9 ms·
Google warns that rate limits, overage fees are coming to Maps API
- chrismealy 15y agoYahoo maps isn't bad, and as far as I can tell they aren't enforcing their limits.
- thomasgerbe 15y agoMeh. Google maps UI is by far better than Yahoo maps. That and the street view/bike maps/etc. are features that give it a nice edge over alternatives.
- aresant 15y ago" - the "JavaScript API or the static maps API will be capped at 25,000 map loads per day. - They will be expected to pay a fee of $4 per thousand loads in excess of the limit. - The cap is set to 2,500 loads for styled maps that customize the presentation. - After 25,000 loads, the overage fee for styled maps will bump up to $8 per thousand. " That is no joke, a $4 - $8 CPM on map loads means your app has to be doing substantially better than that, which is NOT an easy enterprise.
- rorrr 15y agoYeah, the pricing is absolutely ridiculous. At least there are alternatives: 1) Yahoo maps 2) Bing maps 3) OpenStreetMap 4) Nokia Maps 5) Cloudmade
- shashashasha 15y agoThere's also (I'm as surprised as you are) Mapquest. They have a whole host of open APIs now, built on OSM, and even have web services like directions/elevation: http://developer.mapquest.com/web/products/open http://developer.mapquest.com/web/products/open http://developer.mapquest.com/web/products/open/directions-service http://developer.mapquest.com/web/products/open/directions-s...
- tomkarlo 15y agoI believe Yahoo! is out of the maps API business as of September. http://developer.yahoo.com/maps/ http://developer.yahoo.com/maps/
- 7952 15y agoNot exactly. If you use 30,000 a day you will pay $20, or only $0.66 per one thousand. They are giving you over 9 million requests a year for free. Its not unreasonable to expect the profit from that to help subsidize the excess,
- jquery 15y agoSure, if you plan on staying small and never growing, this is fine. But you can't build your site for growth staring at the edge of an $4-8/CPM marginal cost (in addition to all your other overhead!). $4-8/CPM is far more than most ad networks pay. Perhaps Google is deliberately trying to get rid of most major GMaps users. If they follow through on this, they will be successful.
- fr0sty 15y agoSounds like they are trying to push their high-bandwidh users to enterprise pricing. The $10k/yr Enterprise licence works out to $27/day which breaks even with the incremental pricing at 58k visits/day.
- easp 15y agoIsn't $10k/yr just the starting price of the enterprise license, don't they have tiered pricing there too?
- v01 15y agoThere is tiered pricing. Per client basis... with large discounts for large volumes.
- mnutt 15y agoThe price I was quoted was actually $17k/year for 250,000 impressions. We asked for clarification, and the salesperson said yes, you only get 250,000 impressions a year. That's $68 cpm. With some pushback they increased it to 1M impressions a year, but it's still a bit ridiculous.
- jroseattle 15y agoThis has an MBA-in-charge smell about it. I'm not certain how many GMap implementations there are that exceed a 25k/day load, but my back-of-the-napkin guesstimation is <10% of all sites that use Google Maps. But, those are exactly the sites that I want using my maps, instead of Yahoo or Bing or some other provider. Unless there's something I'm missing, this seems penny-wise and pound-foolish.
- untog 15y agoThere's actually not a huge benefit to Google in my site using Google Maps instead of Yahoo Maps. There is a branding benefit for sure, but there are no links to Google services, no ads, or anything like that. I've been wondering for a long time when this would come- the processing (getting directions, geocoding, etc) and bandwidth (for map images) demands must be huge, with comparatively little payback. It'll be interesting to see how many big operations pay up, and how many switch. To an extent switching might be futile- if Google can't afford to keep the maps offering free, do you really think Yahoo can?
- draebek 15y ago> I've been wondering for a long time when this would come- the processing (getting directions, geocoding, etc) and bandwidth (for map images) demands must be huge, with comparatively little payback. I'm more thinking about the costs of developing the software and gathering the data. And also the perceived _value_ of the data, independent from its costs. Ever tried to buy the kind of data Google uses on their backend, with terms of use that would support the kind of services Google offers? Good luck--both with terms and then with pricing. Other companies have been charging a fortune for this data. > It'll be interesting to see how many big operations pay up, and how many switch. To an extent switching might be futile- if Google can't afford to keep the maps offering free, do you really think Yahoo can? Regardless of whether they can, with Google pulling back, don't you think Yahoo et al. will want to raise their prices?
