5 ms·
> ALL so called "green" technologies are either fake WTF? Let's take one example, the F-150 Lightning. When it replaces a gasoline truck sale, it eliminates
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
> ALL so called "green" technologies are either fake
WTF? Let's take one example, the F-150 Lightning. When it replaces a gasoline truck sale, it eliminates 150 tons of CO2 from burning gasoline, and about 80 tons of CO2 from drilling, refining and transporting that gasoline.
Sure, producing the truck takes a little extra energy, and electricity isn't carbon free in most places, but that doesn't come anywhere close to 200 tons of CO2.
- lozenge 4y ago>either fake or not impacting climate at all There is no climate benefit to opening a wind farm. The climate benefit comes when a wind farm causes a fossil fuel power plant to be shut down. When you look at what politicians and corporations boast about, it's always about adding. New renewables, new solar panels on our roof. Not about taking away fossil fuels. As an example, "carriers reduced their fuel consumption per passenger-kilometer by approximately 39 percent between 2005 and 2019 (pre-COVID-19), a compound annual growth rate of about 3.4 percent per year". [globally] - you can be sure the industry touts its increased efficiency. But globally, the emissions of the airline industry have gone up, meaning it's damaging the climate more than every before. https://www.eesi.org/papers/view/fact-sheet-the-growth-in-greenhouse-gas-emissions-from-commercial-aviation https://www.eesi.org/papers/view/fact-sheet-the-growth-in-gr... Even with your example - is the new truck going to travel more miles than the previous one? The US is still building urban sprawl by default. Does the owner use the pickup truck or, like most pickup truck owners, they could be use a smaller more efficient vehicle? As in the famous talk "Hans Rosling: the magic washing machine", we haven't done anything to actually reduce emissions. Yet we are sold a narrative of constant progress towards our climate goals.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe F150 Lightning has a carbon footprint comparable to a Prius. Not every Lightning sold is replacing a truck, but in general they're replacing something considerably larger than a Prius. And coal plants are being shut down at a very significant rate. The number of ICE vehicles being sold annually is also going down.
- lozenge 4y agoThe US and every country continue to license new fossil fuel extraction, knowing that any carbon extracted will end up in our atmosphere, regardless of where the power plant is. Coal peaked, but gas and oil extraction are still growing fast.
- jeromegv 4y agoIf you look at the last decade, gas consumption has been going up even if the share of electric vehicle has been going up. Why? Because people with ice vehicles have been buying suv and pickups in higher percentage and driving more. So the average personal “car” consumption is up. I’m not as gloomy. I can acknowledge progress. But when it comes to cars, it’s been worse, not better. But at least now the technology is better and can hope for the curve to finally invert itself.
- _ea1k 4y agoWeird, I thought it was because gas cars (EDIT: This should say electric cars) only just recently approached 4% of total sales and are still under 1% of the cars on the road. Normal growth is enough to explain why that hasn't (yet) resulted in a net decrease. If the growth rate continues at 50+%, that will change in about 5 years, though.
- hihihihi1234 4y agoWhat? You meant to write "electric cars" in your first sentence, right?
- _ea1k 4y agoYes, I definitely did. Monday brain, I guess.
- Unbeliever69 4y agoJevon's Paradox - learned a lot reading The Ministry for the Future by Kim Stanley Robinson.
- zeckalpha 4y agoThis goes back 50 years to 1972, when they realized that renewables don’t avoid peak oil, just delay it. The justification is delaying buys us time, but delaying means we are adding more years of fossil fuels into the atmosphere. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth
- cameronh90 4y ago> There is no climate benefit to opening a wind farm. The climate benefit comes when a wind farm causes a fossil fuel power plant to be shut down. In many countries, this is exactly what's happening. In the UK for example, gas and electricity usage has been declining for the last 15 years. Coal has been almost eliminated from the grid, and renewables now account for about 40% of generation, from less than 10% a decade ago. Overall carbon emissions are below 1890 levels. Obviously we have outsourced some of our emissions but there's very clearly a huge reduction that can't be entirely explained by that.
- eatmyshorts 4y agoIt's happening throughout Europe and North America. The United States has had declining per-capita carbon consumption since around 1970. Absolute levels, which include population growth, have been going down since around 2000. We're replacing high-carbon power sources (i.e. coal) with lower carbon power sources (i.e. nat gas) and carbon-based sources with renewable sources, with wind and solar now producing some 13% of the total energy consumption and 20% of domestic energy production, more than double the percentages from 2015.
- cruano 4y ago>There is no climate benefit to opening a wind farm. The climate benefit comes when a wind farm causes a fossil fuel power plant to be shut down. Or when it prevents a new fossil fuel power plant to open. No one is going to sell their old vehicles just because there's a greener version, but if all new vehicles are green you'll eventually phase down the old ones. You can't expect people to care overnight, much less to lose money because of it.
- bluGill 4y agoI looked close at replacing my current vehicles. A new EV minivan would cost more per month than gas in my wife's current van (which is paid for), but it won't last forever and the difference is not that much. Of course that assumes something that will work is available, in our case adjustable pedals a must (my wife is short) and nobody makes an EV minivan with them as far as I can tell. My truck is a little trickier. The F150 lightening would do everything I need a truck for, but I drive my truck so rarely (one fill up per year). too bad nobody will rent me a truck for what I want t truck for.
