4 ms·
It's hard for me to know why I should care that Winer doesn't like the book. It's true that the book is not written by someone with a deep understanding of tec
by jgrahamc 15y ago
It's hard for me to know why I should care that Winer doesn't like the book.
It's true that the book is not written by someone with a deep understanding of technology, but this is mostly a story about Steve Jobs the man, and not technical detail. What comes through in the book is that Jobs was a very difficult and troubled person with a tremendous energy to try to do things 'right' (for his definition of right).
I've found it a very enjoyable read. Here you have a book written with the cooperation of a man who knows he's dying and wants to talk about his story. It's an interesting book because it's not a hagiography nor is Jobs making excuses. Early in the book he says straight up that he behaved poorly towards his parents and Lisa Brennan-Jobs and at the same time can't quite recall stiffing Woz out of money for the Atari work.
- davewiner 15y agoGlad you enjoyed the book. And of course there's no reason you should care what I think. Can't think of a single reason. :-)
- Tloewald 15y agoI like your suggestions for a more tech savvy bio, but like the grandparent I think Isaacson has done a pretty good job. I totally agree that so much of the story has become rehearsed myth that it's kind of annoying to see it regurgitated here and there although, to give one example, I think Isaacson does a great job of dealing with the relationship between Woz and jobs when so many others simply accept Woz's evolving "standard version".
- jseliger 15y agoRight. To some extent, the review is criticizing something Isaacson pretty clearly didn't set out to do—explain technology. Isaacson wants to look at Jobs's contradictions and paradoxes—the kindness and cruelty in a single package, indifference tempered by sudden engagement, a frequently binary worldview, the lack of consistency from the outside, the habits that we'd normally dismiss as bizarre, like dietary ones, that might also be tied to success. Now, I can understand why someone might not be interested in those things, but to me that doesn't invalidate the book. BTW, I started it and wrote about the first 50 or so pages here: http://jseliger.com/2011/10/24/the-steve-jobs-biography http://jseliger.com/2011/10/24/the-steve-jobs-biography . Note that the book itself is actually nicely and well-made; it feels like a Jobesian artifact, instead of the usual publishing industry pablum.
- davewiner 15y agoI didn't say you shouldn't read it -- I didn't even say I wouldn't finish it myself. I just said why it was painful for me to read it. And why the story is so well-rehearsed, and how the myth has replaced the actual events. So many people are reading so much more into what I wrote than what I actually wrote (and think).
- danso 15y agoCan you give any concrete example of where Issacson's apparently shoddy reporting has led to a well-rehearsed myth replaced the actual events? Instead of complaining about how non-insiders keep trumpeting up "bullshit", help shed light on the truth.
- danilocampos 15y ago> And why the story is so well-rehearsed, and how the myth has replaced the actual events. Your post would be much more valuable had you provided even one concrete example of this.
- tptacek 15y agoNeither can I. Could you perhaps be a little clearer?
- chugger 15y agoYou're just jealous no one's writing about you. :)
- davewiner 15y agoThat's it! You figured it out. Give that man a cigar! :)
- xpose2000 15y agoI have yet to read the book, but I hope to crack it open this weekend. So take what I say with a grain of salt. To me it seems like the reason this book may be hard to read for some people is due to the public persona of Jobs over the past decade. He was an icon for all things Apple. How dare this non-technical person speak of Jobs in this light!? Surely he feels this way because he "doesn't get it" and "doesn't get his vision". Seem familiar? Maybe that's the wrong feeling a person should have. Maybe he's just a brilliant man with flaws like everyone else. Maybe the real Jobs isn't what you pictured in your mind and this book is ruining your perception of Jobs. Edit: not sure when I hit reply on this comment, but this is a general observation to everyone.
- AllenKids 15y agoDave Winer certainly does not belong to the group you described. If anything he is too disenchanted, knows a lttle bit too much, and is too sure of his own version of the lore.
- idspispopd 15y agoThe thing I've found most interesting is the negative view of Jobs-elitism when it comes to the platform. "We can't just let anyone program for it" (or similar words). I happen to disagree with this point of view for consumer products. I believe the content should be curated, poured over and held to usability standards. That is the only way that we'll be able to empower ordinary people, people who aren't engineers, programmers, or have ample time to fiddle with the software. If Jobs wanted everyone to be able to use his devices, to make it a household item, then he was going to have to make it fool proof. Jobs recognised that cynical connection, he wasn't just being a cunt for the thrill of it. Coincidentally, if they weren't elitist on the development end, then they were being elitist on the consumer's side.