5 ms·
Why is it essential? I was in school a little over 5 years ago and no one received special training on Office. You were just expected to work it out since it is
by Gigachad 4y ago
Why is it essential? I was in school a little over 5 years ago and no one received special training on Office. You were just expected to work it out since it is obvious. Many students used Google Docs instead, I saw some use Libre Office, I used Latex. None of this was a problem. You just converted the file to pdf and sent it away. Even conversions to docx work fine since your documents are simple.
None of this seemed very consequential to me. Your choice of document editor meant little more than your choice of shoes. It doesn’t impact you in any way going forward and is trivial to swap later.
- boondaburrah 4y agoI got mandatory training in Microsoft Office as part of the state curriculum for highschoolers. I don't think basic training really promotes lock-in with Office suites. (well, except for Excel, but that's a programming environment) It's surprising how non-obvious office suites are, because I regularly see people in a professional setting who don't know how to use them well enough. However, I don't really think training in any particular office suite isn't transferable, since the major skill is knowing what the ruler, styles, and various line/page breaks are actually there for apparently. I had no trouble using LibreOffice or whatever, but people definitely don't seem to know the concepts of word processing well at all. This isn't their fault, as it does /kinda/ work even if you just keep slamming shit into the page until it's right. Forcing people to work it out on their own is just training people to put up with "I don't know, I got it to look right but if I put a space between these words my entire layout breaks 4 pages later." when they don't have to live like this.
- analog31 4y agoMy kids are in college now, so they went to high school recently. The school subscribed to Google Classroom, and students used Google Docs to work on assignments, often collaboratively. There was no systematic training, and no use of features beyond basic text editing. Nobody uses Google Classroom after they finish school, and most people can quickly adapt to any text editor. They already use multiple text editors if they interact with any online software. There's no use for fancy page formatting of documents that will be read once and never printed. If anything, Google and Microsoft tools have the advantage of being general purpose, even if they are closed source. This liberates students from "educational" software that is almost universally abysmal. Subjects like math were still being taught in relatively traditional ways, e.g., by pencil and paper. My main gripe was that you couldn't put Python on the school issued Chromebooks.
- einpoklum 4y ago> I used Latex. None of this was a problem I used LaTeX for years, and almost _everything_ was a problem. The moment I wanted to venture one bit beyond the obvious and typical, it's very crufty macro programming. The situation has improved somewhat w.r.t. packages supporting you in doing that, but still, "no problem" is certainly not how I'd describe it.
- wasyl 4y agoI think op meant that using different software (including LaTeX) was not a problem, not that LaTeX itself wasn't problematic
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nonrandomstring 4y agoWhat seems to be happening in the past 5 years is BigTech aggressively pushing into education. Get them hooked young. A sixth form (high-school) headmaster proudly told me how his school was not under the thumb of Microsoft, because his was a "Google Academy". I have no idea what that even means by the way - other than that money changed hands in a back room deal. Kids may not be told expressly "You must use Vendor X", but network effects and non-interoperability will pressure them in subtle ways. This is exacerbated when teachers ask students to submit course-work via proprietary vendor platforms. A departure from open standards and neutral tools, toward monopoly proprietary suppliers is obviously unacceptable in education. But the rationale, as always, is economic, and against a background of deskilling of educational ICT. Wherever I get to choose tools and direct students I pick the most universal, accessible, free and open source software I can.
- urthor 4y agoIt's also. Schools just plain old don't have much money. Big tech has an advantage going into schools because schools LOVE end to end contracts that do everything. No other vendors but Google and Microsoft are willing to fight over schools, because the margin is too low. Google and Microsoft however will, because they are vertical enough they can absorb the low margin.
- cestith 4y agoThey're willing to do this at low margin, zero margin, or potentially at a small loss. It's not just because they can absorb it. It's because mindshare is real. Having schoolchildren trained in your technology is a loss leader for the workplace contracts you're seeking from everyone from the corner store to the Fortune 500 companies.
- rvense 4y agoThe startup I work for in Scandinavia sells to education customers. As far as I understand, all schools here are either "Microsoft schools" or "Google schools".
- 4y ago
- ahmadmijot 4y ago> Even conversions to docx work fine since your documents are simple. In my day to day operation, converting pdf to docx is not a trivial task.
- kgwgk 4y agoHe meant converting whatever format is used to create the document to pdf _or_ docx. I doubt many people compose documents writing pdf files.
- BeetleB 4y agoTo be fair, converting pdf to any other format is not a trivial task. PDF has bigger interoperability problems than docx. I can collaborate with Word users using Emacs's org mode. I cannot do that with PDF.