- lozenge 4y ago>Or when it prevents a new fossil fuel power plant to open. That's not a benefit, that's a loss averted. These claims are usually over egged as well for "net zero" calculations. Net zero against some hypothetical averted future, but in physical reality the emissions are still there heating the atmosphere. As an analogy, I can "prevent spending" by buying a coffee machine, bulk buying some products, etc. However, there are more ways to spend money than I can even notice, and I can pile up the "savings" but still find I have no money left at the end of a month to... actually deposit into my savings. I think it's a common experience. If production of fossil fuels is not decreased by regulation, then a drop in domestic demand means more is available to export. The export price goes down, encouraging the continued use of fossil fuels abroad. Another power plant is built over there and emits GHGs.
- mattnewton 4y ago> There is no climate benefit to opening a wind farm. The climate benefit comes when a wind farm causes a fossil fuel power plant to be shut down. Or when a new fossil fuel power plant is _not_ built, or when demand spikes but the renewable sources handle the load and make fossil fuels less attractive. We aren’t socially set up with the mechanisms to make this change overnight. Basically no society is, we have to move people there with a viable alternative to them going without energy, or they will find ways to burn the earth to keep warm as the previous generations of all of us have.
- tejohnso 4y agoProducing the battery takes a LOT more energy, and the electricity is MOST LIKELY not carbon free, so total creation and operation CO2 output EXCEEDS the CO2 output from the gasoline truck over most of its lifetime. Maybe we should provide (edit: sourced) data to back up our claims.
- heretogetout 4y agoThe person you're replying to did provide data, albeit without sources. Do you have data showing that these trucks result in higher CO2 emissions?
- CyanBird 4y ago> EXCEEDS the CO2 output from the gasoline truck over most of its lifetime. The combustion of a gas plant or of a coal plant is more efficient than the combustion happening in a internal combustion engine, a turbine on a gas power plant can reach 44 to 60%[1] , a thermal plant 33% to 49%, an internal gasoline combustion engine tops at 35% in an idealized state, which real performance between 20 and 29% Unless you have got strong metrics which quantitatively show this to be true, then it is not a claim that can be spouted easily [1] http://needtoknow.nas.edu/energy/energy-sources/fossil-fuels/natural-gas/ http://needtoknow.nas.edu/energy/energy-sources/fossil-fuels... [2] https://www.williamson.edu/2018/05/the-most-efficient-thermal-power-generation-plants-in-america/ https://www.williamson.edu/2018/05/the-most-efficient-therma...
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIf you're demanding numbers, where are yours? They're easy to find. gasoline truck: 1/15 gallons per mile * 17 pounds CO2 / gallon = 1.1 pounds/mile electric truck: 0.5 kWh per mile * 0.8 pounds CO2 / kWh = 0.4 pounds / mile That 0.8 pounds CO2/kWh number is the US average from 2020. It's predicted to halve by 2025. And I didn't include the numbers for drilling, refining and transporting the gasoline used, which are massive, and increase the 1.1 pounds/mile figure by at least 40%.
- TomSwirly 4y ago
- globular-toast 4y ago> Let's take one example, the F-150 Lightning Great example. Let's see. Compared to the previous model it is: bigger, heavier (like 150% the weight), faster, more powerful, more torque. More, more, more. Increased efficiency of internal combustion engines has not led to decreased fossil fuel usage. It has led to bigger and more powerful vehicles and increased fossil fuel usage. There is no reason at all to believe electric vehicles will be any different. People simply refuse to sacrifice anything.
- tzs 4y agoThat's a silly argument because the world is not now or foreseeably facing a problem with global massing, global speeding, or global torquing.
- TurningCanadian 4y agoThe size of the car does correlate with its likelihood to hit pedestrians. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2022/03/17/suvs-pickups-pedestrian-fatalities-rise/7075333001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2022/03/17/suvs-pickups...
- trgn 4y ago> People simply refuse to sacrifice anything. This is because of two things: (1) fetishization of size, weight, speed. This is modernism, a monomaniacal obsession with measurements, a very infantile mindset. (2) self-preservation; People are more inclined to buy bigger vehicles when they are surrounded by oversized death machines anyway. It's a textbook tragedy of the commons. This can never resolve positively in a bottom-up manner. It's a local maximum that will require top down intervention, or some serious soul searching.
- bombcar 4y agoAlso the larger vehicles are taxed lower so there’s perverse incentives on all sides. A scaled tax based on vehicle weight compared to number of seats or something would make the smaller cars more attractive.
- giantg2 4y agoDo we have a sustainable solution for 'green' roads? Or are we going to continue using asphalt and concrete? And of course there's the source of the electricity for charging. Those affect warming too. I wouldn't call it really green if it still relies heavily on non-green tech to operate. Maybe a step in the right direction, but the overall system it requires to operate in is still 'dirty', with no end in sight.
- JaimeThompson 4y agoWhile I do not know how much carbon is created during the recycling asphalt is nearly 100% recyclable.
- rsync 4y ago"... Let's take one example, the F-150 Lightning. When it replaces a gasoline truck sale, it eliminates 150 tons of CO2 from burning gasoline, and about 80 tons of CO2 from drilling, refining and transporting that gasoline." For some perspective, it is likely that the production of a full sized truck embodies 30-40 tons of carbon.