6 ms·
Just think, if the recent advances in longevity work out, we could have Putin and Trump around for decades more.
by Animats 4y ago
Just think, if the recent advances in longevity work out, we could have Putin and Trump around for decades more.
- strogonoff 4y agoAging is quite a sad prospect overall, but as long as everyone is subject to the same process it is a great equalizer of sorts. An unforeseen consequence that is often brought up regarding the philosophy of unlimited or greatly extended human age is that it would exacerbate all inequalities in a society. As it’s well-known, time is the biggest pyramid scheme of them all. On the day of Tiananmen massacre, it occurred to me that it would have even stronger repercussions at country scale. Taking democratic countries’ shift to the policy of non-involvement and combining it with hypothetical advancements that continuously extend Supreme Leaders’ ages essentially sentences generations of dictatorships’ subjects to hardship, exploitation and gaslit life under a kleptocracy. Add to that increased existential threat to democracy, since such a dictator never would have to deal with inefficiencies of internal power and knowledge transfer or spending resources on facilitating an honest voting process, infinitely building connections and spinning its webs around the remaining parts of the free world. One wicked old man interminably learning new ways to turn the world into a zero-sum game and win at it, as generations of servants come and go around him they are even easier to control.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tayne 4y agoThat’s like saying that one person will dominate the tv show survivor. In reality new cliques and alliances form all the time, power shifts and swirls as alliances coalesce and disperse. We will still have wars and disasters and things that no one person can control. Plus, people will still die just not necessarily from the disease of aging. I often notice that people resist something they are afraid of by thinking it will cause a disaster to change how things are. I think you are subconsciously afraid that it’s too good to be true. In reality it will be like penicillin or vaccines — massive improvement and not much else.
- strogonoff 4y agoYou may be thinking that this tech will automatically trickle down. There is infinite incentive to withhold it, whether by controlling access to it outright in a dictatorship or by letting it naturally be exorbitantly expensive in a market economy. Note that in thought experiments I mentioned it is considered to exacerbate inequalities even if it is distributed equally to all. A thought experiment that reflects reality a bit better would be one where the rich not only get more rich thanks to money dynamics (plus a vicious circle of theft and violence in case of dictators, who are the bigger concern) but also never die.
- tayne 4y ago
- strogonoff 4y ago> There are precisely zero things that were deliberately made to be more expensive than their intrinsic cost by a small group of “rich people and dictators” Setting aside the fact that 0) US healthcare is pretty much all “things being made more expensive than their intrinsic cost”, believing 1) the market in a democracy is not affected by information asymmetry and 2) a dictator-kleptocrat elsewhere even needs to manipulate prices hints at immense naivety on your part. > shut up If it’s my mention of the June 4th incident that triggered such reaction, I hope the Party pays you well enough to justify the stress that reading Western media must be to you. > you have no right to pose as some kind of intellectual And you have clearly run out of substance to present.
- tayne 4y ago
- hedora 4y agoThe Science Fiction work "Altered Carbon" takes this to its logical conclusions. Highly recommended (warning: despite the weird sex stuff)
- strogonoff 4y agoIs it the series or the book that you are recommending?
- mentos 4y agoYea I think of the Elves in Lord of the Rings. If a person has lived 200 years then they have lived long enough to see and understand the true costs of war.
- tayne 4y agoSurprised to see this take from you. We could also have your parents, grandparents, siblings, kids, grandkids not get sick and suffer terribly before being discarded like garbage. And we can keep all the amazing people who fight for good. Oh wait, that would mean we can’t stick it to some bad people, never mind.
- tablespoon 4y ago> Surprised to see this take from you. We could also have your parents, grandparents, siblings, kids, grandkids not get sick and suffer terribly before being discarded like garbage. And we can keep all the amazing people who fight for good. Oh wait, that would mean we can’t stick it to some bad people, never mind. I don't think you're thinking this through. Immortality plus "kids, grandkids" (without sci-fi spaceships or suicide/euthanasia) will pretty quickly lead to overpopulation and a lot of obvious problems.
- cestith 4y agoIf it leads to decades more time of fertile reproduction and productivity, it needn't do so. We'll still have some rapid diseases not related to age, and of course accidents. If some of our brightest minds have another 40 years at the peak of their scientific and engineering careers, maybe we'll have seasteading and urban hydronic/aquaponic/aeroponic food supplies figured out and affordable. Convincing people not to have another generation at 20 years of age would of course be the hard part.
- tayne 4y agoLet’s establish the fact. Nobody knows what the consequences will be. But overpopulation won’t be The outcome. Developed countries have a population die-off problem. In the US the birth rate has plummeted since the 70s and we are way below replacement. We desperately need more people. Tens of thousands of people die in car accidents alone every year. The geriatric population is exploding and we can’t take care of all of them. We need a cure for the disease of aging.
- tablespoon 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qgin 4y agoIf we're optimizing for the smallest number of bad people on earth, then yes definitely we should make sure all humans die ASAP.
- serf 4y agoI can't imagine the frame of mind wherein when i'm told that there is a way to stave off dying (a gross over-simplification of the article) -- our number one problem for the entirety of our existence -- and I am compelled to sour the news with a reverse "I wish they were dead" statement about my political enemies. Defeating death just feels larger than human politics, it reaches into the entirety of biology unlike who The Favorite Person is at the moment.
- saiya-jin 4y agoWell then you have weak imagination. No large dictator went out willingly, all who killed tens of millions thought they are on some holy mission for greater good and just squashing the enemies of this greater good. Death is great, frees up limited resources, removes old farts who think they know how future for everybody should look like without actually having a good reason why. Lets expand reasonably at least around out solar system first (meaning say >50% of human population not on earth), and then start looming into immortality. Show me 1 truly powerful person in the past who wasnt an arrogant self centered a-hole. We talk about enslavement of whole human race potentially forever in worst possible case. If that is something you can ignore, well I can't.
- tayne 4y agoShow me one truly powerful person who could have survived 30% of his subjects actively resisting.
- tablespoon 4y ago> Show me one truly powerful person who could have survived 30% of his subjects actively resisting. It's a lot easier for "truly powerful person" to keep "his subjects [from] actively resisting" than you seem to think.
- tayne 4y ago
- andrew_ 4y agoOr we could be treated to gems like this for decades to come.
- georgia_peach 4y ago