4 ms·
"He designed them to refuse even to let users install their own choice of applications — and installing free (freedom-respecting) applications is entirely forbi
by outworlder 15y ago
"He designed them to refuse even to let users install their own choice of applications — and installing free (freedom-respecting) applications is entirely forbidden."
Uh... installing free software is forbidden by the GPL, not Apple. Since GPL forbids further restrictions on distributions, there's no way to legally install them in an Apple device, because of the EULA.
Since this is already forbidden by the GPL, for Apple it makes (legal) sense to not approve them in the first place.
EDIT: Removing comment about the approval process.
- ajross 15y agoThat's true, but sort of twists the point. The GPL is designed to preserve the freedom (in the sense the FSF has defined -- RMS is nothing if not consistent in that usage) of users to use and modify the software. The EULA and approval process deny that freedom. The net effect is that copyleft apps simply cannot be shipped for iOS, and that is indeed a restriction imposed by the GPL. But that doesn't make iOS software free, either. RMS isn't complaining that Apple dissallows GPL software. He's complaining that they dissallow redistribution of the software on the device even where the authors desire it to be redistributable.
- outworlder 15y ago> The net effect is that copyleft apps simply cannot be shipped for iOS, and that is indeed a restriction imposed by the GPL. But that doesn't make iOS software free, either. That is my point. They both have restrictions. RMS designed the GPL on purpose so that a third party is not able to place additional restrictions. Apple designed its devices so users can only install Apps by agreeing with the EULA first. One of them must relax the restrictions - which one depends on your ideology alone. I tend to side with RMS here > RMS isn't complaining that Apple dissallows GPL software. He's complaining that they dissallow redistribution of the software on the device even where the authors desire it to be redistributable. Eat your cake or have it. With a permissive license, you can install wherever you want, at the expense of "freedom" (for some definition of). Get a strong copyleft license and you cannot install it on some devices, but it will be forever "free". I feel it is shortsighted to blace the blame solely on Apple, while ignoring the ideological war as a whole.
- ajross 15y agoYou're still misinterpreting. RMS's goal is not merely getting GPL apps running on an iPhone. He wants the iPhone to allow redistribution and user-controlled software installation. Compromising on the license won't change that. The iPhone will still disallow freedom-respecting applications.
- outworlder 15y agoDoes a BSD license "disrespects" freedom, for instance? But this is all academic. RMS has shown that he will never allow compromises, no matter what.
- bzbarsky 15y agoYou can't legally get a BSD-licensed app from the App Store and then modify and redistribute it, last I checked. So it has nothing to do with the license and everything to do with the App Store EULA.
- Someone 15y agoTechnically, you can redistribute it, but not trough the App Store. That, in turn, means most people will not be able to actually _use_ the app you distribute to them. As I see it, the issue the FSF has with Apple's model boils down to the following: the FSF claims that being free should be an unalienable right of _all_ software. Apple, on the other hand, claims that _not_all_ software must be free. The two statements are in conflict. IMO, it is a matter of opinion which world view you prefer. However, it also is true that, historically, 'A or B is a matter of opinion' can evolve into 'A is evil, B is good', or even 'B is an inalienable right' (for an example, look at the treatment of prisoners of war over the ages) IMO, it is quite likely that, eventually, RMS will be found to be found 'right' in this discussion.
- parfe 15y ago"If she had just said Yes it wouldn't have been rape!" Apple restricts end user rights. I cannot believe you found a way to blame that on the GPL. I want a piece of software on MY phone. Apple says no. The GPL receives the blame? That makes no sense.
- tobylane 15y agoApple puts DRM on for the user's safety. GPL quite reasonably dislikes DRM, but if Apple's reasons are good, the developer still wants to have the app in the store, then the GPL is the blocker. There should be something between the GPL and the BSD licences, GPL with an exception for whatever DRM the first party agrees to.
- jhuni 15y agoThere is no good reason to have DRM malfeatures, on someone from a society as backwards as ours would believe something like that.
- outworlder 15y agoWell, assuming a sufficiently advanced society, our houses wouldn't even need keys. We wouldn't even have need for licenses to begin with. Therefore, we are very backwards indeed. That's something we have to take into account.
- srdev 15y agoI can think of a few good reasons, but none of that includes consuming data that I ostensibly own.
- mindslight 15y ago> Apple puts DRM on for the user's safety. Nope. Guess again! It'd be trivial to redesign the bootloader so it could flash any image from the USB port. This would make it easier for Apple techs to restore a known-good state (say if a new exploit was used to install a rootkit rather than one-click jailbreak) > There should be something between the GPL and the BSD licences, GPL with an exception for whatever DRM the first party agrees to. This is called BSD. There is no middle ground - either the end user can tweak the software running on their device, or they cannot.
- brlewis 15y agoRMS is very careful and precise about these things. When you think he is wrong, more likely it's you. There is plenty of GPL software available legally on Apple devices, particularly Macs. On iOS devices the conflict is the EULA only. The approval process has nothing to do with it. GNU/Linux distributions have approval processes too. More about how the EULA conflicts with the GPL: http://www.fsf.org/blogs/licensing/more-about-the-app-store-gpl-enforcement http://www.fsf.org/blogs/licensing/more-about-the-app-store-...
- outworlder 15y agoThat is a good point. I retract my statement about the approval process. I had read you link, but my memory failed me. The one about the EULA still stands.
- freyrs3 15y agoThat's a function of the user's choice to use a installation channel that requires a approval process, not the GPL itself. Anyone can download GPLd source code and compile it ( in theory ) on a Mac if they choose not to go through Apple's channels.
- sagarm 15y agoYou can't install software on your own phone without joining the iOS developer program, which costs $99/year. http://mobiforge.com/developing/story/deploying-iphone-apps-real-devices http://mobiforge.com/developing/story/deploying-iphone-apps-...
- phillmv 15y ago>Uh... installing free software is forbidden by the GPL, not Apple. Since GPL forbids further restrictions on distributions, there's no way to legally install them in an Apple device. Talk about cognitive dissonance. The whole issue at stake is that Apple's terms are too restrictive. That's the point they're making here. Of course it's legal for Apple to set whatever terms they desire. It's also shitty of them.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoHence the criticism of Apple for placing further restrictions on all software installed on their devices.