5 ms·
Counterpoint: M2 is a tock release, not a tick. This is pretty much the same behavior that ended up getting Intel shot in the foot: leaning too heavily on margi
by smoldesu 4y ago
Counterpoint: M2 is a tock release, not a tick. This is pretty much the same behavior that ended up getting Intel shot in the foot: leaning too heavily on marginal performance increases from process enhancement will bite you in the butt when your competitors get their tech on your node. Intel and AMD are both going to be on 5nm in 2023, Apple should be pretty worried if this is what they're fighting with. 3nm isn't even getting taped off until 2024 AFAIK, so this really does feel like Apple's "Skylake" moment, as far as desktop CPU architecture is concerned.
- nojito 4y agoOnly because it’s a COVID year.
- 7speter 4y agoMy understanding is that AMD coasts behind Apple’s process progress at tsmc, seeing as Apple invests the bulk of resources into tsmc’s cutting edge nodes. If apple hits a wall, well so does everyone else depending on the fruits of their r and d. Also, if Intel can keep up this time, and if tsmc/apple slouches, I wonder if there will be Apple silicon and Intel x86-64/risc macs/apppe devices on available simultaneously?
- dmix 4y agoApple doesn't really have to worry about competition too much for a long time, even if Intel and AMD get comparable watt/power levels for laptops, Apple isn't going to be using them for their products anytime soon. And people using Macbooks aren't likely to switch to Windows/Linux machines, even if there is a 20% better CPU. But really we've only had 2.5 released cycles so far. Not much to go by.
- arcticfox 4y agoI might be a very small minority but I'd personally switch back to Linux in an instant if there was something comparable to the M series hardware
- markmark 4y agoI'm considering getting an M2 Air even though I very much don't like OSX.
- sliken 4y agoAsahi linux has most things working, except the accelerated GPU. Just in the last week or so a triangle was rendered, so progress is has been made. Sadly while apple has 128 bit wide memory on the low end (66-100GB/sec on the mac mini and mba), 256 bit wide (200GB/sec), 512 bits wide (400GB/sec), and 1024 bits wide (800GB/sec). Nothing wider than 128 bits looks to be coming to standard laptops or desktops in the non-apple world. I don't really count HEDT chips like the threadripper pro, since they are very expensive and very limited, and burn many 100s of watts.
- criddell 4y agoAsahi Linux is, for me, the most interesting thing going on in Linux these days.
- sliken 4y agoAgreed. I'd likely have a studio today if the GPU port worked, but unless it comes out RSN I'd likely wait for the M2 based studio to come out. The chip has other magic inside as well. I'm hoping Linux continues to implement support for the MatMul instruction (not just vector multiplies), 16 trillion op neural engine, various encode/decode video accelerators, etc. I've heard vague references to compressed swap to help make the most of limited ram (m1 limit was 16GB).
- dmix 4y agoWhat package manager/distro will Asahi Linux be using/basing off of?
- viraptor 4y agoIt's based on arch, but there are already people who ported the necessary changes to nix and something else I can't recall. The idea though is that once things get upstreamed, any distro will work.
- gwbas1c 4y agoSpend a few minutes talking with someone who designs hardware. Often when they release something, there are TONs of incremental improvements that they just didn't have time to get to when a new product is released. I remember having a conversation with someone who worked on hard drives in the 80s. He got so ^%$^$# excited telling me about all the improvements he worked on between generations; they were mostly things like tighter calibrations, and refinements. Point being: Don't knock releases like this.
- FullyFunctional 4y agoIndeed, that "18%" improvement is almost certainly made up of very many 1% improvements (or more likely, many improvements that each only makes difference in some scenarios).
- reaperducer 4y agothat "18%" improvement is almost certainly made up of very many 1% improvements My guess is 18 of them.
- smoldesu 4y agoThis comment sounds like the exact same hopium I heard about Intel in 2016. I get what you're saying, and there are definitely smaller changes packed in here, but my point is that Apple's performance crown is looking mighty easy to usurp right about now. Hell, they even showed a graph with the i7 1280p beating the M2's single-core performance by ~20% at the WWDC today; they know they're on notice.
- mrtksn 4y agoM2 has a media engine, which was previously reserved for the higher end versions. Considering that M1 was already an overkill for the most tasks, I think it is a meaningful "tok" upgrade. Besides, I kind of expect the trend of ASIC to continue. Instead of having more extreme and extreme lithography, it kind of feels more appropriate to have computation specific developments.
- GeekyBear 4y agoAMD recently teased a ~15% single threaded performance increase for Zen4 when they will move from TSMC 7nm to TSMC 5nm. Apple just teased ~18% CPU increase while staying on TSMC 5nm. Sounds like they are doing just fine.
- seritools 4y agoAMD stated >15%, not ~15%, and this was the worst-case, conservative number, as they have clarified. The increased core frequency alone brings in around that number already. https://overclock3d.net/news/cpu_mainboard/amd_calls_its_zen_4_s_15_single-threaded_uplift_conservative_and_their_5_5ghz_clock_speeds_very_easy/1 https://overclock3d.net/news/cpu_mainboard/amd_calls_its_zen...
- fyzix 4y agoThat 18% is multicore
- drno123 4y agoMy understanding is that 3nm for Apple is coming in 2023. https://www.slashgear.com/833760/apples-3nm-processor-is-about-to-become-a-reality/ https://www.slashgear.com/833760/apples-3nm-processor-is-abo...
- Reason077 4y agoComing in 2022 for the iPhone 14 Pro line.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]