3 ms·
The F150 Lightning has a carbon footprint comparable to a Prius. Not every Lightning sold is replacing a truck, but in general they're replacing something cons
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
The F150 Lightning has a carbon footprint comparable to a Prius. Not every Lightning sold is replacing a truck, but in general they're replacing something considerably larger than a Prius.
And coal plants are being shut down at a very significant rate.
The number of ICE vehicles being sold annually is also going down.
- lozenge 4y agoThe US and every country continue to license new fossil fuel extraction, knowing that any carbon extracted will end up in our atmosphere, regardless of where the power plant is. Coal peaked, but gas and oil extraction are still growing fast.
- jeromegv 4y agoIf you look at the last decade, gas consumption has been going up even if the share of electric vehicle has been going up. Why? Because people with ice vehicles have been buying suv and pickups in higher percentage and driving more. So the average personal “car” consumption is up. I’m not as gloomy. I can acknowledge progress. But when it comes to cars, it’s been worse, not better. But at least now the technology is better and can hope for the curve to finally invert itself.
- _ea1k 4y agoWeird, I thought it was because gas cars (EDIT: This should say electric cars) only just recently approached 4% of total sales and are still under 1% of the cars on the road. Normal growth is enough to explain why that hasn't (yet) resulted in a net decrease. If the growth rate continues at 50+%, that will change in about 5 years, though.
- hihihihi1234 4y agoWhat? You meant to write "electric cars" in your first sentence, right?
- _ea1k 4y agoYes, I definitely did. Monday brain, I guess.
- Unbeliever69 4y agoJevon's Paradox - learned a lot reading The Ministry for the Future by Kim Stanley Robinson.
- guerrilla 4y agoThanks. I was trying to remember the name of that. Highly relevant and likely explanatory for at least some of what's going on. > In economics, the Jevons paradox (/ˈdʒɛvənz/; sometimes Jevons effect) occurs when technological progress or government policy increases the efficiency with which a resource is used (reducing the amount necessary for any one use), but the falling cost of use increases its demand, negating the efficiency gains.
- CyanBird 4y ago> but in general they're replacing something considerably larger than a Prius. You are conceding the point with extra words here Reality is that the amount of vehicles is increasing, and by rule of thumb 50% of the emissions released by vehicles come from their own construction, steel, copper, manufacturing, chemicals needed for the production Given the size of a f150, would you take the bet that its manufacturing cost co2 wise is lower than a prius? This is obviously, bypassing the fact that rather than having to buy a 0km vehicle instead someone could have bought a second hand f150 and therefore not strictly needed to increase the total amount of vehicles in circulation
- bryanlarsen 4y agoYour rule of thumb is from 2012, and is very wrong in 2022. A recent paper came out that determined that the production emissions of gasoline and electric vehicles are now equivalent. I can't dig it up and it hasn't been generally accepted yet, but the generally accepted number now is that an EV is net carbon negative after 6 months of driving. But that's for an electric car vs a fuel efficient car. An electric truck vs a 15 mpg gasoline truck will go carbon negative a lot faster than 6 months.
- bombcar 4y agoThe other poster is saying that what’s happening is there are MORE vehicles so carbon production continues to rise. That the real deal is figuring how to reduce the number of vehicles in total. Is the F150 Lightning better than commuting to work in a deuce and half? Sure. But it is not carbon neutral or negative except when compared to something worse - and there’s always something worse that could be compared.
- ncallaway 4y ago> The other poster is saying that what’s happening is there are MORE vehicles so carbon production continues to rise. I think people are looking at different derivatives. If you compare the rate of change of emissions, they do continue to rise as new electric vehicles are produced. But, the claim that an EV is more efficient than a regular truck is not a claim about the first derivative, but about the second. That is, in theory, an EV raises CO2 emissions less than the equivalent truck. That's saying the impact should be visible in the *2nd* derivative being negative, but not necessarily the first.