- 7952 15y agoDon't forget the cost of the actual data. Remote sensing satellites are not cheap. Google Maps is heavily dependant on a few companies who provide the bulk of the data.
- randall 15y agoThey say the premiere service will be cheaper than the overage. http://www.google.com/enterprise/earthmaps/maps-compare.html http://www.google.com/enterprise/earthmaps/maps-compare.html Unfortunately, they don't list pricing in an obvious way.
- redstripe 15y agoI beleive it's 10K per year.
- septicmadman 15y agoYep http://www.google.com/enterprise/earthmaps/maps-faq.html http://www.google.com/enterprise/earthmaps/maps-faq.html
- easp 15y agoIt starts at $10K a year.
- alphamale3000 15y ago10,000$ per million page views per year. So it's 10$ per 1000, more than the 8$ or 4$ per 1000 that was announced. I don't know any big site that gets more than 10$ per 1000 pageviews with ads. It's insane!
- magicalist 15y agothat can't be right. the limits here get you 25k*365=9,125,000 views per year for free.
- alphamale3000 15y agoit is right... with the premier pricing. EDIT: fill in the form you'll get the pricing... 10k$ upfront for 10MM views: http://www.google.com/support/enterprise/bin/request.py?contact_type=gme#utm_campaign=en&utm_medium=et&utm_source=maps-en-home http://www.google.com/support/enterprise/bin/request.py?cont...
- lrfunk 15y agoThere are some incredible Google Maps mashups, but I wonder how many make enough money to pay Google. I sure hope this isn't too tall a hurdle for PadMapper.
- wensing 15y agoGlad we (Stormpulse) made the decision to build our own mapping system.
- arctangent 15y agoI will be switching. I quite like the Google Maps API but in my company we're just not able to pay for things with credit cards or in fact to pay for anything we don't know the cost of up-front (i.e. variable billing). We'll happily and routinely pay hundreds of millions to suppliers so long as we have a contract, of course. This is no doubt more of an indictment of my employer's internal processes and policies rather than Google, but it does mean that the "standard" maps platform I built will have to be re-written to use another source of tile data etc. But it does seem like this means I have some re-work to do :-(
- robin_reala 15y agoIs that not what Google Maps Premier is for? http://www.google.com/enterprise/earthmaps/maps.html http://www.google.com/enterprise/earthmaps/maps.html
- arctangent 15y agoI imagine so - I've already requested info. It will take my company literally months to push through a contract for something like this. Google will be required to tender, alongside other comparable services. I just don't see that happening...
- v01 15y agoIf your company is going to consume large volumes of mapcalls you will definitely need the tiered pricing which they do offer per client basis. It's possible to get 50% discounts of the $4 price (if you do more that 100,000,000 per year)
- arctangent 15y agoThe main problem is that my company (an executive agency of the UK government, effectively) can't enter into this kind of financial agreement easily, precisely because we have such a huge budget (numbered in the billions). Any contract we sign needs to be for a fixed price, rather than a variable amount. And amounts above a certain limit need to go out to competitive tender, which takes a long time. (I'm not sure Google or the other players in this space would even bother to tender anyway.) So the only option remaining is to rebuild the mapping solution using another technology to ensure continuity of service.
- pbz 15y agoSeems to me like Google has only two dials: free or expensive. For example, in the case of Google Apps, the jump from free to $50 per account / year is rather steep imo. $4 fee for each 1K over seems rather expensive. Anybody know the price range for the subscription?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ceol 15y agoI agree with you that Google's Apps pricing is steep, but I don't think they're marketing it towards the average guy who just wants a couple of email accounts for his personal site. I think they're marketing it towards businesses and schools who see $50/acct/yr as pennies compared to hosting their own email server, hiring a sysadmin (or telling their current admin to handle it), and then supporting that server all day, every day. I'm not a small business owner, though, so I don't know how much one would generally pay for email, or how much $50/person/yr is compared to the rest of the business.
- pbz 15y agoExactly, you're either small and use the free version or you're very big and $50/a/y is no big deal. There's nothing in-between. I know quite a few companies who would gladly pay something, even if the free version works for them.
- ceol 15y agoI'd like the option to maybe pay $50/yr for 20 or 30 accounts. I have a couple of sites that need more than 10 accounts but can't justify paying $50 per. But who knows? Maybe Google saw that most businesses use 15 or 20 email accounts, so if they offered something like that, they'd lose a lot of money.
