3 ms·
As a comparison, Pentium 3 had 10 million transistors. Does that mean that in theory you could implement P3 CPU on this FPGA?
by zokier 15y ago
As a comparison, Pentium 3 had 10 million transistors. Does that mean that in theory you could implement P3 CPU on this FPGA?
- luu 15y agoYou could do a lot more than that, as there are multiple transistors for each gate (assuming static CMOS). My company uses FPGAs to for verification during development (because it takes months to get silicon back after tapeout, and it costs millions of dollars even if you only want one single test chip). We make chips that are much more complex than a P3. Friends of mine at other microprocessor companies have told me that they have a similar process, though some of them at larger companies use their own custom hardware for accelerated simulation, since you can't fit anything like a POWER7 or even a core i3 on a commercially available FPGA.
- rbanffy 15y agoI don't know if that would be practical, but both Intel and IBM can build wafer-sized FPGAs if they really need to. The standard wafer they use is around 30 cm, right?
- pilom 15y agoThere is a difference between transistors and gates. FPGA's implement gates (i.e. "and", "or", "xor", "not", but really they're all only nand). Generally on a standard processor, one gate is approximately 2 transistors (assuming a CMOS process). So theoretically this FPGA could implement approximately 4 P3's. 10 million transistors ~= 5 million gates. However, the process of implementing circuits in an FPGA isn't that efficient (processors can do a lot of tricks to get better than 2 transistors/gate. They can also do other tricks to do calculations with just transistors instead of gates and FPGA's can't). However given the 4x overhead, I would say, yes, theoretically an Intel engineer with a full spec and some really good VHDL (the programming language of FPGAs) skills could implement a P3 on this.
- ajross 15y agoFPGA parts don't model gates, actually. Their unit is a giant array of SRAM lookup table (two bits wide by 5 address bits I think?) plus some interconnect logic that you can "wire up" by setting more bits in other SRAM cells. They translate this into "gates" with some marketing cookery as the number of logic gates that would be required to duplicate the most complicated configuration. So when they say "20 million gates", they don't actually mean that any 20M-gate circuit can be built. It depends on what you're doing; some things (e.g. big logic functions) work better in FPGA logic than others (e.g. complicated wiring and bus architectures).