3 ms·
For better or worse, Hacker News is designed around the assumption that as participation in a thread continues, the quality of comments decrease over time, whil
by krapp 4y ago
For better or worse, Hacker News is designed around the assumption that as participation in a thread continues, the quality of comments decrease over time, while the likelihood of flamewars and antagonism increases. Thus, not having reply notifications to comments is an intentional quality control feature, suppressing engagement with a thread after the productive phase has likely passed.
It's been requested many many times - it's likely the most frequently requested feature - but the mods are adamant that they feel it would only have a net negative effect on the signal to noise ratio.
There are services that will do this for you, but beyond that, it's up to you to just keep track manually or else ignore anything that drops off your threads page.
- rektide 4y agoThe guidelines[1] clearly call for optimism: > Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. They also have other good debate practices: > Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. I see a lot of doubt & criticality across this site. I continue to feel like skepticism & scorn is broadly, not here but everywhere, cheap & plentiful. There's a kind of mono-mindedness that's convenient, but to dare to enter into the possibility that someone might be right is the mark of a real seeker, a real Hacker. Hackers never get far by assuming their beliefs are right. Anyone whose worked with systems know: the only way to progress is to question everything, repeatedly, to drum up data & examples, again & again. Ask ask ask, explore explore explore. Anyhow I think you're probably right that the lived experience is very much not as sunny as the guidelines requests; "behind every warning sign is a story"[2]. In this case uncountably many sad stories, of failure to honestly engage, dis-earnest barely masked popularity contents & self-justifications. And perhaps, as you say, not providing tools to keep the conversations going is a bit of a neutron-moderator for the ongoing chain reactions that might perhaps occur. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html [2] https://twitter.com/behindeverysign https://twitter.com/behindeverysign
- muzani 4y agoI think a lot of us suffer from "Someone on the internet is wrong!" syndrome. Frequently that person is me, but I will stand my ground and argue it until proven wrong. It's socratic, good way to learn, by questioning everything and letting others question you. But it's not a productive way to spend your days and nights, so I'm happy to let the conversations die after a few days.