- JonWood 15y ago
- ChrisLTD 15y agoI remember in the 90s when we lambasted Microsoft for cornering markets with free products (IE) so they could drive out the competition (Netscape) and eventually start charging for them when we had no other choice. Luckily that never really happened, Microsoft never started charging for IE. While Google isn't exactly doing that here, it's coming awfully close.
- acavailhez 15y agoI agree with that, it is quite similar to what they did with youtube and the unbearing amount of ad that one has to endure before watching a video now, after 5 years+ of making it available free of annoyance.
- abraham 15y agoUploaders of videos can enable/disable the inStream ads. They are not required by Google. http://www.google.com/support/youtube/bin/answer.py?answer=188038 http://www.google.com/support/youtube/bin/answer.py?answer=1...
- palish 15y agoI don't have to bear one second of Youtube ads. (Thank you AdBlock!) The "Shark Week" ad that literally screamed at me at 11PM was the straw that broke my mental back. I immediately installed AdBlock.
- cpeterso 15y agoSome video ads (on YouTube and elsewhere) can detect AdBlock and refuse to play the video.
- alphamale3000 15y agoWhen you can't innovate anymore, you increase your prices. After a few years, the company becomes a dinosaur loaded with cash... like Microsoft.
- 15y ago
- willfully_lost 15y agoReposted from other Maps thread Aren't the limits IP based? This page on Google's 'Geocoding Strategies' seems to say so: http://code.google.com/apis/maps/articles/geocodestrat.html#quota-limits http://code.google.com/apis/maps/articles/geocodestrat.html#... So as long as your call to the Maps API goes out client side, aren't you ok?
- lftl 15y agoI think the Maps API is different than the Geocode in that the Maps API requires you to grab a key here: http://code.google.com/apis/maps/signup.html http://code.google.com/apis/maps/signup.html So to avoid it in that sense you'd have to force every one of your clients to go grab an API key and input it.
- willfully_lost 15y agoLook at the note at the top of the page you linked, Version 3 of the Maps API doesn't require a key.
- mildweed 15y agoNot only does v3 not require an API key, as of Sept 28 (a couple days before the rate limiting went into effect) sending a v2 API key to v3 will cause the request to fail: http://groups.google.com/group/google-maps-js-api-v3-notify/browse_thread/thread/46666c2d61f8bf66 http://groups.google.com/group/google-maps-js-api-v3-notify/... Sounds like they're laying the ground work for v3 to use API keys again.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rohitkumar 15y agoShit! There are so many sites out there using this API. And many are totally dependent on it - location is the cornerstone of their model. Zaarly, Foodspotting, AirBnb, GetAround - every location-based P2P platform. I guess this was inevitable. But maybe we can switch to a different maps API? Google is so smooth though.
- sturadnidge 15y agoWhen spending $12bil on a second rate hardware company is cheaper than the legal cost of patent defense, things like this will happen.
- gcb 15y agoSo, does this mean they can't monetize ads on maps?
- alphamale3000 15y agoGoogle Maps is dead, long live OpenStreetMap!
- roblobue 15y agoOn reading this I wondered if this was meant to target Apple? I'm sure the Maps app uses over 25k API calls a day.
- schwanksta 15y agoProbably not. The guy who authored the blog post says that Google Maps use in Android apps won't be bound, I imagine the same would be true for iOS: https://twitter.com/thormitchell/status/129665976001236994 https://twitter.com/thormitchell/status/129665976001236994
- zone411 15y agoI'm really surprised that Google would make such a sudden change. I would've expected lower rates or allowing free use if AdSense ads are placed on the maps or on the same page. Such changes could've been easier to accept for many sites instead of making them look for alternatives. It appears that they decided that the branding effect of having the Google logo and copyright plastered on so many Web pages wasn't doing much.
- loceng 15y agoVisual candy for the world that people didn't know they wanted - but want. +1
- ajtaylor 15y agoAt $work we signed for the Premier agreement. We're paying more than $10k/year but it's still reasonable for the benefits it gives us. There are ways to keep your map views down when they aren't essential to the page. :)
- dannyr 15y agoHere's a Tweet from the Google Maps team: Google Maps API is still free! Just has a limit of 25k maps/day. That means pricing only affects the top 0.35% sites! https://twitter.com/#!/GoogleMapsAPI/status/129687373700276225 https://twitter.com/#!/GoogleMapsAPI/status/1296873737002762...
- ww520 15y agoIt's time like this that RMS Free Software message really stands out. Corporations will screw you eventually no matter how sweet they sound initially.