4 ms·
This seems like a good first step on shaving the US' 1st Amendment thin enough that in practice, it means nothing. "Opening up" libel laws some way, maybe maki
by bediger4000 4y ago
This seems like a good first step on shaving the US' 1st Amendment thin enough that in practice, it means nothing.
"Opening up" libel laws some way, maybe making truth not an absolute defense, or making intent a much bigger factor or much lesser factor, or doing away in whole or in part with that doctrine about "famous people", all would help limit what we now consider "free speech".
I'd suggest changing the way we treat speech about religion, if we're going down this path, too. Criticizing religious practice could somehow not be free speech. That would be a big slice off our current free speech environment.
A few years ago, a couple of states tried to outlaw "economic terrorism". I'm not sure what happened there, those efforts appear to have stopped, but that might be a good way to restrict the contours of free speech while still technically having free speech. Make criticism of business products or practices where you even hint at a boycott into harshly-punishable crimes.
- codefreeordie 4y agoThis decision was reached by an Australian court, and so has no real connection to US law
- bediger4000 4y agoWow! Thanks for the correction! But I think my plan would work in the USA better than it would in Australia. Australia, like the UK, isn't very religious, so shaving off "no religious criticism" from protected speech wouldn't fly there. But it definitely will in the USA.