones that lack the U1 chip, and it's even more limited in non-Apple devices. You need an iPhone, iPad, or Mac to set up AirTags because they require the Find My app that's only available for Apple devices. You also need an iPhone, iPad, or Mac to put AirTags into Lost Mode or find your AirTags on a map because both of those functions require the Find My app.
- Phenomenit 4y ago>Are we really better off having competition for competitions sake rather than looking at what delivers the best outcome? No but competition is the bedrock of the resource distribution philosophy at hand. If thats not the case then we should just let all companies consolidate in to a large monopoly because their products are superior to non existing companies.
- lwhi 4y ago> Are we really better off having competition for competitions sake rather than looking at what delivers the best outcome? Yes, because there's a fundamental cost to society. The cost v. benefit and what's actually an acceptable payoff is of course up for debate. However the day has been coming for a long time. It doesn't take that much in the way of critical thinking, to have been able to preempt that this situation would manifest. Many people have been asking for this for a long time. Let's hope it's not too late when the destructive effect of monopolies are taken seriously.
- dereg 4y agoAny discussion of monopoly must demonstrate harm to the consumer. Breaking up companies for breaking ups sake is not the spirit of antitrust law. In this case, I can argue that Apple is protecting us from crappy companies. Tile sold its business to Life360. Life360 sells users' location data to anyone willing to pay for it. What's the fundamental cost to society of keeping companies like Tile around? Maybe Life360 goes out of business. A bunch of engineers get hurt, some product people, marketers, accountants, administrators. 300 employees, laid off. That sucks, I agree. The effort of earning 27 million MAUs will be thrown down the toilet if they fail. That sucks. Now Life360 users must migrate to something that Apple offers. Is the product better? Yes. Does Apple have a fundamentally rivalrous relationship with its users? No. Does Apple sell users' data? No. I see no demonstration of consumer harm in this segment. Let's take a real hard look at the people harmed by Apple's monopoly. These are other monopolists of their own vertical who are incensed that they can no longer enjoy monopolistic rents. Furthermore, that company may go out of business. The people being put out of business are likely engineers who would have no trouble finding another job. I do not have sympathy for technologists. I do have sympathy for the tens if not hundreds of millions of people in America who struggle to make a living. What's the effect to them if we break up Apple? Nothing. What's the effect if we don't break up Apple? Apple at this point in their life has reached a point where its value proposition is more than just a luxury. They've created meaningful products creating meaningful changes in lives. Apple Watch has helped vulnerable folks (including me) get emergency services via fall detection, which leverages technologies and products made possible by Apple's "monopoly". Apple gives consumers the option to privately monitor their own home and premises through Homekit whereas other surveillance services brazenly monetize their services by selling data to law enforcement. In the case of Homekit, what do consumers gain if Apple had to break out its home automation unit? They may have to pay more for that standalone service or else have their data monetized in other ways. Is that good for consumers? Heck no. What's paying for those services now? Apple's "monopolistic" profits. I could go down the line with every one of Apples units and services. They've helped my family experience a level of richness that we've never enjoyed before. For as much as pockets of the tech industry grandstands about "monopoly" because they don't like IAP rules, actual people don't care because they have benefitted greatly from what this "monopolistic" entity has contributed to their lives. You're going to have a tough time convincing me that this would all be possible had Apple not consolidated many parts of the industry. > Yes, because there's a fundamental cost to society. Insofar as my non-tech family and friends see it, this "cost" to society has been more like a dividend. When Apple starts acting maliciously, I'll drive everyone here to your local Attorney General's office. Here's how I see Apple: Apple is Jupiter. It's the largest planet in the solar system. Is it terrifyingly large? Yes. Is it protecting me, Earth, from getting smashed by asteroids? Definitely. I like Jupiter.
- eternityforest 4y agoI'm mostly fine with monopolies that exist because nobody can make a better product. It's scary, but there's not much to be done about it. Unfortunately, Apple is not the kind of product I would actually want to use. They are still behind Android on many features, because the lock so much down, don't prioritize compatibility, etc. They also cost more, and you can't develop apps for them unless you also have a Mac. To any techie, that's a problem, especially when a MacBook costs more than anything else I've ever owned. iOS apps also seem to often cost a few bucks, despite free equivalents existing for Android. Perhaps because they are more expensive to make, or because they can't rely on a data collection business model, whatever the case pretty much everything seems more expensive. There are lots of reports that third party stuff is just a bit worse because of the privacy restrictions. The UI is non-customizable in a very annoying way, it's all based on gestures and shortcuts with many things hidden. Apple makes appliances more than computers. Android, Windows, and Linux all share a general idea of doing anything, in any scenario. With Apple you're never quite sure what they'll do. Anything beyond core phone use cases seems more like a bonus, and a lot of the exclusive features have to do with some other Apple specific thing. Plus, apparently, they don't have per app notifications, and some are saying that push notifications can be unreliable. There is essentially never a time when I want anything like a full do not disturb. So... I'd have to be interrupted every 4 seconds by crappy apps that spam notifications to avoid being unreachable? With Android, you feel like no matter what tech task you want to do, you can probably do it with an app. I don't get the impression Apple is really trying to be more than an appliance.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe fact that Android seems to fill all of your needs shows that there is viable competition and the market is still working fine. Most of the stuff you listed as an is things that others desire as a feature. And if that isn’t you, Android is a great alternative.
- astrange 4y ago> There is essentially never a time when I want anything like a full do not disturb. So... I'd have to be interrupted every 4 seconds by crappy apps that spam notifications to avoid being unreachable? Your solution is focus modes, which they spent rather a long time talking about in the keynote.