2 ms·
I am aware that this website is predominantly web developers. But I’m personally quite disappointed in Apple for this move. That you can turn a browser into an
by dijit 4y ago
I am aware that this website is predominantly web developers. But I’m personally quite disappointed in Apple for this move.
That you can turn a browser into an app platform is not a success for browsers, it’s a failing in application distribution and native application tooling.
As a user I am not looking forward to the inevitable deprecation of native applications to PWAs; because when that happens I will not be able to turn off the push notification feature in the browser.
The same was true of JavaScript: it’s impossible to run a browser without JavaScript, what was originally progressive enhancement is now mandatory code execution; for many web developers that is not an issue at all, as a user: I shouldn't have to trust _all_ the code in the world that my browser can potentially pull in.
The sandbox, as complex as it is, is not infallible.
All of this consolidation on the browser frightens me, personally, and maybe you disagree, but honestly I’d like someone to be pushing back on the “faster horse”[0] requests from web developers.
0: reference to the famous quote by Henry Ford: “If I had asked my customers what they wanted they would have said a faster horse.”
Edit: expected result from the hackernews audience. But at least if I managed to convince one person that the browser shouldn’t do everything then it’s worth the karma sacrifice.
- endisneigh 4y agoIt’s literally opt-in. Given that this will be relegated to a small niche at best. Most people aren’t going to go into Safari advanced settings and toggle a flag. Native apps will always be necessary for something that actually needs it. If anything you should be happy about this as it’ll remove control of everything from Google and Apple exclusively. Funny you talk about consolidation…
- dijit 4y ago> It’s literally opt-in. For now, I’m not sure how that will be though, if it’s anything like adding a calendar then it’s just hitting “yes” on a prompt. > Given that this will be relegated to a small niche at best. How many apps on your phone want to send notifications? > Most people aren’t going to go into Safari advanced settings and toggle a flag. Assuming that’s how it will be enabled (and in perpetuity), I can’t see people doing that in the general case either and this the effectiveness of this feature is questionable. I think everyone in this thread assumes they can deploy PWAs in a generally available way that support push notifications over the web, if you have to go into safari settings (as in, the settings app) then people are not likely to enable it and the this you can’t use them generally. What I’m saying is: either this is easy to use for users, and it will be abused; or it’s hard for users and the actual usefulness of the feature is dubious.
- endisneigh 4y ago> For now, I’m not sure how that will be though, if it’s anything like adding a calendar then it’s just hitting “yes” on a prompt. It’s a safari flag in the advanced settings. I’ll never understand why people aren’t for more options. Why constrain yourself?
- dijit 4y ago> It’s a safari flag in the advanced settings. 1) that’s how betas are 2) you should read the last part of my comment where I discuss the usability aspect if that’s the case in future 3) are you sure that wouldn’t change? I would expect at some point it becomes opt-out because of #2.
- endisneigh 4y agoThere’s no point of speculating about hypotheticals. It’s been a flag since 15.3. It’s for power users only just like some of the WebRTC flags. Literally if you don’t want it then you don’t have to do anything.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dijit 4y agoWhat’s new now then? Surely its either not new and thus not noteworthy, as you imply, or it’s a new feature with a somewhat uncertain future for us mere mortals to fully know.
- endisneigh 4y agoIt’s the same feature. They stubbed out the flag and will be implemented in 2023, accessible via opt in via the same flag that already exists today. It’s not news worthy, which is why you have to scroll all the way down in a random list of new features to even find it. What is news worthy is the date, not the functionality.
- dntrkv 4y agoThe web is the only free platform we have. Everything done to bring it inline with proprietary apps is a good thing in my eyes. - web dev that prefers native apps most of the time
- dijit 4y agoI’m sure you didn’t intend to, but you’ve dismissed the work of F-droid and all of Linux. What you might intend to say is that it’s the only cross platform application distribution and execution environment that is free. But how free is it when one company controls 80%+ of the browser market and has the muscle to force standards?
- tomComb 4y agoYou lament Google's dominance of the web platform while listing F-droid? Google's dominance is unfortunate, but their support for the web has been vital in keeping it (sort of) competitive with the proprietary platforms, including their own. Google does this for financial reasons, of course, but it is still a good thing. And the web is still the only major client platform we have. We can still successfully object when Google promotes changes that are not in the platform's interest. Look how often Mozilla has thwarted Google proposals for the web, like their vision of webasm or web components.
- dijit 4y ago> You lament Google's dominance of the web platform while listing F-droid? pardon my ignorance, I don't personally use an Android phone, my understanding was that f-droid was essentially a FOSS app-store, built in order to solve distribution for non-playstore .apk's. I thought it wasn't a store that was in any way controversial on the android ecosystem.
- tomComb 4y agoYes, that is all correct. It is a good thing, but it is not a platform, it is an App Store for a mostly open source but still proprietary platform owned by Google.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoFor me, the biggest problem with the web as an app platform is that many of its advancements in the past 10-15 years have been heavily weighted towards giving total control to the developer rather than the end user. This isn't much of a surprise given the biggest players in this space, but it's disappointing nonetheless.
- brundolf 4y agoWhat? > the inevitable deprecation of native applications to PWAs If that were going to happen it would have happened already, at least on Android. The reality (and I say this as a web developer) is that it's harder to make mobile apps that perform and feel and look as good as native apps. The same is not true on desktop OSes, with their current SDKs and dev experience, which is the reason they've taken over there. > I will not be able to turn off the push notification feature in the browser I have no idea what this means either. You already have to opt-in to notifications for each individual web app, which is actually more than can be said for native apps. Web apps are assumed to be user-hostile, vs native apps that are usually just slightly user-hostile but get treated as non-hostile anyway. > I shouldn't have to trust _all_ the code in the world that my browser can potentially pull in How is this different from trusting all the code in the world that your native apps pull in? And before you say it's all been screened by Apple- there are various widely-used methods to dynamically load code into an app after the fact PWAs are especially important on mobile OSes because they put competitive pressure on the walled garden. xCloud only exists on iOS because of a web app. When I used a de-googled Android phone I was only able to use maps and access my bank account by using web apps. The web is an open platform that pierces the veil, and keeps the native ecosystems honest.
- dwaite 4y ago> How is this different from trusting all the code in the world that your native apps pull in? And before you say it's all been screened by Apple- there are various widely-used methods to dynamically load code into an app after the fact The difference is that organizations sign a contract to publish into the App Store, and do so under their legal name. This gives Apple the opportunity to be punitive in the face of abuse. They do not have this ability for the web (for practical and for regulatory reasons).